Provable Unrestricted Adversarial Training without Compromise with Generalizability
0
🏋️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Adversarial training (AT) is a popular strategy for defending against adversarial attacks, but it faces two key challenges:
- Inability to handle unrestricted adversarial examples (UAEs), which are built from scratch rather than restricted adversarial examples (RAEs) with bounded perturbations
- Tradeoff between adversarial robustness and standard generalization (accuracy on natural examples)
Plain English Explanation
Adversarial training is a technique used to make machine learning models more robust against adversarial attacks, which are small, imperceptible changes to inputs that can cause the model to make incorrect predictions. Researchers have found that existing adversarial training methods struggle with two key challenges:
-
Handling Unrestricted Adversarial Examples (UAEs): Current methods are good at defending against restricted adversarial examples (RAEs), which are created by adding small, bounded changes to real examples. However, they have a harder time with UAEs, which are built from scratch to trick the model without any constraints.
-
Tradeoff Between Robustness and Generalization: When training models to be more robust against adversarial attacks, the models often become less accurate on regular, "natural" examples that weren't designed to fool them. Researchers are trying to find a way to improve both adversarial robustness and standard generalization at the same time.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel adversarial training approach called Provable Unrestricted Adversarial Training (PUAT) that aims to address these two challenges. PUAT takes the perspective that UAEs can be viewed as imperceptibly perturbed unobserved examples, rather than just random noise. It uses partially labeled data and a novel augmented triple-GAN architecture to effectively generate UAEs that accurately capture the natural data distribution.
At the same time, PUAT extends traditional adversarial training by incorporating the supervised loss of the target classifier into the adversarial loss. This helps align the distributions of UAEs, natural data, and the classifier's learned distribution, improving both adversarial robustness and standard generalization.
The paper provides solid theoretical analysis and extensive experiments on benchmark datasets to demonstrate the superiority of PUAT over existing adversarial training methods. PUAT is able to achieve comprehensive adversarial robustness against both UAEs and RAEs while simultaneously improving the model's standard accuracy.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful and well-designed approach to the challenging problem of adversarial robustness. The key ideas, such as viewing UAEs as imperceptibly perturbed unobserved examples and aligning the relevant distributions, are novel and appear promising.
However, the paper does not address potential limitations or edge cases. For example, it's unclear how well PUAT would perform against more advanced and adaptive adversarial attacks that actively try to circumvent the defense. Additionally, the reliance on partially labeled data may limit the practical applicability of PUAT in real-world scenarios where labeled data is scarce.
Further research is needed to understand the broader implications and generalizability of PUAT, as well as its robustness to adversarial attacks that target the training process itself rather than just the final model.
Conclusion
The proposed Provable Unrestricted Adversarial Training (PUAT) approach represents a significant step forward in addressing the challenges of adversarial robustness. By treating UAEs as imperceptibly perturbed unobserved examples and aligning the relevant distributions, PUAT is able to achieve comprehensive adversarial robustness while also improving standard generalization.
The technical insights and empirical results presented in the paper suggest that PUAT could be a valuable tool for developing more secure and reliable machine learning systems, with potential applications in a wide range of domains. However, further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and broader implications of this approach.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏋️
0
Provable Unrestricted Adversarial Training without Compromise with Generalizability
Lilin Zhang, Ning Yang, Yanchao Sun, Philip S. Yu
Adversarial training (AT) is widely considered as the most promising strategy to defend against adversarial attacks and has drawn increasing interest from researchers. However, the existing AT methods still suffer from two challenges. First, they are unable to handle unrestricted adversarial examples (UAEs), which are built from scratch, as opposed to restricted adversarial examples (RAEs), which are created by adding perturbations bound by an $l_p$ norm to observed examples. Second, the existing AT methods often achieve adversarial robustness at the expense of standard generalizability (i.e., the accuracy on natural examples) because they make a tradeoff between them. To overcome these challenges, we propose a unique viewpoint that understands UAEs as imperceptibly perturbed unobserved examples. Also, we find that the tradeoff results from the separation of the distributions of adversarial examples and natural examples. Based on these ideas, we propose a novel AT approach called Provable Unrestricted Adversarial Training (PUAT), which can provide a target classifier with comprehensive adversarial robustness against both UAE and RAE, and simultaneously improve its standard generalizability. Particularly, PUAT utilizes partially labeled data to achieve effective UAE generation by accurately capturing the natural data distribution through a novel augmented triple-GAN. At the same time, PUAT extends the traditional AT by introducing the supervised loss of the target classifier into the adversarial loss and achieves the alignment between the UAE distribution, the natural data distribution, and the distribution learned by the classifier, with the collaboration of the augmented triple-GAN. Finally, the solid theoretical analysis and extensive experiments conducted on widely-used benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of PUAT.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Exploiting the Layered Intrinsic Dimensionality of Deep Models for Practical Adversarial Training
Enes Altinisik, Safa Messaoud, Husrev Taha Sencar, Hassan Sajjad, Sanjay Chawla
Despite being a heavily researched topic, Adversarial Training (AT) is rarely, if ever, deployed in practical AI systems for two primary reasons: (i) the gained robustness is frequently accompanied by a drop in generalization and (ii) generating adversarial examples (AEs) is computationally prohibitively expensive. To address these limitations, we propose SMAAT, a new AT algorithm that leverages the manifold conjecture, stating that off-manifold AEs lead to better robustness while on-manifold AEs result in better generalization. Specifically, SMAAT aims at generating a higher proportion of off-manifold AEs by perturbing the intermediate deepnet layer with the lowest intrinsic dimension. This systematically results in better scalability compared to classical AT as it reduces the PGD chains length required for generating the AEs. Additionally, our study provides, to the best of our knowledge, the first explanation for the difference in the generalization and robustness trends between vision and language models, ie., AT results in a drop in generalization in vision models whereas, in encoder-based language models, generalization either improves or remains unchanged. We show that vision transformers and decoder-based models tend to have low intrinsic dimensionality in the earlier layers of the network (more off-manifold AEs), while encoder-based models have low intrinsic dimensionality in the later layers. We demonstrate the efficacy of SMAAT; on several tasks, including robustifying (i) sentiment classifiers, (ii) safety filters in decoder-based models, and (iii) retrievers in RAG setups. SMAAT requires only 25-33% of the GPU time compared to standard AT, while significantly improving robustness across all applications and maintaining comparable generalization.
Read more5/28/2024
🏋️
0
Adversarial Training on Purification (AToP): Advancing Both Robustness and Generalization
Guang Lin, Chao Li, Jianhai Zhang, Toshihisa Tanaka, Qibin Zhao
The deep neural networks are known to be vulnerable to well-designed adversarial attacks. The most successful defense technique based on adversarial training (AT) can achieve optimal robustness against particular attacks but cannot generalize well to unseen attacks. Another effective defense technique based on adversarial purification (AP) can enhance generalization but cannot achieve optimal robustness. Meanwhile, both methods share one common limitation on the degraded standard accuracy. To mitigate these issues, we propose a novel pipeline to acquire the robust purifier model, named Adversarial Training on Purification (AToP), which comprises two components: perturbation destruction by random transforms (RT) and purifier model fine-tuned (FT) by adversarial loss. RT is essential to avoid overlearning to known attacks, resulting in the robustness generalization to unseen attacks, and FT is essential for the improvement of robustness. To evaluate our method in an efficient and scalable way, we conduct extensive experiments on CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and ImageNette to demonstrate that our method achieves optimal robustness and exhibits generalization ability against unseen attacks.
Read more8/26/2024
0
Rethinking Invariance Regularization in Adversarial Training to Improve Robustness-Accuracy Trade-off
Futa Waseda, Ching-Chun Chang, Isao Echizen
Although adversarial training has been the state-of-the-art approach to defend against adversarial examples (AEs), it suffers from a robustness-accuracy trade-off, where high robustness is achieved at the cost of clean accuracy. In this work, we leverage invariance regularization on latent representations to learn discriminative yet adversarially invariant representations, aiming to mitigate this trade-off. We analyze two key issues in representation learning with invariance regularization: (1) a gradient conflict between invariance loss and classification objectives, leading to suboptimal convergence, and (2) the mixture distribution problem arising from diverged distributions of clean and adversarial inputs. To address these issues, we propose Asymmetrically Representation-regularized Adversarial Training (AR-AT), which incorporates asymmetric invariance loss with stop-gradient operation and a predictor to improve the convergence, and a split-BatchNorm (BN) structure to resolve the mixture distribution problem. Our method significantly improves the robustness-accuracy trade-off by learning adversarially invariant representations without sacrificing discriminative ability. Furthermore, we discuss the relevance of our findings to knowledge-distillation-based defense methods, contributing to a deeper understanding of their relative successes.
Read more5/30/2024