ReFIT: Relevance Feedback from a Reranker during Inference

Overview

• This paper proposes a novel approach to improve retrieval recall in the popular retrieve-and-rerank framework for neural information retrieval.
• The key idea is to leverage the more powerful reranker model to provide relevance feedback to the initial retriever model, allowing the retriever to better align its candidate scores with the reranker's predictions.
• The authors demonstrate that this method substantially enhances retrieval recall across multiple domains, languages, and modalities.

Plain English Explanation

In the field of neural information retrieval, a common approach is the "retrieve-and-rerank" framework. Here, a initial retriever model quickly finds a set of relevant candidates, which are then reranked by a more sophisticated reranker model to produce the final results.

While the reranker often improves the scores of the top-ranked candidates, it is limited to only refining the initial set of results retrieved by the first model. This means the reranker cannot actually improve the overall recall - the ability to retrieve relevant items in the first place.

To address this, the authors of this paper propose a novel technique that allows the reranker to provide feedback to the retriever model. Specifically, during inference, the reranker's predictions for a given query are distilled into the retriever's query representation using a lightweight update mechanism. This helps align the retriever's candidate scores more closely with the reranker's assessments.

The algorithm then proceeds to execute a second retrieval step using this updated query vector. The authors show that this approach, applicable to various retrieve-and-rerank frameworks, can significantly boost retrieval recall across a wide range of applications, including different domains, languages, and even modalities like images.

By leveraging the power of the reranker to improve the initial retriever, this method addresses a key limitation of the traditional retrieve-and-rerank pipeline, potentially leading to more effective and comprehensive information retrieval systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on the retrieve-and-rerank framework, a prevalent approach in neural information retrieval. In this framework, a bi-encoder retriever model first quickly finds a pre-defined number of candidate results (e.g., K=100). These candidates are then reranked by a more powerful cross-encoder reranker model to produce the final output.

While the reranker often improves the scores of the top-ranked candidates, its scope is confined to only the initial K retrieved items. As a result, the reranker cannot enhance retrieval performance in terms of Recall@K, which measures the ability to retrieve relevant items in the first place.

To address this limitation, the authors propose a method to leverage the reranker to improve the recall of the retriever. Specifically, during inference, the reranker's predictions for a given test instance are distilled into the retriever's query representation using a lightweight update mechanism. The aim of this distillation loss is to align the retriever's candidate scores more closely with those produced by the reranker.

After this update, the algorithm executes a second retrieval step using the modified query vector. The authors demonstrate empirically that this approach, which can be applied to various retrieve-and-rerank frameworks, substantially enhances retrieval recall across multiple domains, languages, and modalities.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and compelling approach to improving retrieval recall in the retrieve-and-rerank framework. By allowing the reranker to provide relevance feedback to the retriever, the authors overcome a key limitation of the traditional pipeline.

However, the paper does not extensively discuss potential caveats or limitations of the proposed method. For example, it is unclear how the distillation mechanism may scale or perform with larger retriever and reranker models, or how sensitive the approach is to the specific architectures and training regimes of the underlying models.

Additionally, while the authors demonstrate significant improvements in retrieval recall, the impact on other metrics, such as precision or ranking quality, is not fully explored. It would be valuable to understand the broader effects of this technique on the overall retrieval system performance.

Further research could also investigate how this approach might interact with or complement other techniques for improving retrieval, such as Revisiting Relevance Feedback in CLIP-based Interactive Image Retrieval, Generative Relevance Feedback for Convergence Adaptive Re-ranking, or Recall, Retrieve, and Reason: Towards Better Context Relation.

Overall, the paper presents a promising approach that could lead to more effective and comprehensive information retrieval systems. However, further exploration of its limitations, tradeoffs, and potential synergies with other techniques would be valuable for researchers and practitioners in this field.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel method to improve retrieval recall in the popular retrieve-and-rerank framework for neural information retrieval. By allowing the more powerful reranker model to provide relevance feedback to the initial retriever, the authors demonstrate a substantial enhancement in retrieval recall across multiple domains, languages, and modalities.

This work addresses a key limitation of the traditional retrieve-and-rerank pipeline, where the reranker is confined to only refining the top-ranked candidates. The proposed distillation-based approach enables the retriever to better align its candidate scores with the reranker's assessments, leading to improved overall retrieval performance.

The authors' findings highlight the potential benefits of leveraging the complementary strengths of retriever and reranker models to advance the state-of-the-art in neural information retrieval. Further research exploring the scalability, robustness, and synergies of this technique could yield valuable insights and spur the development of more effective and comprehensive retrieval systems, benefiting a wide range of applications that rely on accurate and comprehensive information retrieval.