Push and Pull: A Framework for Measuring Attentional Agency

Overview

• The paper proposes a framework for measuring "attentional agency" - the ability of people to control their attention on digital platforms.
• Platforms can both extend and limit people's attention through personalization and influencing other users.
• The framework aims to quantify how much platforms empower people to pull information into their own attention and push information into others' attention.
• The paper also discusses the implications of generative AI models, which could allow users to bypass methods platforms use to capture economic value from information.
• The paper concludes with policy strategies to understand and reshape the distribution of attentional agency online.

Plain English Explanation

In the digital age, people's attention has become a valuable resource. Platforms like social media can personalize information to capture our focus, but they also allow us to influence each other's attention. This paper presents a way to measure "attentional agency" - how much control we have over where we focus our attention and what we expose others to.

The key idea is that platforms give us both the ability to pull information into our own attention based on our interests, and to push information into the attention of others. The paper introduces a formal framework for quantifying these two sides of attentional agency. This can shed light on how platforms shape what we see and what others see.

For example, generative AI models could let users bypass the methods platforms use to profit from our attention, fundamentally changing the dynamic. The paper suggests policy strategies to understand and adjust the balance of attentional agency online.

The overall goal is to provide a way to measure and manage the tug-of-war for people's attention on digital platforms, which has important implications for individual agency, information access, and the broader collaboration between humans and AI.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a formal framework for quantifying "attentional agency" - the ability of people to allocate their attention according to their own desires, goals, and intentions on digital platforms. This draws on the insight that platforms extend people's limited attentional capacity by personalizing information, but also allow people to influence each other's attention.

The key components of the framework are:

1. Attentional pull: The extent to which a platform empowers a person to draw information into their own attentional field based on their preferences.
2. Attentional push: The extent to which a platform empowers a person to push information into the attentional fields of others.

The paper argues that these two dimensions capture the core mechanisms by which platforms mediate attention. It then uses this framework to analyze the implications of emerging technologies like generative AI models, which could enable users to bypass the "attentional bargain" that underlies ad-supported platforms.

The paper concludes by outlining policy strategies to understand and reshape the distribution of attentional agency online, with the goal of promoting individual agency, equitable access to information, and beneficial human-AI collaboration.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a thoughtful and well-reasoned framework for analyzing the dynamics of attention on digital platforms. By distinguishing between the ability to pull information into one's own attention and the ability to push information into the attention of others, it provides a useful conceptual lens for understanding how platforms mediate the allocation of this scarce cognitive resource.

One potential limitation is the challenge of actually quantifying these attentional pull and push factors in practice. The paper acknowledges this and suggests that further research is needed to develop robust measurement techniques. Additionally, the framework may oversimplify the complex social and psychological factors that influence attention online.

That said, the core insight - that platforms play a pivotal role in structuring the distribution of attentional agency - is an important one. As the paper notes, this has significant implications for individual autonomy, information access, and the evolving relationship between humans and AI systems. Policymakers and platform designers would do well to consider these dynamics as they work to create a more equitable and empowering digital information ecosystem.

Conclusion

This paper proposes a novel framework for understanding and measuring "attentional agency" on digital platforms. By distinguishing between a person's ability to pull information into their own attention and push information into the attention of others, the framework sheds light on how platforms shape the allocation of this valuable cognitive resource.

The paper's analysis of the implications of emerging technologies like generative AI models is particularly thought-provoking, as it suggests that these advances could disrupt the "attentional bargain" that underlies many current platform business models. Overall, this work offers a valuable conceptual tool for policymakers, platform designers, and researchers seeking to promote individual agency, equitable access to information, and beneficial human-AI collaboration in the digital age.