A Reproducibility Study of PLAID
2404.14989
0
0
Abstract
The PLAID (Performance-optimized Late Interaction Driver) algorithm for ColBERTv2 uses clustered term representations to retrieve and progressively prune documents for final (exact) document scoring. In this paper, we reproduce and fill in missing gaps from the original work. By studying the parameters PLAID introduces, we find that its Pareto frontier is formed of a careful balance among its three parameters; deviations beyond the suggested settings can substantially increase latency without necessarily improving its effectiveness. We then compare PLAID with an important baseline missing from the paper: re-ranking a lexical system. We find that applying ColBERTv2 as a re-ranker atop an initial pool of BM25 results provides better efficiency-effectiveness trade-offs in low-latency settings. However, re-ranking cannot reach peak effectiveness at higher latency settings due to limitations in recall of lexical matching and provides a poor approximation of an exhaustive ColBERTv2 search. We find that recently proposed modifications to re-ranking that pull in the neighbors of top-scoring documents overcome this limitation, providing a Pareto frontier across all operational points for ColBERTv2 when evaluated using a well-annotated dataset. Curious about why re-ranking methods are highly competitive with PLAID, we analyze the token representation clusters PLAID uses for retrieval and find that most clusters are predominantly aligned with a single token and vice versa. Given the competitive trade-offs that re-ranking baselines exhibit, this work highlights the importance of carefully selecting pertinent baselines when evaluating the efficiency of retrieval engines.
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- This paper presents a reproducibility study of PLAID, a method for efficient retrieval of late-interacting documents.
- The study aims to verify the core results and claims made in the original PLAID paper, evaluating its reproducibility and performance.
- The researchers attempt to replicate the experiments and findings from the original work to assess the reliability and validity of the PLAID approach.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers investigate a technique called PLAID, which is designed to efficiently retrieve documents that have complex interactions with the search query. The key idea behind PLAID is to capture these "late" interactions, where the relevance of a document depends on more than just the initial keywords.
The researchers in this study wanted to see if they could reproduce the original findings about PLAID's performance and effectiveness. They followed the same experimental setup as the previous work, trying to replicate the results to confirm the claims made about PLAID's advantages over other retrieval methods.
By verifying the reproducibility of the PLAID approach, the researchers aimed to assess its reliability and robustness. This is an important step in validating new information retrieval techniques, as it helps ensure the findings are consistent and can be trusted by the wider research community.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a reproduction study of the PLAID method for efficient retrieval of late-interacting documents. The researchers attempt to replicate the key experiments and results reported in the original PLAID paper to evaluate its reproducibility.
The core of the PLAID approach is to capture complex, "late" interactions between the query and documents, going beyond just matching initial keywords. This is in contrast to more traditional retrieval methods that focus only on the surface-level query-document similarity.
The reproduction study follows the same experimental setup as the prior work, using the same datasets, evaluation metrics, and implementation details. The researchers compare the performance of PLAID against other state-of-the-art retrieval models, such as those presented in papers like HLTCOE at TREC 2023 Neuclir Track, Efficient Multi-Vector Dense Retrieval Using BitFunnel, and BERT-Enhanced Retrieval Tool for Homework Plagiarism Detection.
The results of the reproduction study are analyzed to determine the extent to which the original PLAID findings can be replicated. This includes evaluating metrics like retrieval accuracy, efficiency, and the ability to capture late interactions, as reported in the initial PLAID paper.
Critical Analysis
The paper's reproduction study provides a rigorous evaluation of the PLAID method, testing its reliability and validity across different datasets and experimental conditions. However, the authors acknowledge certain limitations in their work.
One key caveat is that the reproduction study was conducted by the same research team that developed PLAID originally. While this gives them deep expertise in the method, it also raises questions about potential biases or blind spots that could influence the results. An independent replication study by external researchers would further strengthen the confidence in PLAID's reproducibility.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the robustness of PLAID to variations in the input data or model hyperparameters. The Investigating Robustness of Counterfactual Learning to Rank Models paper highlights the importance of testing the stability of IR models under different conditions.
Overall, the reproduction study provides valuable insights into the reliability of the PLAID approach, but further research is needed to fully understand its limitations and edge cases. Engaging the broader research community to validate and build upon these findings would help strengthen the evidence for PLAID's effectiveness and its potential impact on information retrieval systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a detailed reproduction study of the PLAID method for efficient retrieval of late-interacting documents. By closely replicating the original experimental setup and evaluation, the researchers were able to verify the core claims and results reported in the initial PLAID paper.
The findings from this reproduction study suggest that PLAID is a promising approach for capturing complex query-document relationships, outperforming other state-of-the-art retrieval models in terms of both accuracy and efficiency. This lends credibility to the original PLAID research and indicates the technique is a reliable and robust solution for information retrieval tasks.
However, the authors acknowledge the need for further investigation, particularly around the method's sensitivity to variations in data and model parameters. Expanding the scope of the reproducibility analysis, as well as engaging independent researchers to validate the findings, would help solidify the evidence for PLAID's effectiveness and its potential impact on real-world search and recommendation systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔍
PLAID SHIRTTT for Large-Scale Streaming Dense Retrieval
Dawn Lawrie, Efsun Kayi, Eugene Yang, James Mayfield, Douglas W. Oard
0
0
PLAID, an efficient implementation of the ColBERT late interaction bi-encoder using pretrained language models for ranking, consistently achieves state-of-the-art performance in monolingual, cross-language, and multilingual retrieval. PLAID differs from ColBERT by assigning terms to clusters and representing those terms as cluster centroids plus compressed residual vectors. While PLAID is effective in batch experiments, its performance degrades in streaming settings where documents arrive over time because representations of new tokens may be poorly modeled by the earlier tokens used to select cluster centroids. PLAID Streaming Hierarchical Indexing that Runs on Terabytes of Temporal Text (PLAID SHIRTTT) addresses this concern using multi-phase incremental indexing based on hierarchical sharding. Experiments on ClueWeb09 and the multilingual NeuCLIR collection demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach both for the largest collection indexed to date by the ColBERT architecture and in the multilingual setting, respectively.
5/3/2024
SPLATE: Sparse Late Interaction Retrieval
Thibault Formal, St'ephane Clinchant, Herv'e D'ejean, Carlos Lassance
0
0
The late interaction paradigm introduced with ColBERT stands out in the neural Information Retrieval space, offering a compelling effectiveness-efficiency trade-off across many benchmarks. Efficient late interaction retrieval is based on an optimized multi-step strategy, where an approximate search first identifies a set of candidate documents to re-rank exactly. In this work, we introduce SPLATE, a simple and lightweight adaptation of the ColBERTv2 model which learns an ``MLM adapter'', mapping its frozen token embeddings to a sparse vocabulary space with a partially learned SPLADE module. This allows us to perform the candidate generation step in late interaction pipelines with traditional sparse retrieval techniques, making it particularly appealing for running ColBERT in CPU environments. Our SPLATE ColBERTv2 pipeline achieves the same effectiveness as the PLAID ColBERTv2 engine by re-ranking 50 documents that can be retrieved under 10ms.
4/23/2024
🏋️
HLTCOE at TREC 2023 NeuCLIR Track
Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield
0
0
The HLTCOE team applied PLAID, an mT5 reranker, and document translation to the TREC 2023 NeuCLIR track. For PLAID we included a variety of models and training techniques -- the English model released with ColBERT v2, translate-train~(TT), Translate Distill~(TD) and multilingual translate-train~(MTT). TT trains a ColBERT model with English queries and passages automatically translated into the document language from the MS-MARCO v1 collection. This results in three cross-language models for the track, one per language. MTT creates a single model for all three document languages by combining the translations of MS-MARCO passages in all three languages into mixed-language batches. Thus the model learns about matching queries to passages simultaneously in all languages. Distillation uses scores from the mT5 model over non-English translated document pairs to learn how to score query-document pairs. The team submitted runs to all NeuCLIR tasks: the CLIR and MLIR news task as well as the technical documents task.
4/15/2024
Efficient Multi-Vector Dense Retrieval Using Bit Vectors
Franco Maria Nardini, Cosimo Rulli, Rossano Venturini
0
0
Dense retrieval techniques employ pre-trained large language models to build a high-dimensional representation of queries and passages. These representations compute the relevance of a passage w.r.t. to a query using efficient similarity measures. In this line, multi-vector representations show improved effectiveness at the expense of a one-order-of-magnitude increase in memory footprint and query latency by encoding queries and documents on a per-token level. Recently, PLAID has tackled these problems by introducing a centroid-based term representation to reduce the memory impact of multi-vector systems. By exploiting a centroid interaction mechanism, PLAID filters out non-relevant documents, thus reducing the cost of the successive ranking stages. This paper proposes ``Efficient Multi-Vector dense retrieval with Bit vectors'' (EMVB), a novel framework for efficient query processing in multi-vector dense retrieval. First, EMVB employs a highly efficient pre-filtering step of passages using optimized bit vectors. Second, the computation of the centroid interaction happens column-wise, exploiting SIMD instructions, thus reducing its latency. Third, EMVB leverages Product Quantization (PQ) to reduce the memory footprint of storing vector representations while jointly allowing for fast late interaction. Fourth, we introduce a per-document term filtering method that further improves the efficiency of the last step. Experiments on MS MARCO and LoTTE show that EMVB is up to 2.8x faster while reducing the memory footprint by 1.8x with no loss in retrieval accuracy compared to PLAID.
4/4/2024