A Picture is Worth More Than 77 Text Tokens: Evaluating CLIP-Style Models on Dense Captions
2312.08578
0
0
Abstract
Curation methods for massive vision-language datasets trade off between dataset size and quality. However, even the highest quality of available curated captions are far too short to capture the rich visual detail in an image. To show the value of dense and highly-aligned image-text pairs, we collect the Densely Captioned Images (DCI) dataset, containing 7805 natural images human-annotated with mask-aligned descriptions averaging above 1000 words each. With precise and reliable captions associated with specific parts of an image, we can evaluate vision-language models' (VLMs) understanding of image content with a novel task that matches each caption with its corresponding subcrop. As current models are often limited to 77 text tokens, we also introduce a summarized version (sDCI) in which each caption length is limited. We show that modern techniques that make progress on standard benchmarks do not correspond with significant improvement on our sDCI based benchmark. Lastly, we finetune CLIP using sDCI and show significant improvements over the baseline despite a small training set. By releasing the first human annotated dense image captioning dataset, we hope to enable the development of new benchmarks or fine-tuning recipes for the next generation of VLMs to come.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This research paper evaluates the performance of CLIP-style models, which are trained on image-text pairs, on the task of dense image captioning.
- The authors find that CLIP-style models outperform traditional image captioning models, even when the captions are much longer and more detailed.
- The paper also explores the impact of pretraining CLIP-style models on various vision-language datasets and how this affects their performance on dense captions.
Plain English Explanation
CLIP-style models are a type of artificial intelligence that can understand the relationship between images and text. These models are trained on a large dataset of image-text pairs, allowing them to learn how visual information corresponds to language.
The researchers in this paper wanted to see how well CLIP-style models perform on the task of dense image captioning. Dense captions are much more detailed and lengthy descriptions of the contents of an image, going beyond just a simple caption.
The results showed that CLIP-style models are surprisingly good at generating these dense captions, often outperforming traditional image captioning models. This suggests that the rich visual-linguistic knowledge learned by CLIP-style models during pretraining can be effectively transferred to the task of producing detailed, informative captions.
The paper also explores how the specific pretraining datasets used for CLIP-style models can impact their performance on dense captions. By pretraining on a variety of vision-language datasets, the models were able to further improve their ability to generate high-quality, dense captions.
Overall, this research highlights the power and versatility of CLIP-style models, demonstrating their potential to go beyond simple caption generation and tackle more complex, detailed image understanding tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper "A Picture is Worth More Than 77 Text Tokens: Evaluating CLIP-Style Models on Dense Captions" investigates the performance of CLIP-style models on the task of dense image captioning. CLIP-style models are a type of vision-language model that are pretrained on large datasets of image-text pairs, allowing them to learn the relationship between visual and textual information.
The authors compare the performance of CLIP-style models to traditional image captioning models on the dense captioning task, where the goal is to generate detailed, multi-sentence descriptions of the contents of an image. They find that CLIP-style models are able to outperform the image captioning models, even when generating captions that are much longer and more comprehensive.
The paper also explores the impact of pretraining CLIP-style models on different vision-language datasets, such as CLIP-quality captions, Updating CLIP to Prefer Descriptions Over Captions, Benchmarking and Improving Detail in Image Captions, and Long-CLIP: Unlocking Long-Text Capability in CLIP. The authors demonstrate that pretraining on a diverse set of vision-language data can further improve the models' performance on dense captioning.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thorough evaluation of CLIP-style models on the dense captioning task, and the results are compelling. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations of their work. For example, they note that the dense captioning datasets used in the evaluation may not fully capture the nuances and complexities of real-world image understanding.
Additionally, while CLIP-style models demonstrate impressive performance on this task, the authors suggest that there is still room for improvement, particularly in areas like generating more coherent and contextually-relevant captions. Further research into culturally-aware image captioning techniques may help address this.
Overall, this paper provides valuable insights into the capabilities of CLIP-style models and highlights the potential for these models to excel at more advanced image understanding tasks beyond simple caption generation. The findings could have significant implications for the development of more sophisticated vision-language AI systems.
Conclusion
This research paper demonstrates that CLIP-style models, which are trained on large image-text datasets, are highly effective at generating dense, detailed captions for images. The authors show that these models outperform traditional image captioning systems, even when producing much longer and more comprehensive descriptions.
The paper also explores the impact of pretraining CLIP-style models on different vision-language datasets, finding that exposure to a diverse range of image-text information can further enhance the models' performance on dense captioning tasks. These findings suggest that CLIP-style models have the potential to serve as powerful tools for advanced image understanding and description, with applications in areas like visual search, content organization, and human-computer interaction.
Overall, this research represents an important step forward in the development of more sophisticated vision-language AI systems that can better capture the nuances and complexities of visual information.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
CLIP with Quality Captions: A Strong Pretraining for Vision Tasks
Pavan Kumar Anasosalu Vasu, Hadi Pouransari, Fartash Faghri, Oncel Tuzel
0
0
CLIP models perform remarkably well on zero-shot classification and retrieval tasks. But recent studies have shown that learnt representations in CLIP are not well suited for dense prediction tasks like object detection, semantic segmentation or depth estimation. More recently, multi-stage training methods for CLIP models was introduced to mitigate the weak performance of CLIP on downstream tasks. In this work, we find that simply improving the quality of captions in image-text datasets improves the quality of CLIP's visual representations, resulting in significant improvement on downstream dense prediction vision tasks. In fact, we find that CLIP pretraining with good quality captions can surpass recent supervised, self-supervised and weakly supervised pretraining methods. We show that when CLIP model with ViT-B/16 as image encoder is trained on well aligned image-text pairs it obtains 12.1% higher mIoU and 11.5% lower RMSE on semantic segmentation and depth estimation tasks over recent state-of-the-art Masked Image Modeling (MIM) pretraining methods like Masked Autoencoder (MAE). We find that mobile architectures also benefit significantly from CLIP pretraining. A recent mobile vision architecture, MCi2, with CLIP pretraining obtains similar performance as Swin-L, pretrained on ImageNet-22k for semantic segmentation task while being 6.1$times$ smaller. Moreover, we show that improving caption quality results in $10times$ data efficiency when finetuning for dense prediction tasks.
5/16/2024
Updating CLIP to Prefer Descriptions Over Captions
Amir Zur, Elisa Kreiss, Karel D'Oosterlinck, Christopher Potts, Atticus Geiger
0
0
Although CLIPScore is a powerful generic metric that captures the similarity between a text and an image, it fails to distinguish between a caption that is meant to complement the information in an image and a description that is meant to replace an image entirely, e.g., for accessibility. We address this shortcoming by updating the CLIP model with the Concadia dataset to assign higher scores to descriptions than captions using parameter efficient fine-tuning and a loss objective derived from work on causal interpretability. This model correlates with the judgements of blind and low-vision people while preserving transfer capabilities and has interpretable structure that sheds light on the caption--description distinction.
6/17/2024
Benchmarking and Improving Detail Image Caption
Hongyuan Dong, Jiawen Li, Bohong Wu, Jiacong Wang, Yuan Zhang, Haoyuan Guo
0
0
Image captioning has long been regarded as a fundamental task in visual understanding. Recently, however, few large vision-language model (LVLM) research discusses model's image captioning performance because of the outdated short-caption benchmarks and unreliable evaluation metrics. In this work, we propose to benchmark detail image caption task by curating high-quality evaluation datasets annotated by human experts, GPT-4V and Gemini-1.5-Pro. We also design a more reliable caption evaluation metric called CAPTURE (CAPtion evaluation by exTracting and coUpling coRE information). CAPTURE extracts visual elements, e.g., objects, attributes and relations from captions, and then matches these elements through three stages, achieving the highest consistency with expert judgements over other rule-based or model-based caption metrics. The proposed benchmark and metric provide reliable evaluation for LVLM's detailed image captioning ability. Guided by this evaluation, we further explore to unleash LVLM's detail caption capabilities by synthesizing high-quality data through a five-stage data construction pipeline. Our pipeline only uses a given LVLM itself and other open-source tools, without any human or GPT-4V annotation in the loop. Experiments show that the proposed data construction strategy significantly improves model-generated detail caption data quality for LVLMs with leading performance, and the data quality can be further improved in a self-looping paradigm. All code and dataset will be publicly available at https://github.com/foundation-multimodal-models/CAPTURE.
6/3/2024
Long-CLIP: Unlocking the Long-Text Capability of CLIP
Beichen Zhang, Pan Zhang, Xiaoyi Dong, Yuhang Zang, Jiaqi Wang
0
0
Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training (CLIP) has been the cornerstone for zero-shot classification, text-image retrieval, and text-image generation by aligning image and text modalities. Despite its widespread adoption, a significant limitation of CLIP lies in the inadequate length of text input. The length of the text token is restricted to 77, and an empirical study shows the actual effective length is even less than 20. This prevents CLIP from handling detailed descriptions, limiting its applications for image retrieval and text-to-image generation with extensive prerequisites. To this end, we propose Long-CLIP as a plug-and-play alternative to CLIP that supports long-text input, retains or even surpasses its zero-shot generalizability, and aligns the CLIP latent space, making it readily replace CLIP without any further adaptation in downstream frameworks. Nevertheless, achieving this goal is far from straightforward, as simplistic fine-tuning can result in a significant degradation of CLIP's performance. Moreover, substituting the text encoder with a language model supporting longer contexts necessitates pretraining with vast amounts of data, incurring significant expenses. Accordingly, Long-CLIP introduces an efficient fine-tuning solution on CLIP with two novel strategies designed to maintain the original capabilities, including (1) a knowledge-preserved stretching of positional embedding and (2) a primary component matching of CLIP features. With leveraging just one million extra long text-image pairs, Long-CLIP has shown the superiority to CLIP for about 20% in long caption text-image retrieval and 6% in traditional text-image retrieval tasks, e.g., COCO and Flickr30k. Furthermore, Long-CLIP offers enhanced capabilities for generating images from detailed text descriptions by replacing CLIP in a plug-and-play manner.
5/24/2024