Investigating the prompt leakage effect and black-box defenses for multi-turn LLM interactions
0
🏷️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper investigates the "prompt leakage effect" in multi-turn interactions with large language models (LLMs) and explores black-box defenses to mitigate this issue.
• The prompt leakage effect occurs when information from previous interactions with an LLM leaks into the model's responses, potentially revealing sensitive prompts or previous conversations.
• The researchers propose several black-box defense techniques to address this problem, including prompt obfuscation, adversarial training, and prompt mixture models.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful AI systems that can engage in multi-turn conversations. However, these models can sometimes "remember" or "leak" information from previous conversations, which can be a privacy and security concern. For example, if someone asks an LLM a sensitive question, the model might inadvertently reveal details about that question in a later response.
The researchers in this paper explore ways to address this "prompt leakage effect." They propose several techniques, such as obfuscating or mixing the prompts given to the LLM, or training the model to be more adversarial to these types of attacks. The goal is to help protect the privacy and security of users interacting with LLMs, especially in sensitive or multi-turn conversations.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by defining the prompt leakage effect, which occurs when information from previous interactions with an LLM leaks into the model's responses. This can reveal sensitive prompts or previous conversations, posing privacy and security risks.
To address this issue, the researchers propose several black-box defense techniques:
- Prompt obfuscation: Modifying the input prompts to the LLM to obscure sensitive information.
- Adversarial training: Training the LLM to be more robust against prompt leakage attacks.
- Prompt mixture models: Combining multiple prompts to reduce the impact of any single prompt.
The paper presents experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of these defenses against various prompt leakage attack scenarios, including the generalized nested jailbreak prompt attack and the spiral silences attack. The results demonstrate the potential of these black-box defense techniques to mitigate the prompt leakage effect.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive investigation of the prompt leakage effect and proposes several promising defense strategies. However, the authors acknowledge that their work has some limitations. For example, the effectiveness of the defenses may depend on the specific LLM architecture and attack scenarios, and further research is needed to understand the broader implications and generalizability of the findings.
Additionally, while the paper focuses on black-box defenses, there may be opportunities to explore white-box or hybrid approaches that leverage more detailed information about the LLM's inner workings. This could potentially lead to even more effective solutions for protecting user privacy and security in multi-turn LLM interactions.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important contribution to the field of LLM security and privacy by investigating the prompt leakage effect and proposing several black-box defense techniques to mitigate this issue. As LLMs become increasingly prevalent in our everyday interactions, ensuring the confidentiality and integrity of these conversations is crucial. The insights and strategies presented in this work could have significant implications for the design and deployment of more secure and trustworthy LLM-based systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏷️
0
Investigating the prompt leakage effect and black-box defenses for multi-turn LLM interactions
Divyansh Agarwal, Alexander R. Fabbri, Ben Risher, Philippe Laban, Shafiq Joty, Chien-Sheng Wu
Prompt leakage poses a compelling security and privacy threat in LLM applications. Leakage of system prompts may compromise intellectual property, and act as adversarial reconnaissance for an attacker. A systematic evaluation of prompt leakage threats and mitigation strategies is lacking, especially for multi-turn LLM interactions. In this paper, we systematically investigate LLM vulnerabilities against prompt leakage for 10 closed- and open-source LLMs, across four domains. We design a unique threat model which leverages the LLM sycophancy effect and elevates the average attack success rate (ASR) from 17.7% to 86.2% in a multi-turn setting. Our standardized setup further allows dissecting leakage of specific prompt contents such as task instructions and knowledge documents. We measure the mitigation effect of 7 black-box defense strategies, along with finetuning an open-source model to defend against leakage attempts. We present different combination of defenses against our threat model, including a cost analysis. Our study highlights key takeaways for building secure LLM applications and provides directions for research in multi-turn LLM interactions
Read more7/30/2024
0
PLeak: Prompt Leaking Attacks against Large Language Model Applications
Bo Hui, Haolin Yuan, Neil Gong, Philippe Burlina, Yinzhi Cao
Large Language Models (LLMs) enable a new ecosystem with many downstream applications, called LLM applications, with different natural language processing tasks. The functionality and performance of an LLM application highly depend on its system prompt, which instructs the backend LLM on what task to perform. Therefore, an LLM application developer often keeps a system prompt confidential to protect its intellectual property. As a result, a natural attack, called prompt leaking, is to steal the system prompt from an LLM application, which compromises the developer's intellectual property. Existing prompt leaking attacks primarily rely on manually crafted queries, and thus achieve limited effectiveness. In this paper, we design a novel, closed-box prompt leaking attack framework, called PLeak, to optimize an adversarial query such that when the attacker sends it to a target LLM application, its response reveals its own system prompt. We formulate finding such an adversarial query as an optimization problem and solve it with a gradient-based method approximately. Our key idea is to break down the optimization goal by optimizing adversary queries for system prompts incrementally, i.e., starting from the first few tokens of each system prompt step by step until the entire length of the system prompt. We evaluate PLeak in both offline settings and for real-world LLM applications, e.g., those on Poe, a popular platform hosting such applications. Our results show that PLeak can effectively leak system prompts and significantly outperforms not only baselines that manually curate queries but also baselines with optimized queries that are modified and adapted from existing jailbreaking attacks. We responsibly reported the issues to Poe and are still waiting for their response. Our implementation is available at this repository: https://github.com/BHui97/PLeak.
Read more5/15/2024
0
Securing Multi-turn Conversational Language Models Against Distributed Backdoor Triggers
Terry Tong, Jiashu Xu, Qin Liu, Muhao Chen
The security of multi-turn conversational large language models (LLMs) is understudied despite it being one of the most popular LLM utilization. Specifically, LLMs are vulnerable to data poisoning backdoor attacks, where an adversary manipulates the training data to cause the model to output malicious responses to predefined triggers. Specific to the multi-turn dialogue setting, LLMs are at the risk of even more harmful and stealthy backdoor attacks where the backdoor triggers may span across multiple utterances, giving lee-way to context-driven attacks. In this paper, we explore a novel distributed backdoor trigger attack that serves to be an extra tool in an adversary's toolbox that can interface with other single-turn attack strategies in a plug and play manner. Results on two representative defense mechanisms indicate that distributed backdoor triggers are robust against existing defense strategies which are designed for single-turn user-model interactions, motivating us to propose a new defense strategy for the multi-turn dialogue setting that is more challenging. To this end, we also explore a novel contrastive decoding based defense that is able to mitigate the backdoor with a low computational tradeoff.
Read more7/8/2024
0
A Study on Prompt Injection Attack Against LLM-Integrated Mobile Robotic Systems
Wenxiao Zhang, Xiangrui Kong, Conan Dewitt, Thomas Braunl, Jin B. Hong
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4o into robotic systems represents a significant advancement in embodied artificial intelligence. These models can process multi-modal prompts, enabling them to generate more context-aware responses. However, this integration is not without challenges. One of the primary concerns is the potential security risks associated with using LLMs in robotic navigation tasks. These tasks require precise and reliable responses to ensure safe and effective operation. Multi-modal prompts, while enhancing the robot's understanding, also introduce complexities that can be exploited maliciously. For instance, adversarial inputs designed to mislead the model can lead to incorrect or dangerous navigational decisions. This study investigates the impact of prompt injections on mobile robot performance in LLM-integrated systems and explores secure prompt strategies to mitigate these risks. Our findings demonstrate a substantial overall improvement of approximately 30.8% in both attack detection and system performance with the implementation of robust defence mechanisms, highlighting their critical role in enhancing security and reliability in mission-oriented tasks.
Read more9/10/2024