A quantitative investigation for deployment of mobile collaborative robots in high-value manufacturing

Overview

• Automated component inspection is crucial for high-value manufacturing industries like aerospace
• Current fixed-arm robot systems lack flexibility in adapting to new parts or orientations
• Advanced mobile robotic platforms with updated sensors and algorithms have improved localization and path planning
• However, mobile platforms introduce challenges in localization and maneuverability, leading to potential errors
• Positional uncertainty is higher than fixed systems due to the lack of a fixed calibrated location

Plain English Explanation

Inspecting components is often a slow process in high-value manufacturing, like in the aerospace industry. Factories currently use fixed robot arms to do this inspection, but these systems struggle to adapt when new parts or orientations are introduced. Advanced mobile robotic platforms with updated sensors and software have improved their ability to navigate and plan paths, making them well-suited for bringing the inspection process directly to the parts.

However, these mobile platforms come with their own challenges. Their ability to precisely locate themselves is not as good as the fixed systems, which can lead to errors during the inspection process. This is because the mobile platforms don't have a fixed, calibrated location like the stationary robots do.

To address this, the researchers evaluated the accuracy and repeatability of a specific mobile platform, the KUKA KMR iiwa. They found that enabling the platform's feature mapping capabilities substantially improved its performance, reducing errors by over 90%. The platform also demonstrated good repeatability, with errors under 7 millimeters when the mapping was activated, and around 2.5 millimeters in practical scenarios.

This shows that mobile manipulators, combining a robot arm and a mobile base, can meet the precise requirements of industries that need high-precision inspection, providing a flexible alternative to traditional fixed-base industrial robots.

Technical Explanation

The researchers chose to evaluate the KUKA KMR iiwa mobile platform for its collaborative features, robust build, and scalability within the KUKA product range. They conducted a series of tests to assess the accuracy and repeatability of the mobile platform's positioning.

The experiments evaluated the performance of the platform's integrated feature mapping, the effect of various speeds on positional accuracy, and the efficiency of the omnidirectional wheels for a range of translation orientations. The results showed that enabling the feature mapping substantially improved the KUKA KMR iiwa's performance, with accuracy gains and error reductions exceeding 90%.

Repeatability errors were under 7 mm with mapping activated and around 2.5 mm in practical scenarios. This demonstrates that mobile manipulators, incorporating both the manipulator and platform, can fulfill the precise requirements of industries with high precision needs, such as aerospace and automated real-time 3D inspection.

The researchers also found that the mobile platform's relative motion tracking and repeatability were reliable, providing a diverse alternative to traditional fixed-base industrial manipulators.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of the KUKA KMR iiwa's positioning accuracy and repeatability, which are crucial factors for industries requiring high-precision inspection. The researchers' experimental approach, using feature mapping, speed variations, and orientation tests, offers valuable insights into the platform's capabilities.

However, the paper does not address potential limitations or challenges that may arise in real-world deployment scenarios. For example, the effects of changing environmental conditions, such as varying lighting or obstacle interference, on the platform's performance are not explored. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational resources required for the feature mapping algorithms or the scalability of the approach for larger-scale operations.

Further research could investigate the integration of advanced sensor technologies, such as high-accuracy 3D vision, to enhance the platform's inspection capabilities. Exploring the platform's performance in dynamic manufacturing environments and construction sites could also provide valuable insights for broader industrial applications.

Conclusion

The research paper demonstrates the potential of mobile manipulator platforms, such as the KUKA KMR iiwa, to address the precision requirements of high-value manufacturing industries like aerospace. The researchers' evaluation of the platform's accuracy and repeatability, particularly with the use of feature mapping, highlights the technology's ability to overcome the limitations of traditional fixed-base industrial robots.

These findings suggest that mobile manipulators can bring the inspection process directly to the parts, providing a flexible and scalable solution for industries that require precise, automated component inspection. As the technology continues to evolve, further advancements in sensor integration and algorithm development may unlock even greater capabilities, paving the way for widespread adoption of mobile robotic solutions in smart manufacturing environments.