PLA-SGCN: Protein-Ligand Binding Affinity Prediction by Integrating Similar Pairs and Semi-supervised Graph Convolutional Network

Read original: arXiv:2405.07452 - Published 5/21/2024 by Karim Abbasi, Parvin Razzaghi, Amin Ghareyazi, Hamid R. Rabiee

🔮

Overview

This paper focuses on improving the prediction of protein-ligand binding affinity (PLA) using deep learning techniques.
The key ideas are: 1) retrieving similar "hard" protein-ligand pairs to incorporate into the prediction model, and 2) using a semi-supervised graph convolutional network (GCN) to learn the relationships between these pairs.
The proposed end-to-end framework simultaneously retrieves similar samples, learns protein-ligand descriptors, constructs a similarity graph, and predicts binding affinity.
The method is evaluated on several well-known PLA datasets and shows significant performance improvements over comparable approaches.

Plain English Explanation

Predicting whether a ligand (a small molecule) will bind to a protein is an important task in drug discovery. Recent deep learning-based approaches have focused on developing new feature extraction networks or incorporating additional information like protein-protein interaction networks.

This paper takes a different approach. It first identifies "hard" protein-ligand pairs - those that are similar but have different binding affinities. It then uses a semi-supervised graph convolutional network to learn the relationships between these hard pairs and use that information to improve the overall binding affinity prediction.

The key idea is that by focusing on the hard cases, the model can learn more nuanced patterns that lead to better predictions. The framework automatically retrieves these hard samples, builds a similarity graph between them, and then uses that graph structure to train a more powerful prediction model.

Technical Explanation

The proposed approach has three main components:

Hard Sample Retrieval: For each input protein-ligand pair, the method retrieves similar "hard" pairs - ones that are structurally similar but have different binding affinities. This is done based on a manifold smoothness constraint.
Graph Construction: A graph is automatically constructed where each node represents a protein-ligand pair, and the edges represent the similarity between pairs. This graph encodes the relationships between the hard samples.
Semi-Supervised GCN Prediction: A semi-supervised graph convolutional network (GCN) is used as the task prediction model. It takes the protein-ligand descriptors and the constructed graph as input, and outputs the binding affinity prediction.

The key innovation is the integration of the hard sample retrieval and graph learning components into an end-to-end deep learning framework. This allows the model to jointly optimize the feature extraction, graph construction, and final prediction steps.

The method is evaluated on four well-known PLA datasets (PDBbind, Davis, KIBA, BindingDB) and shows significant performance improvements over baseline deep learning approaches that do not incorporate the hard sample retrieval and graph learning components.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for the value of focusing on "hard" protein-ligand pairs in PLA prediction. By retrieving and leveraging the relationships between these challenging cases, the model is able to learn more nuanced patterns that improve overall performance.

However, the paper does not provide much detail on the specific algorithms used for hard sample retrieval and graph construction. It would be helpful to have a clearer understanding of how these components work in practice.

Additionally, the paper only evaluates the method on four datasets. It would be useful to see how the approach generalizes to a wider range of PLA prediction tasks and datasets.

Finally, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or areas for further research. It would be interesting to explore how the method could be extended or improved, such as by incorporating additional sources of information or exploring alternative graph construction techniques.

Conclusion

This paper presents an innovative deep learning-based approach for protein-ligand binding affinity prediction that leverages the relationships between "hard" protein-ligand pairs. By automatically retrieving these challenging cases and modeling their similarities using a semi-supervised graph convolutional network, the method is able to achieve significant performance improvements over comparable techniques.

The key insights from this research could have important implications for drug discovery and development, as accurate PLA prediction is a critical step in the process of identifying and optimizing potential drug candidates. The proposed framework offers a novel way to tackle this challenge by focusing on the most informative and difficult cases, which could lead to the discovery of new drug targets and more effective therapeutic agents.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🔮

PLA-SGCN: Protein-Ligand Binding Affinity Prediction by Integrating Similar Pairs and Semi-supervised Graph Convolutional Network

Karim Abbasi, Parvin Razzaghi, Amin Ghareyazi, Hamid R. Rabiee

The protein-ligand binding affinity (PLA) prediction goal is to predict whether or not the ligand could bind to a protein sequence. Recently, in PLA prediction, deep learning has received much attention. Two steps are involved in deep learning-based approaches: feature extraction and task prediction step. Many deep learning-based approaches concentrate on introducing new feature extraction networks or integrating auxiliary knowledge like protein-protein interaction networks or gene ontology knowledge. Then, a task prediction network is designed simply using some fully connected layers. This paper aims to integrate retrieved similar hard protein-ligand pairs in PLA prediction (i.e., task prediction step) using a semi-supervised graph convolutional network (GCN). Hard protein-ligand pairs are retrieved for each input query sample based on the manifold smoothness constraint. Then, a graph is learned automatically in which each node is a protein-ligand pair, and each edge represents the similarity between pairs. In other words, an end-to-end framework is proposed that simultaneously retrieves hard similar samples, learns protein-ligand descriptor, learns the graph topology of the input sample with retrieved similar hard samples (learn adjacency matrix), and learns a semi-supervised GCN to predict the binding affinity (as task predictor). The training step adjusts the parameter values, and in the inference step, the learned model is fine-tuned for each input sample. To evaluate the proposed approach, it is applied to the four well-known PDBbind, Davis, KIBA, and BindingDB datasets. The results show that the proposed method significantly performs better than the comparable approaches.

5/21/2024

On Machine Learning Approaches for Protein-Ligand Binding Affinity Prediction

Nikolai Schapin, Carles Navarro, Albert Bou, Gianni De Fabritiis

Binding affinity optimization is crucial in early-stage drug discovery. While numerous machine learning methods exist for predicting ligand potency, their comparative efficacy remains unclear. This study evaluates the performance of classical tree-based models and advanced neural networks in protein-ligand binding affinity prediction. Our comprehensive benchmarking encompasses 2D models utilizing ligand-only RDKit embeddings and Large Language Model (LLM) ligand representations, as well as 3D neural networks incorporating bound protein-ligand conformations. We assess these models across multiple standard datasets, examining various predictive scenarios including classification, ranking, regression, and active learning. Results indicate that simpler models can surpass more complex ones in specific tasks, while 3D models leveraging structural information become increasingly competitive with larger training datasets containing compounds with labelled affinity data against multiple targets. Pre-trained 3D models, by incorporating protein pocket environments, demonstrate significant advantages in data-scarce scenarios for specific binding pockets. Additionally, LLM pretraining on 2D ligand data enhances complex model performance, providing versatile embeddings that outperform traditional RDKit features in computational efficiency. Finally, we show that combining 2D and 3D model strengths improves active learning outcomes beyond current state-of-the-art approaches. These findings offer valuable insights for optimizing machine learning strategies in drug discovery pipelines.

7/30/2024

Improving generalisability of 3D binding affinity models in low data regimes

Julia Buhmann, Ward Haddadin, Luk'av{s} Pravda, Alan Bilsland, Hagen Triendl

Predicting protein-ligand binding affinity is an essential part of computer-aided drug design. However, generalisable and performant global binding affinity models remain elusive, particularly in low data regimes. Despite the evolution of model architectures, current benchmarks are not well-suited to probe the generalisability of 3D binding affinity models. Furthermore, 3D global architectures such as GNNs have not lived up to performance expectations. To investigate these issues, we introduce a novel split of the PDBBind dataset, minimizing similarity leakage between train and test sets and allowing for a fair and direct comparison between various model architectures. On this low similarity split, we demonstrate that, in general, 3D global models are superior to protein-specific local models in low data regimes. We also demonstrate that the performance of GNNs benefits from three novel contributions: supervised pre-training via quantum mechanical data, unsupervised pre-training via small molecule diffusion, and explicitly modeling hydrogen atoms in the input graph. We believe that this work introduces promising new approaches to unlock the potential of GNN architectures for binding affinity modelling.

9/23/2024

One-step Structure Prediction and Screening for Protein-Ligand Complexes using Multi-Task Geometric Deep Learning

Kelei He, Tiejun Dong, Jinhui Wu, Junfeng Zhang

Understanding the structure of the protein-ligand complex is crucial to drug development. Existing virtual structure measurement and screening methods are dominated by docking and its derived methods combined with deep learning. However, the sampling and scoring methodology have largely restricted the accuracy and efficiency. Here, we show that these two fundamental tasks can be accurately tackled with a single model, namely LigPose, based on multi-task geometric deep learning. By representing the ligand and the protein pair as a graph, LigPose directly optimizes the three-dimensional structure of the complex, with the learning of binding strength and atomic interactions as auxiliary tasks, enabling its one-step prediction ability without docking tools. Extensive experiments show LigPose achieved state-of-the-art performance on major tasks in drug research. Its considerable improvements indicate a promising paradigm of AI-based pipeline for drug development.

8/22/2024