REVEAL-IT: REinforcement learning with Visibility of Evolving Agent poLicy for InTerpretability
2406.14214
0
0
Abstract
Understanding the agent's learning process, particularly the factors that contribute to its success or failure post-training, is crucial for comprehending the rationale behind the agent's decision-making process. Prior methods clarify the learning process by creating a structural causal model (SCM) or visually representing the distribution of value functions. Nevertheless, these approaches have constraints as they exclusively function in 2D-environments or with uncomplicated transition dynamics. Understanding the agent's learning process in complicated environments or tasks is more challenging. In this paper, we propose REVEAL-IT, a novel framework for explaining the learning process of an agent in complex environments. Initially, we visualize the policy structure and the agent's learning process for various training tasks. By visualizing these findings, we can understand how much a particular training task or stage affects the agent's performance in test. Then, a GNN-based explainer learns to highlight the most important section of the policy, providing a more clear and robust explanation of the agent's learning process. The experiments demonstrate that explanations derived from this framework can effectively help in the optimization of the training tasks, resulting in improved learning efficiency and final performance.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents REVEAL-IT, a reinforcement learning (RL) framework that aims to provide interpretability and transparency into the agent's policy evolution during training.
- REVEAL-IT introduces a novel technique to visualize the agent's decision-making process and track the changes in its policy over time.
- The authors demonstrate REVEAL-IT's effectiveness on several RL benchmark tasks and compare it to other interpretable RL approaches.
Plain English Explanation
REVEAL-IT: REinforcement learning with Visibility of Evolving Agent poLicy for InTerpretability is a new reinforcement learning system that makes the agent's decision-making more transparent and understandable. Typically, reinforcement learning agents learn complex behaviors by trial and error, but it can be challenging to understand how they arrive at their decisions.
REVEAL-IT addresses this by providing a way to "look inside" the agent and see how its decision-making policy evolves over the course of training. The researchers developed a novel visualization technique that allows users to track changes in the agent's policy and better understand the reasoning behind its actions.
This transparency can be valuable for tasks where it's important to understand why the agent is making certain choices, such as in safety-critical applications or when training agents to interact with humans. By making the agent's decision-making more interpretable, REVEAL-IT could help build trust and accountability in reinforcement learning systems.
The paper demonstrates REVEAL-IT on several standard reinforcement learning benchmark tasks and compares it to other interpretable RL approaches. The results suggest that REVEAL-IT can provide meaningful insights into the agent's learning process without significantly compromising performance.
Technical Explanation
REVEAL-IT: REinforcement learning with Visibility of Evolving Agent poLicy for InTerpretability introduces a novel reinforcement learning framework that aims to provide interpretability and visibility into the agent's policy evolution during training.
The core idea behind REVEAL-IT is to augment the agent's learning process with an additional module that continuously tracks and visualizes changes in the agent's decision-making policy. This is achieved by introducing a "policy interpreter" that maps the agent's internal state representation to a set of interpretable and human-understandable features.
As the agent learns and updates its policy during training, REVEAL-IT records the evolution of these interpretable features over time, allowing users to observe and understand how the agent's decision-making process is changing. The authors demonstrate that this visibility can be achieved without significantly impacting the agent's overall performance on the task.
REVEAL-IT is evaluated on several reinforcement learning benchmark tasks, including classic control problems and more complex environments. The results show that REVEAL-IT can provide meaningful insights into the agent's learning process and outperforms other interpretable RL approaches in terms of both interpretability and task performance.
Critical Analysis
The REVEAL-IT paper presents a promising approach for improving the interpretability of reinforcement learning agents. By providing visibility into the agent's decision-making process, the authors aim to build trust and accountability in these systems, which is crucial for their widespread adoption, especially in safety-critical applications.
One potential limitation of the REVEAL-IT framework is that the interpretability of the agent's policy is heavily dependent on the choice of the policy interpreter module. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that further research is needed to develop more robust and generalizable interpretability techniques.
Additionally, the paper does not address the scalability of REVEAL-IT to more complex and high-dimensional environments. As the state and action spaces grow, the interpretability of the agent's policy may become more challenging to maintain.
The authors also mention the potential for REVEAL-IT to be combined with other interpretable RL approaches, such as those based on explainable AI (XAI) techniques. Exploring these synergies could lead to even more powerful and comprehensive interpretability solutions for reinforcement learning.
Conclusion
The REVEAL-IT framework represents an important step towards making reinforcement learning systems more transparent and interpretable. By providing a mechanism to visualize the agent's decision-making process and track the evolution of its policy, REVEAL-IT can help build trust and accountability in these systems, which is crucial for their widespread deployment, especially in safety-critical applications.
The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of REVEAL-IT on several benchmark tasks and suggests that the approach can provide meaningful insights into the agent's learning process without significantly compromising performance. While the framework has some limitations, the authors' work lays the foundation for further research into interpretable reinforcement learning, which could have significant implications for the field and its real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
INSIGHT: End-to-End Neuro-Symbolic Visual Reinforcement Learning with Language Explanations
Lirui Luo, Guoxi Zhang, Hongming Xu, Yaodong Yang, Cong Fang, Qing Li
0
0
Neuro-symbolic reinforcement learning (NS-RL) has emerged as a promising paradigm for explainable decision-making, characterized by the interpretability of symbolic policies. NS-RL entails structured state representations for tasks with visual observations, but previous methods cannot refine the structured states with rewards due to a lack of efficiency. Accessibility also remains an issue, as extensive domain knowledge is required to interpret symbolic policies. In this paper, we present a neuro-symbolic framework for jointly learning structured states and symbolic policies, whose key idea is to distill the vision foundation model into an efficient perception module and refine it during policy learning. Moreover, we design a pipeline to prompt GPT-4 to generate textual explanations for the learned policies and decisions, significantly reducing users' cognitive load to understand the symbolic policies. We verify the efficacy of our approach on nine Atari tasks and present GPT-generated explanations for policies and decisions.
6/14/2024
REACT: Revealing Evolutionary Action Consequence Trajectories for Interpretable Reinforcement Learning
Philipp Altmann, C'eline Davignon, Maximilian Zorn, Fabian Ritz, Claudia Linnhoff-Popien, Thomas Gabor
0
0
To enhance the interpretability of Reinforcement Learning (RL), we propose Revealing Evolutionary Action Consequence Trajectories (REACT). In contrast to the prevalent practice of validating RL models based on their optimal behavior learned during training, we posit that considering a range of edge-case trajectories provides a more comprehensive understanding of their inherent behavior. To induce such scenarios, we introduce a disturbance to the initial state, optimizing it through an evolutionary algorithm to generate a diverse population of demonstrations. To evaluate the fitness of trajectories, REACT incorporates a joint fitness function that encourages both local and global diversity in the encountered states and chosen actions. Through assessments with policies trained for varying durations in discrete and continuous environments, we demonstrate the descriptive power of REACT. Our results highlight its effectiveness in revealing nuanced aspects of RL models' behavior beyond optimal performance, thereby contributing to improved interpretability.
4/5/2024
EXPIL: Explanatory Predicate Invention for Learning in Games
Jingyuan Sha, Hikaru Shindo, Quentin Delfosse, Kristian Kersting, Devendra Singh Dhami
0
0
Reinforcement learning (RL) has proven to be a powerful tool for training agents that excel in various games. However, the black-box nature of neural network models often hinders our ability to understand the reasoning behind the agent's actions. Recent research has attempted to address this issue by using the guidance of pretrained neural agents to encode logic-based policies, allowing for interpretable decisions. A drawback of such approaches is the requirement of large amounts of predefined background knowledge in the form of predicates, limiting its applicability and scalability. In this work, we propose a novel approach, Explanatory Predicate Invention for Learning in Games (EXPIL), that identifies and extracts predicates from a pretrained neural agent, later used in the logic-based agents, reducing the dependency on predefined background knowledge. Our experimental evaluation on various games demonstrate the effectiveness of EXPIL in achieving explainable behavior in logic agents while requiring less background knowledge.
6/11/2024
SEER: Facilitating Structured Reasoning and Explanation via Reinforcement Learning
Guoxin Chen, Kexin Tang, Chao Yang, Fuying Ye, Yu Qiao, Yiming Qian
0
0
Elucidating the reasoning process with structured explanations from question to answer is crucial, as it significantly enhances the interpretability, traceability, and trustworthiness of question-answering (QA) systems. However, structured explanations demand models to perform intricately structured reasoning, which poses great challenges. Most existing methods focus on single-step reasoning through supervised learning, ignoring logical dependencies between steps. Moreover, existing reinforcement learning (RL) based methods overlook the structured relationships, underutilizing the potential of RL in structured reasoning. In this paper, we propose SEER, a novel method that maximizes a structure-based return to facilitate structured reasoning and explanation. Our proposed structure-based return precisely describes the hierarchical and branching structure inherent in structured reasoning, effectively capturing the intricate relationships between different reasoning steps. In addition, we introduce a fine-grained reward function to meticulously delineate diverse reasoning steps. Extensive experiments show that SEER significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods, achieving an absolute improvement of 6.9% over RL-based methods on EntailmentBank, a 4.4% average improvement on STREET benchmark, and exhibiting outstanding efficiency and cross-dataset generalization performance. Our code is available at https://github.com/Chen-GX/SEER.
6/5/2024