Revisiting, Benchmarking and Understanding Unsupervised Graph Domain Adaptation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper revisits and benchmarks unsupervised graph domain adaptation, a technique for transferring knowledge from one graph domain to another without labeled data.
- The authors investigate the performance of existing unsupervised graph domain adaptation methods across various real-world datasets and tasks.
- They identify several key issues with current approaches and propose new directions for improving the reliability and generalization of unsupervised graph domain adaptation.
Plain English Explanation
Unsupervised graph domain adaptation is a way to transfer knowledge between different types of graph-structured data, like social networks or biological molecules, without having labeled examples for training. The authors of this paper wanted to take a closer look at how well the existing methods for this task actually work in practice.
They tested these methods on real-world datasets covering different applications, like predicting properties of chemical compounds or classifying users in social networks. The results showed that the current approaches have some significant limitations - they don't always generalize well to new data, and their performance can be quite inconsistent.
Based on their findings, the authors suggest new directions for improving unsupervised graph domain adaptation. This could involve finding better ways to capture the underlying structure and relationships in the data, or developing more robust algorithms that can handle the complexities of real-world graph-structured information.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the performance of existing unsupervised graph domain adaptation methods on a variety of real-world datasets and tasks. The authors benchmark several well-known techniques, including Multi-Source Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Graphs, Gradually Vanishing Gap in Prototypical Network for Unsupervised Domain Adaptation, and Style Adaptation for Domain-Adaptive Semantic Segmentation.
Their experiments cover diverse applications such as node classification, graph classification, and link prediction. The results reveal several key issues with the current state-of-the-art, including poor generalization to new domains, high sensitivity to hyperparameter settings, and difficulty in leveraging higher-order graph structures like hypergraphs.
Based on these findings, the authors propose new research directions to improve the reliability and transferability of unsupervised graph domain adaptation. This could involve developing more robust and fair adaptation techniques that can better capture the underlying graph properties and relationships.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable benchmarking study that highlights the limitations of existing unsupervised graph domain adaptation methods. The authors acknowledge that their findings are limited to the specific datasets and tasks considered, and that further research is needed to fully understand the generalization capabilities of these techniques.
One potential issue not discussed in the paper is the sensitivity of graph-based methods to the quality and completeness of the input data. Real-world graphs often suffer from missing or noisy information, which could significantly impact the performance of adaptation algorithms. Addressing these data quality challenges may be an important area for future work.
The authors also do not delve deeply into the reasons behind the poor generalization observed in their experiments. Understanding the underlying factors that contribute to the lack of transferability could help guide the development of more robust and reliable adaptation approaches.
Conclusion
This paper offers a critical look at the current state of unsupervised graph domain adaptation, an important technique for transferring knowledge between different types of graph-structured data. The authors' extensive benchmarking study reveals several key limitations of existing methods, including poor generalization, sensitivity to hyperparameters, and difficulty in leveraging higher-order graph structures.
Based on these findings, the authors propose new research directions to improve the reliability and transferability of unsupervised graph domain adaptation. Developing more robust and data-efficient adaptation algorithms, as well as better understanding the factors that influence generalization, could have significant implications for a wide range of graph-based applications, from social network analysis to drug discovery.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Revisiting, Benchmarking and Understanding Unsupervised Graph Domain Adaptation
Meihan Liu, Zhen Zhang, Jiachen Tang, Jiajun Bu, Bingsheng He, Sheng Zhou
Unsupervised Graph Domain Adaptation (UGDA) involves the transfer of knowledge from a label-rich source graph to an unlabeled target graph under domain discrepancies. Despite the proliferation of methods designed for this emerging task, the lack of standard experimental settings and fair performance comparisons makes it challenging to understand which and when models perform well across different scenarios. To fill this gap, we present the first comprehensive benchmark for unsupervised graph domain adaptation named GDABench, which encompasses 16 algorithms across 5 datasets with 74 adaptation tasks. Through extensive experiments, we observe that the performance of current UGDA models varies significantly across different datasets and adaptation scenarios. Specifically, we recognize that when the source and target graphs face significant distribution shifts, it is imperative to formulate strategies to effectively address and mitigate graph structural shifts. We also find that with appropriate neighbourhood aggregation mechanisms, simple GNN variants can even surpass state-of-the-art UGDA baselines. To facilitate reproducibility, we have developed an easy-to-use library PyGDA for training and evaluating existing UGDA methods, providing a standardized platform in this community. Our source codes and datasets can be found at: https://github.com/pygda-team/pygda.
Read more7/17/2024
0
Can Modifying Data Address Graph Domain Adaptation?
Renhong Huang, Jiarong Xu, Xin Jiang, Ruichuan An, Yang Yang
Graph neural networks (GNNs) have demonstrated remarkable success in numerous graph analytical tasks. Yet, their effectiveness is often compromised in real-world scenarios due to distribution shifts, limiting their capacity for knowledge transfer across changing environments or domains. Recently, Unsupervised Graph Domain Adaptation (UGDA) has been introduced to resolve this issue. UGDA aims to facilitate knowledge transfer from a labeled source graph to an unlabeled target graph. Current UGDA efforts primarily focus on model-centric methods, such as employing domain invariant learning strategies and designing model architectures. However, our critical examination reveals the limitations inherent to these model-centric methods, while a data-centric method allowed to modify the source graph provably demonstrates considerable potential. This insight motivates us to explore UGDA from a data-centric perspective. By revisiting the theoretical generalization bound for UGDA, we identify two data-centric principles for UGDA: alignment principle and rescaling principle. Guided by these principles, we propose GraphAlign, a novel UGDA method that generates a small yet transferable graph. By exclusively training a GNN on this new graph with classic Empirical Risk Minimization (ERM), GraphAlign attains exceptional performance on the target graph. Extensive experiments under various transfer scenarios demonstrate the GraphAlign outperforms the best baselines by an average of 2.16%, training on the generated graph as small as 0.25~1% of the original training graph.
Read more7/30/2024
🤷
0
Multi-source Unsupervised Domain Adaptation on Graphs with Transferability Modeling
Tianxiang Zhao, Dongsheng Luo, Xiang Zhang, Suhang Wang
In this paper, we tackle a new problem of textit{multi-source unsupervised domain adaptation (MSUDA) for graphs}, where models trained on annotated source domains need to be transferred to the unsupervised target graph for node classification. Due to the discrepancy in distribution across domains, the key challenge is how to select good source instances and how to adapt the model. Diverse graph structures further complicate this problem, rendering previous MSUDA approaches less effective. In this work, we present the framework Selective Multi-source Adaptation for Graph ({method}), with a graph-modeling-based domain selector, a sub-graph node selector, and a bi-level alignment objective for the adaptation. Concretely, to facilitate the identification of informative source data, the similarity across graphs is disentangled and measured with the transferability of a graph-modeling task set, and we use it as evidence for source domain selection. A node selector is further incorporated to capture the variation in transferability of nodes within the same source domain. To learn invariant features for adaptation, we align the target domain to selected source data both at the embedding space by minimizing the optimal transport distance and at the classification level by distilling the label function. Modules are explicitly learned to select informative source data and conduct the alignment in virtual training splits with a meta-learning strategy. Experimental results on five graph datasets show the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Read more6/26/2024
0
Gradually Vanishing Gap in Prototypical Network for Unsupervised Domain Adaptation
Shanshan Wang, Hao Zhou, Xun Yang, Zhenwei He, Mengzhu Wang, Xingyi Zhang, Meng Wang
Unsupervised domain adaptation (UDA) is a critical problem for transfer learning, which aims to transfer the semantic information from labeled source domain to unlabeled target domain. Recent advancements in UDA models have demonstrated significant generalization capabilities on the target domain. However, the generalization boundary of UDA models remains unclear. When the domain discrepancy is too large, the model can not preserve the distribution structure, leading to distribution collapse during the alignment. To address this challenge, we propose an efficient UDA framework named Gradually Vanishing Gap in Prototypical Network (GVG-PN), which achieves transfer learning from both global and local perspectives. From the global alignment standpoint, our model generates a domain-biased intermediate domain that helps preserve the distribution structures. By entangling cross-domain features, our model progressively reduces the risk of distribution collapse. However, only relying on global alignment is insufficient to preserve the distribution structure. To further enhance the inner relationships of features, we introduce the local perspective. We utilize the graph convolutional network (GCN) as an intuitive method to explore the internal relationships between features, ensuring the preservation of manifold structures and generating domain-biased prototypes. Additionally, we consider the discriminability of the inner relationships between features. We propose a pro-contrastive loss to enhance the discriminability at the prototype level by separating hard negative pairs. By incorporating both GCN and the pro-contrastive loss, our model fully explores fine-grained semantic relationships. Experiments on several UDA benchmarks validated that the proposed GVG-PN can clearly outperform the SOTA models.
Read more5/29/2024