Revisiting the Power of Prompt for Visual Tuning
0
🤔
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores a promising solution called Visual Prompt Tuning (VPT) that customizes pre-trained models for downstream tasks using learnable prompt tokens.
- However, VPT and its variants often face challenges like prompt initialization, prompt length, and subpar performance in self-supervised pretraining, hindering successful contextual adaptation.
- The study investigates the correlation between prompts and patch tokens during training, and proposes a strategic initialization method to address these challenges.
- The authors also introduce a streamlined pipeline to optimize token construction, which maintains excellent performance with minimal computational overhead compared to VPT.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a technique called Visual Prompt Tuning (VPT) that can help customize pre-trained AI models for new tasks. VPT works by adding "prompt tokens" - small pieces of information - to the model, which allows it to adapt to the new task.
However, the researchers found that VPT and similar methods often run into problems. For example, it can be tricky to figure out how to initialize the prompt tokens, and the models don't always perform well when they're trained on large, unlabeled datasets (a common technique called "self-supervised pretraining").
To address these issues, the researchers explored how the prompt tokens interact with the other parts of the AI model during training. They noticed that the prompt tokens tend to share a lot of information with the "patch tokens" - small pieces that the model uses to understand the input data.
Inspired by this observation, the researchers developed a new way to initialize the prompt tokens that uses information from the patch tokens. This helps the model perform better when it's fine-tuned for a specific task.
The researchers also streamlined the process of constructing the prompt tokens, which allows the model to maintain excellent performance while using only a tiny fraction of the total parameters (the learnable parts of the model).
Overall, the researchers' approach seems to outperform existing methods, particularly when it comes to adapting pre-trained models to new tasks. It's a promising step forward in making AI models more flexible and easier to customize for different applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel approach called Self-Prompt Tuning (SPT) to address the challenges faced by Visual Prompt Tuning (VPT) and its variants.
The researchers first explore the evolving correlation between prompts and patch tokens during the training process. They observe that the prompt tokens tend to share high mutual information with the patch tokens, which inspires them to initialize the prompts using downstream token prototypes.
This strategic initialization, which replaces the previous random initialization, substantially improves the performance of the model when fine-tuning it for downstream tasks. To further refine the approach, the researchers optimize the token construction with a streamlined pipeline that maintains excellent performance with almost no increase in computational cost compared to VPT.
Extensive experiments show that the proposed SPT approach outperforms existing methods by a significant margin. For instance, it surpasses full fine-tuning in 19 out of 24 tasks on the FGVC and VTAB-1K benchmarks, while using less than 0.4% of the learnable parameters.
Notably, the researchers' method also significantly advances the adaptation for self-supervised pretraining, achieving impressive task performance gains of at least 10% to 30%. The experimental results demonstrate that SPT is robust to prompt lengths and scales well with model capacity and training data size.
Finally, the paper provides an insightful exploration into the amount of target data required to facilitate the adaptation of pre-trained models to downstream tasks.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful and well-designed approach to address the limitations of existing visual prompt tuning methods. The strategic initialization of prompts using downstream token prototypes, and the streamlined pipeline for token construction, are both innovative and effective solutions.
One potential area for further research is the exploration of alternative prompt initialization strategies, beyond the current approach of using downstream token prototypes. The authors of "Can Better Text Semantics from Prompt Tuning Improve Visual Understanding?" have explored the use of text-based prompts to guide the initialization of visual prompts, which could be an interesting direction to investigate.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential limitations or drawbacks of the proposed SPT approach. While the results are impressive, it would be valuable to understand the scenarios or tasks where SPT may not perform as well, and to explore potential mitigation strategies.
Overall, the paper presents a compelling and well-executed study that advances the state of the art in visual prompt tuning. The insights and techniques developed in this work could have significant implications for the broader field of text-as-image multi-label image classification and progressive multi-modal conditional prompt tuning.
Conclusion
The proposed Self-Prompt Tuning (SPT) approach offers a promising solution to the challenges faced by existing Visual Prompt Tuning (VPT) methods. By strategically initializing prompts using downstream token prototypes and optimizing the token construction pipeline, SPT demonstrates superior performance on a range of tasks while using a fraction of the learnable parameters.
The researchers' insights into the correlation between prompts and patch tokens, and their ability to leverage this understanding to improve model adaptation, represent a significant advancement in the field of prompt-based fine-tuning. The scalability and robustness of SPT to prompt lengths and model capacity further highlight its potential for widespread application.
As the research community continues to explore ways to make pre-trained models more flexible and customizable, the techniques and findings presented in this paper will undoubtedly serve as a valuable resource and inspiration for future work in this domain.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤔
0
Revisiting the Power of Prompt for Visual Tuning
Yuzhu Wang, Lechao Cheng, Chaowei Fang, Dingwen Zhang, Manni Duan, Meng Wang
Visual prompt tuning (VPT) is a promising solution incorporating learnable prompt tokens to customize pre-trained models for downstream tasks. However, VPT and its variants often encounter challenges like prompt initialization, prompt length, and subpar performance in self-supervised pretraining, hindering successful contextual adaptation. This study commences by exploring the correlation evolvement between prompts and patch tokens during proficient training. Inspired by the observation that the prompt tokens tend to share high mutual information with patch tokens, we propose initializing prompts with downstream token prototypes. The strategic initialization, a stand-in for the previous initialization, substantially improves performance in fine-tuning. To refine further, we optimize token construction with a streamlined pipeline that maintains excellent performance with almost no increase in computational expenses compared to VPT. Exhaustive experiments show our proposed approach outperforms existing methods by a remarkable margin. For instance, it surpasses full fine-tuning in 19 out of 24 tasks, using less than 0.4% of learnable parameters on the FGVC and VTAB-1K benchmarks. Notably, our method significantly advances the adaptation for self-supervised pretraining, achieving impressive task performance gains of at least 10% to 30%. Besides, the experimental results demonstrate the proposed SPT is robust to prompt lengths and scales well with model capacity and training data size. We finally provide an insightful exploration into the amount of target data facilitating the adaptation of pre-trained models to downstream tasks. The code is available at https://github.com/WangYZ1608/Self-Prompt-Tuning.
Read more5/28/2024
🧪
0
Do We Really Need a Large Number of Visual Prompts?
Youngeun Kim, Yuhang Li, Abhishek Moitra, Ruokai Yin, Priyadarshini Panda
Due to increasing interest in adapting models on resource-constrained edges, parameter-efficient transfer learning has been widely explored. Among various methods, Visual Prompt Tuning (VPT), prepending learnable prompts to input space, shows competitive fine-tuning performance compared to training of full network parameters. However, VPT increases the number of input tokens, resulting in additional computational overhead. In this paper, we analyze the impact of the number of prompts on fine-tuning performance and self-attention operation in a vision transformer architecture. Through theoretical and empirical analysis we show that adding more prompts does not lead to linear performance improvement. Further, we propose a Prompt Condensation (PC) technique that aims to prevent performance degradation from using a small number of prompts. We validate our methods on FGVC and VTAB-1k tasks and show that our approach reduces the number of prompts by ~70% while maintaining accuracy.
Read more5/14/2024
0
CVPT: Cross-Attention help Visual Prompt Tuning adapt visual task
Lingyun Huang, Jianxu Mao, Yaonan Wang, Junfei Yi, Ziming Tao
In recent years, the rapid expansion of model sizes has led to large-scale pre-trained models demonstrating remarkable capabilities. Consequently, there has been a trend towards increasing the scale of models. However, this trend introduces significant challenges, including substantial computational costs of training and transfer to downstream tasks. To address these issues, Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods have been introduced. These methods optimize large-scale pre-trained models for specific tasks by fine-tuning a select group of parameters. Among these PEFT methods, adapter-based and prompt-based methods are the primary techniques. Specifically, in the field of visual fine-tuning, adapters gain prominence over prompts because of the latter's relatively weaker performance and efficiency. Under the circumstances, we refine the widely-used Visual Prompt Tuning (VPT) method, proposing Cross Visual Prompt Tuning (CVPT). CVPT calculates cross-attention between the prompt tokens and the embedded tokens, which allows us to compute the semantic relationship between them and conduct the fine-tuning of models exactly to adapt visual tasks better. Furthermore, we introduce the weight-sharing mechanism to initialize the parameters of cross-attention, which avoids massive learnable parameters from cross-attention and enhances the representative capability of cross-attention. We conduct comprehensive testing across 25 datasets and the result indicates that CVPT significantly improves VPT's performance and efficiency in visual tasks. For example, on the VTAB-1K benchmark, CVPT outperforms VPT over 4% in average accuracy, rivaling the advanced adapter-based methods in performance and efficiency. Our experiments confirm that prompt-based methods can achieve exceptional results in visual fine-tuning.
Read more8/28/2024
0
Efficient Test-Time Prompt Tuning for Vision-Language Models
Yuhan Zhu, Guozhen Zhang, Chen Xu, Haocheng Shen, Xiaoxin Chen, Gangshan Wu, Limin Wang
Vision-language models have showcased impressive zero-shot classification capabilities when equipped with suitable text prompts. Previous studies have shown the effectiveness of test-time prompt tuning; however, these methods typically require per-image prompt adaptation during inference, which incurs high computational budgets and limits scalability and practical deployment. To overcome this issue, we introduce Self-TPT, a novel framework leveraging Self-supervised learning for efficient Test-time Prompt Tuning. The key aspect of Self-TPT is that it turns to efficient predefined class adaptation via self-supervised learning, thus avoiding computation-heavy per-image adaptation at inference. Self-TPT begins by co-training the self-supervised and the classification task using source data, then applies the self-supervised task exclusively for test-time new class adaptation. Specifically, we propose Contrastive Prompt Learning (CPT) as the key task for self-supervision. CPT is designed to minimize the intra-class distances while enhancing inter-class distinguishability via contrastive learning. Furthermore, empirical evidence suggests that CPT could closely mimic back-propagated gradients of the classification task, offering a plausible explanation for its effectiveness. Motivated by this finding, we further introduce a gradient matching loss to explicitly enhance the gradient similarity. We evaluated Self-TPT across three challenging zero-shot benchmarks. The results consistently demonstrate that Self-TPT not only significantly reduces inference costs but also achieves state-of-the-art performance, effectively balancing the efficiency-efficacy trade-off.
Read more8/13/2024