PrivComp-KG : Leveraging Knowledge Graph and Large Language Models for Privacy Policy Compliance Verification
2404.19744
0
0
š¬
Abstract
Data protection and privacy is becoming increasingly crucial in the digital era. Numerous companies depend on third-party vendors and service providers to carry out critical functions within their operations, encompassing tasks such as data handling and storage. However, this reliance introduces potential vulnerabilities, as these vendors' security measures and practices may not always align with the standards expected by regulatory bodies. Businesses are required, often under the penalty of law, to ensure compliance with the evolving regulatory rules. Interpreting and implementing these regulations pose challenges due to their complexity. Regulatory documents are extensive, demanding significant effort for interpretation, while vendor-drafted privacy policies often lack the detail required for full legal compliance, leading to ambiguity. To ensure a concise interpretation of the regulatory requirements and compliance of organizational privacy policy with said regulations, we propose a Large Language Model (LLM) and Semantic Web based approach for privacy compliance. In this paper, we develop the novel Privacy Policy Compliance Verification Knowledge Graph, PrivComp-KG. It is designed to efficiently store and retrieve comprehensive information concerning privacy policies, regulatory frameworks, and domain-specific knowledge pertaining to the legal landscape of privacy. Using Retrieval Augmented Generation, we identify the relevant sections in a privacy policy with corresponding regulatory rules. This information about individual privacy policies is populated into the PrivComp-KG. Combining this with the domain context and rules, the PrivComp-KG can be queried to check for compliance with privacy policies by each vendor against relevant policy regulations. We demonstrate the relevance of the PrivComp-KG, by verifying compliance of privacy policy documents for various organizations.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Businesses increasingly rely on third-party vendors and service providers for critical functions like data handling and storage
- This introduces potential vulnerabilities if vendors' security practices don't align with regulatory standards
- Businesses must ensure compliance with evolving privacy regulations, which is challenging due to the complexity of the regulations
- The paper proposes a Large Language Model (LLM) and Semantic Web-based approach to verify privacy policy compliance
Plain English Explanation
Nowadays, many companies depend on outside vendors and service providers to perform important tasks like managing and storing data for their business. However, this reliance on third parties can create vulnerabilities if those vendors don't have the same level of security and privacy practices as the companies themselves. Businesses are required by law to make sure they comply with constantly-changing privacy regulations, but interpreting and implementing these complex rules can be very difficult.
To address this challenge, the researchers in this paper have developed a new system that uses large language models and semantic web technologies. Their "Privacy Policy Compliance Verification Knowledge Graph" (PrivComp-KG) is designed to efficiently store and organize information about privacy policies, regulations, and legal requirements around privacy. By linking this knowledge together, the system can then check if a company's privacy policy actually complies with the relevant privacy laws and regulations.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the development of the PrivComp-KG, a knowledge graph that integrates information about privacy policies, regulatory frameworks, and domain-specific legal knowledge. The researchers use Retrieval Augmented Generation to identify the relevant sections in a privacy policy and match them to the corresponding regulatory rules. This data is then populated into the PrivComp-KG.
By combining this policy-level information with the broader legal context and rules stored in the knowledge graph, the system can be queried to automatically check if a company's privacy policy is compliant with the applicable privacy regulations. The paper demonstrates the relevance of the PrivComp-KG by verifying the compliance of privacy policy documents for various organizations.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to addressing the challenge of ensuring privacy policy compliance, which is becoming increasingly important as businesses rely more on third-party service providers. The use of an LLM-powered knowledge graph to bridge the gap between privacy policies and regulatory requirements is a novel and potentially impactful solution.
However, the paper does not delve into potential limitations or caveats of the proposed system. For example, it's unclear how the PrivComp-KG would handle ambiguity or inconsistencies in privacy regulations, or how it would scale to handle the privacy policies of a large number of organizations. Additionally, the paper does not discuss potential biases or errors that could arise from the language model-based summarization and analysis.
Further research is needed to thoroughly evaluate the system's performance, robustness, and scalability in real-world deployments. Addressing these areas would strengthen the paper's contribution and help establish the PrivComp-KG as a reliable tool for ensuring privacy policy compliance.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to verifying the compliance of organizational privacy policies with relevant regulations. By leveraging large language models and semantic web technologies, the researchers have developed the Privacy Policy Compliance Verification Knowledge Graph (PrivComp-KG) to efficiently store and retrieve information about privacy policies, regulatory frameworks, and legal requirements.
This system has the potential to significantly simplify the process of interpreting and implementing complex privacy regulations, which is a growing challenge for businesses that rely on third-party vendors and service providers. By automating the verification of privacy policy compliance, the PrivComp-KG could help organizations better protect their customers' data and avoid the legal and reputational risks of non-compliance.
Overall, this research represents an important step forward in the effort to demystify legalese and enhance legal compliance through the application of advanced AI and knowledge graph technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
š¬
Enhancing Legal Compliance and Regulation Analysis with Large Language Models
Shabnam Hassani
0
0
This research explores the application of Large Language Models (LLMs) for automating the extraction of requirement-related legal content in the food safety domain and checking legal compliance of regulatory artifacts. With Industry 4.0 revolutionizing the food industry and with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) reshaping privacy policies and data processing agreements, there is a growing gap between regulatory analysis and recent technological advancements. This study aims to bridge this gap by leveraging LLMs, namely BERT and GPT models, to accurately classify legal provisions and automate compliance checks. Our findings demonstrate promising results, indicating LLMs' significant potential to enhance legal compliance and regulatory analysis efficiency, notably by reducing manual workload and improving accuracy within reasonable time and financial constraints.
4/29/2024
Large Language Models: A New Approach for Privacy Policy Analysis at Scale
David Rodriguez, Ian Yang, Jose M. Del Alamo, Norman Sadeh
0
0
The number and dynamic nature of web and mobile applications presents significant challenges for assessing their compliance with data protection laws. In this context, symbolic and statistical Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques have been employed for the automated analysis of these systems' privacy policies. However, these techniques typically require labor-intensive and potentially error-prone manually annotated datasets for training and validation. This research proposes the application of Large Language Models (LLMs) as an alternative for effectively and efficiently extracting privacy practices from privacy policies at scale. Particularly, we leverage well-known LLMs such as ChatGPT and Llama 2, and offer guidance on the optimal design of prompts, parameters, and models, incorporating advanced strategies such as few-shot learning. We further illustrate its capability to detect detailed and varied privacy practices accurately. Using several renowned datasets in the domain as a benchmark, our evaluation validates its exceptional performance, achieving an F1 score exceeding 93%. Besides, it does so with reduced costs, faster processing times, and fewer technical knowledge requirements. Consequently, we advocate for LLM-based solutions as a sound alternative to traditional NLP techniques for the automated analysis of privacy policies at scale.
6/3/2024
Research Trends for the Interplay between Large Language Models and Knowledge Graphs
Hanieh Khorashadizadeh, Fatima Zahra Amara, Morteza Ezzabady, Fr'ed'eric Ieng, Sanju Tiwari, Nandana Mihindukulasooriya, Jinghua Groppe, Soror Sahri, Farah Benamara, Sven Groppe
0
0
This survey investigates the synergistic relationship between Large Language Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs (KGs), which is crucial for advancing AI's capabilities in understanding, reasoning, and language processing. It aims to address gaps in current research by exploring areas such as KG Question Answering, ontology generation, KG validation, and the enhancement of KG accuracy and consistency through LLMs. The paper further examines the roles of LLMs in generating descriptive texts and natural language queries for KGs. Through a structured analysis that includes categorizing LLM-KG interactions, examining methodologies, and investigating collaborative uses and potential biases, this study seeks to provide new insights into the combined potential of LLMs and KGs. It highlights the importance of their interaction for improving AI applications and outlines future research directions.
6/13/2024
Demystifying Legalese: An Automated Approach for Summarizing and Analyzing Overlaps in Privacy Policies and Terms of Service
Shikha Soneji, Mitchell Hoesing, Sujay Koujalgi, Jonathan Dodge
0
0
The complexities of legalese in terms and policy documents can bind individuals to contracts they do not fully comprehend, potentially leading to uninformed data sharing. Our work seeks to alleviate this issue by developing language models that provide automated, accessible summaries and scores for such documents, aiming to enhance user understanding and facilitate informed decisions. We compared transformer-based and conventional models during training on our dataset, and RoBERTa performed better overall with a remarkable 0.74 F1-score. Leveraging our best-performing model, RoBERTa, we highlighted redundancies and potential guideline violations by identifying overlaps in GDPR-required documents, underscoring the necessity for stricter GDPR compliance.
4/23/2024