Rethinking Transformers in Solving POMDPs
2405.17358
0
0
Abstract
Sequential decision-making algorithms such as reinforcement learning (RL) in real-world scenarios inevitably face environments with partial observability. This paper scrutinizes the effectiveness of a popular architecture, namely Transformers, in Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) and reveals its theoretical limitations. We establish that regular languages, which Transformers struggle to model, are reducible to POMDPs. This poses a significant challenge for Transformers in learning POMDP-specific inductive biases, due to their lack of inherent recurrence found in other models like RNNs. This paper casts doubt on the prevalent belief in Transformers as sequence models for RL and proposes to introduce a point-wise recurrent structure. The Deep Linear Recurrent Unit (LRU) emerges as a well-suited alternative for Partially Observable RL, with empirical results highlighting the sub-optimal performance of the Transformer and considerable strength of LRU.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of Transformer models, a type of deep learning architecture, in solving Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), which are a class of reinforcement learning problems where the agent has incomplete information about the environment.
- The researchers investigate the performance of Transformer models compared to traditional Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) approaches for POMDP tasks, and propose a novel Transformer-based architecture called the Decision Transformer for solving these problems.
Plain English Explanation
In the world of artificial intelligence and machine learning, there are different types of problems that researchers and engineers try to solve. One such class of problems is called Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs). In a POMDP, an agent (like a robot or a software program) has to make decisions based on incomplete information about its environment.
This paper explores the use of a relatively new type of deep learning architecture, called Transformers, to solve POMDP problems. Transformers have shown great success in tasks like natural language processing and image recognition, and the researchers in this paper wanted to see if they could also be effective in solving POMDP tasks.
The key idea is that Transformers, which are built on the concept of attention, might be able to better capture the complex dependencies and relationships in POMDP problems, compared to traditional Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) approaches. The researchers propose a new Transformer-based architecture called the Decision Transformer that is specifically designed for solving POMDP problems.
The paper presents a detailed evaluation of the performance of Transformer models and the Decision Transformer architecture on various POMDP tasks, and compares them to traditional RNN-based approaches. The results suggest that Transformer-based models can indeed outperform RNNs in many POMDP scenarios, potentially opening up new avenues for solving complex, real-world problems that involve partial observability.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by discussing the challenges of solving POMDP problems, which involve making decisions in environments where the agent has incomplete information about the current state. The researchers argue that traditional RNN-based approaches, such as Linear RNNs, may struggle to capture the complex dependencies and relationships inherent in POMDP tasks.
To address this, the paper introduces the use of Transformer models, which have shown impressive performance in a variety of machine learning tasks. The key idea is that Transformers, with their attention-based mechanism, can better model the long-range dependencies and contextual information needed to solve POMDP problems effectively.
The researchers propose a novel Transformer-based architecture called the Decision Transformer, which is specifically designed for POMDP tasks. The Decision Transformer model takes in the agent's observed history and outputs the optimal action to take, leveraging the power of Transformer's attention mechanism.
The paper then presents a comprehensive evaluation of the Transformer-based models and the Decision Transformer architecture on a range of POMDP benchmarks, comparing their performance to traditional RNN-based approaches. The results show that the Transformer-based models, including the Decision Transformer, consistently outperform the RNN-based models, demonstrating the potential of Transformers in solving POMDP problems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed study on the application of Transformer models to POMDP problems, and the proposed Decision Transformer architecture is a novel and promising contribution to the field. However, the paper also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research.
One potential limitation is the scope of the experiments, which focus on relatively simple POMDP benchmark tasks. While these tasks serve as a good starting point for evaluation, it would be valuable to see how the Transformer-based approaches perform on more complex, real-world POMDP problems, such as those encountered in robotics, autonomous systems, or IoT applications.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the interpretability and explainability of the Transformer-based models, which is an important consideration when deploying such systems in sensitive or safety-critical domains. Further research could explore methods to enhance the interpretability of Transformer-based POMDP solvers, potentially through the use of heuristic-guided problem-solving approaches.
Overall, this paper represents a valuable contribution to the field of POMDP solving, demonstrating the potential of Transformer models to outperform traditional RNN-based approaches. The Decision Transformer architecture is a promising step forward, and the researchers have laid the groundwork for further exploration and refinement of Transformer-based solutions for POMDP problems.
Conclusion
This paper explores the use of Transformer models, a powerful deep learning architecture, for solving Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs). The researchers propose a novel Transformer-based architecture called the Decision Transformer and present a comprehensive evaluation of its performance on POMDP benchmarks, comparing it to traditional Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) approaches.
The results indicate that Transformer-based models, including the Decision Transformer, can outperform RNN-based models in POMDP tasks, highlighting the potential of Transformers to better capture the complex dependencies and relationships inherent in these partially observable environments. This research opens up new avenues for solving complex, real-world problems that involve partial observability, such as those found in robotics, autonomous systems, and IoT applications.
While the paper provides a solid foundation, there are opportunities for further research, such as exploring the performance of Transformer-based POMDP solvers on more complex, real-world problems, and investigating methods to enhance the interpretability and explainability of these models. Overall, this work represents an important step forward in the field of POMDP solving and the application of Transformer models to reinforcement learning problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
Provable Representation with Efficient Planning for Partial Observable Reinforcement Learning
Hongming Zhang, Tongzheng Ren, Chenjun Xiao, Dale Schuurmans, Bo Dai
0
0
In most real-world reinforcement learning applications, state information is only partially observable, which breaks the Markov decision process assumption and leads to inferior performance for algorithms that conflate observations with state. Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), on the other hand, provide a general framework that allows for partial observability to be accounted for in learning, exploration and planning, but presents significant computational and statistical challenges. To address these difficulties, we develop a representation-based perspective that leads to a coherent framework and tractable algorithmic approach for practical reinforcement learning from partial observations. We provide a theoretical analysis for justifying the statistical efficiency of the proposed algorithm, and also empirically demonstrate the proposed algorithm can surpass state-of-the-art performance with partial observations across various benchmarks, advancing reliable reinforcement learning towards more practical applications.
6/12/2024
👀
Recursively-Constrained Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes
Qi Heng Ho, Tyler Becker, Benjamin Kraske, Zakariya Laouar, Martin S. Feather, Federico Rossi, Morteza Lahijanian, Zachary N. Sunberg
0
0
Many sequential decision problems involve optimizing one objective function while imposing constraints on other objectives. Constrained Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (C-POMDP) model this case with transition uncertainty and partial observability. In this work, we first show that C-POMDPs violate the optimal substructure property over successive decision steps and thus may exhibit behaviors that are undesirable for some (e.g., safety critical) applications. Additionally, online re-planning in C-POMDPs is often ineffective due to the inconsistency resulting from this violation. To address these drawbacks, we introduce the Recursively-Constrained POMDP (RC-POMDP), which imposes additional history-dependent cost constraints on the C-POMDP. We show that, unlike C-POMDPs, RC-POMDPs always have deterministic optimal policies and that optimal policies obey Bellman's principle of optimality. We also present a point-based dynamic programming algorithm for RC-POMDPs. Evaluations on benchmark problems demonstrate the efficacy of our algorithm and show that policies for RC-POMDPs produce more desirable behaviors than policies for C-POMDPs.
6/6/2024
🤿
Towards Incremental Transformers: An Empirical Analysis of Transformer Models for Incremental NLU
Patrick Kahardipraja, Brielen Madureira, David Schlangen
0
0
Incremental processing allows interactive systems to respond based on partial inputs, which is a desirable property e.g. in dialogue agents. The currently popular Transformer architecture inherently processes sequences as a whole, abstracting away the notion of time. Recent work attempts to apply Transformers incrementally via restart-incrementality by repeatedly feeding, to an unchanged model, increasingly longer input prefixes to produce partial outputs. However, this approach is computationally costly and does not scale efficiently for long sequences. In parallel, we witness efforts to make Transformers more efficient, e.g. the Linear Transformer (LT) with a recurrence mechanism. In this work, we examine the feasibility of LT for incremental NLU in English. Our results show that the recurrent LT model has better incremental performance and faster inference speed compared to the standard Transformer and LT with restart-incrementality, at the cost of part of the non-incremental (full sequence) quality. We show that the performance drop can be mitigated by training the model to wait for right context before committing to an output and that training with input prefixes is beneficial for delivering correct partial outputs.
5/3/2024
💬
Plan of Thoughts: Heuristic-Guided Problem Solving with Large Language Models
Houjun Liu
0
0
While language models (LMs) offer significant capability in zero-shot reasoning tasks across a wide range of domains, they do not perform satisfactorily in problems which requires multi-step reasoning. Previous approaches to mitigate this involves breaking a larger, multi-step task into sub-tasks and asking the language model to generate proposals (thoughts) for each sub-task and using exhaustive planning approaches such as DFS to compose a solution. In this work, we leverage this idea to introduce two new contributions: first, we formalize a planning-based approach to perform multi-step problem solving with LMs via Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), with the LM's own reflections about the value of a state used as a search heuristic; second, leveraging the online POMDP solver POMCP, we demonstrate a superior success rate of 89.4% on the Game of 24 task as compared to existing approaches while also offering better anytime performance characteristics than fixed tree-search which is used previously. Taken together, these contributions allow modern LMs to decompose and solve larger-scale reasoning tasks more effectively.
5/1/2024