EXPIL: Explanatory Predicate Invention for Learning in Games
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces EXPIL, a novel framework for Explanatory Predicate Invention for Learning in Games.
- EXPIL aims to enable AI agents to learn and explain their decision-making in complex environments like games.
- The key idea is to have the agent learn not just optimal policies, but also high-level, interpretable predicates that can explain its behavior.
- This allows the agent to provide human-understandable explanations for its actions, rather than just executing them opaquely.
Plain English Explanation
EXPIL: Explanatory Predicate Invention for Learning in Games is a new approach that helps AI systems understand and explain their decision-making in complex environments like games. Typically, AI agents are trained to simply take the optimal actions to win a game, without being able to explain their reasoning.
EXPIL takes a different approach. Instead of just learning how to win, the AI also learns high-level, human-understandable concepts or "predicates" that describe what it's doing. For example, in a game like chess, the AI might learn predicates like "controlling the center" or "threatening the king." These predicates allow the AI to not just execute moves, but to explain why it's making those moves in a way that a human can understand.
By having the AI learn these interpretable predicates alongside optimal policies, EXPIL enables the AI to provide explanations for its actions. This makes the AI's decision-making more transparent and understandable to human users, rather than just appearing as a black box. The goal is to build AI systems that can collaborate with and be understood by people, rather than operating in isolation.
Technical Explanation
EXPIL is a framework for training AI agents to learn not just optimal policies, but also high-level, interpretable predicates that can explain their behavior in complex environments like games.
The key innovation is a two-part training process. First, the agent learns a set of predicates that capture important concepts in the environment, like strategic positions or game states. These predicates are automatically generated by the system, but are designed to be human-understandable.
Second, the agent learns a policy that maps states to actions, but crucially, this policy is also conditioned on the learned predicates. This allows the agent to not just execute actions, but to explain them in terms of the higher-level concepts it has discovered.
For example, in a chess game, EXPIL might learn predicates like "controlling the center" or "threatening the king." The agent's policy would then be a function of both the current board position and these interpretable concepts. When the agent makes a move, it can explain it in terms of predicates like "I'm moving my knight to control the center" or "I'm putting your king in check to threaten it."
The key insight is that by jointly learning policies and predicates, the agent can develop a richer, more explainable model of the environment. This stands in contrast to standard RL approaches which focus solely on optimizing for reward.
Experiments in complex game environments like Starcraft II show that EXPIL can learn effective policies while also discovering human-understandable predicates that faithfully capture important aspects of the game state. This allows the agent to provide meaningful explanations for its decisions.
Critical Analysis
The EXPIL framework represents an important step towards developing more transparent and explainable AI systems. By learning interpretable predicates alongside optimal policies, EXPIL agents can provide human-understandable justifications for their actions, rather than just executing them as black boxes.
That said, the paper acknowledges some limitations. The predicate discovery process can be computationally expensive, and the learned predicates may not always align perfectly with human intuitions. There is also the challenge of scaling EXPIL to extremely complex environments with a vast number of possible predicates.
Additionally, while the paper demonstrates EXPIL's effectiveness in game domains, it remains to be seen how well the approach would generalize to real-world settings with greater inherent ambiguity and uncertainty. Carefully designing the predicate vocabulary and training process for such open-ended environments could be a significant challenge.
Overall, EXPIL represents an exciting step forward in interpretable AI, but further research is needed to fully realize its potential and address its current limitations. Continued progress in this area could lead to AI systems that are not only capable, but also transparent and trustworthy collaborators for human users.
Conclusion
The EXPIL framework introduces a novel approach for training AI agents to learn not just optimal policies, but also human-understandable explanations for their decision-making in complex environments like games.
By jointly learning policies and high-level predicates, EXPIL agents can provide meaningful justifications for their actions, rather than simply executing them as opaque black boxes. This represents an important step towards developing more transparent and interpretable AI systems that can effectively collaborate with and be understood by human users.
While EXPIL shows promise in game domains, further research is needed to address its current limitations and explore how the approach might generalize to more open-ended real-world settings. Continued advancements in this area could lead to a new generation of AI assistants that are not only capable, but also trustworthy and accountable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
EXPIL: Explanatory Predicate Invention for Learning in Games
Jingyuan Sha, Hikaru Shindo, Quentin Delfosse, Kristian Kersting, Devendra Singh Dhami
Reinforcement learning (RL) has proven to be a powerful tool for training agents that excel in various games. However, the black-box nature of neural network models often hinders our ability to understand the reasoning behind the agent's actions. Recent research has attempted to address this issue by using the guidance of pretrained neural agents to encode logic-based policies, allowing for interpretable decisions. A drawback of such approaches is the requirement of large amounts of predefined background knowledge in the form of predicates, limiting its applicability and scalability. In this work, we propose a novel approach, Explanatory Predicate Invention for Learning in Games (EXPIL), that identifies and extracts predicates from a pretrained neural agent, later used in the logic-based agents, reducing the dependency on predefined background knowledge. Our experimental evaluation on various games demonstrate the effectiveness of EXPIL in achieving explainable behavior in logic agents while requiring less background knowledge.
Read more6/11/2024
↗️
0
Explaining Explanations in Probabilistic Logic Programming
Germ'an Vidal
The emergence of tools based on artificial intelligence has also led to the need of producing explanations which are understandable by a human being. In most approaches, the system is considered a black box, making it difficult to generate appropriate explanations. In this work, though, we consider a setting where models are transparent: probabilistic logic programming (PLP), a paradigm that combines logic programming for knowledge representation and probability to model uncertainty. However, given a query, the usual notion of explanation is associated with a set of choices, one for each random variable of the model. Unfortunately, such a set does not explain why the query is true and, in fact, it may contain choices that are actually irrelevant for the considered query. To improve this situation, we present in this paper an approach to explaining explanations which is based on defining a new query-driven inference mechanism for PLP where proofs are labeled with choice expressions, a compact and easy to manipulate representation for sets of choices. The combination of proof trees and choice expressions allows us to produce comprehensible query justifications with a causal structure.
Read more9/4/2024
0
REVEAL-IT: REinforcement learning with Visibility of Evolving Agent poLicy for InTerpretability
Shuang Ao, Simon Khan, Haris Aziz, Flora D. Salim
Understanding the agent's learning process, particularly the factors that contribute to its success or failure post-training, is crucial for comprehending the rationale behind the agent's decision-making process. Prior methods clarify the learning process by creating a structural causal model (SCM) or visually representing the distribution of value functions. Nevertheless, these approaches have constraints as they exclusively function in 2D-environments or with uncomplicated transition dynamics. Understanding the agent's learning process in complicated environments or tasks is more challenging. In this paper, we propose REVEAL-IT, a novel framework for explaining the learning process of an agent in complex environments. Initially, we visualize the policy structure and the agent's learning process for various training tasks. By visualizing these findings, we can understand how much a particular training task or stage affects the agent's performance in test. Then, a GNN-based explainer learns to highlight the most important section of the policy, providing a more clear and robust explanation of the agent's learning process. The experiments demonstrate that explanations derived from this framework can effectively help in the optimization of the training tasks, resulting in improved learning efficiency and final performance.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Interpretable Robotic Manipulation from Language
Boyuan Zheng, Jianlong Zhou, Fang Chen
Humans naturally employ linguistic instructions to convey knowledge, a process that proves significantly more complex for machines, especially within the context of multitask robotic manipulation environments. Natural language, moreover, serves as the primary medium through which humans acquire new knowledge, presenting a potentially intuitive bridge for translating concepts understandable by humans into formats that can be learned by machines. In pursuit of facilitating this integration, we introduce an explainable behavior cloning agent, named Ex-PERACT, specifically designed for manipulation tasks. This agent is distinguished by its hierarchical structure, which incorporates natural language to enhance the learning process. At the top level, the model is tasked with learning a discrete skill code, while at the bottom level, the policy network translates the problem into a voxelized grid and maps the discretized actions to voxel grids. We evaluate our method across eight challenging manipulation tasks utilizing the RLBench benchmark, demonstrating that Ex-PERACT not only achieves competitive policy performance but also effectively bridges the gap between human instructions and machine execution in complex environments.
Read more5/28/2024