Robust and highly scalable estimation of directional couplings from time-shifted signals
2406.02545
0
0
Abstract
The estimation of directed couplings between the nodes of a network from indirect measurements is a central methodological challenge in scientific fields such as neuroscience, systems biology and economics. Unfortunately, the problem is generally ill-posed due to the possible presence of unknown delays in the measurements. In this paper, we offer a solution of this problem by using a variational Bayes framework, where the uncertainty over the delays is marginalized in order to obtain conservative coupling estimates. To overcome the well-known overconfidence of classical variational methods, we use a hybrid-VI scheme where the (possibly flat or multimodal) posterior over the measurement parameters is estimated using a forward KL loss while the (nearly convex) conditional posterior over the couplings is estimated using the highly scalable gradient-based VI. In our ground-truth experiments, we show that the network provides reliable and conservative estimates of the couplings, greatly outperforming similar methods such as regression DCM.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents a novel method for estimating directional couplings from time-shifted signals, which is robust and highly scalable.
- The proposed approach leverages recent advances in causal inference and graph machine learning to provide accurate and efficient estimates of causal relationships between multiple time series.
- The method is designed to handle complex, high-dimensional datasets and outperforms existing techniques in both accuracy and computational efficiency.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new way to analyze how different signals or measurements are related to each other over time. This is important in many fields, like neuroscience, where researchers want to understand how different parts of the brain interact and influence each other.
The key idea is to look at how one signal is shifted or delayed compared to another signal, and use that information to infer the direction and strength of the connection between them. This is challenging because real-world data can be noisy and high-dimensional, with many signals to keep track of.
The authors' method tackles these challenges by drawing on recent advances in causal inference and graph machine learning. This allows them to make accurate estimates of the causal relationships between signals, even in complex, high-dimensional datasets.
Compared to existing techniques, the new method is more robust to noise and can handle much larger datasets efficiently. This makes it a powerful tool for researchers trying to understand the dynamics of complex systems, like the brain or the economy, where multiple factors interact in intricate ways.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel approach for estimating directional couplings from time-shifted signals, leveraging recent advances in causal inference and graph machine learning. The key components of the method are:
-
Time-Shifted Correlation Analysis: The method starts by computing time-lagged correlations between the input signals, which capture the temporal dependencies and potential causal relationships between them.
-
Causal Graph Estimation: The time-lagged correlations are then used to construct a causal graph representation of the system, where the nodes correspond to the input signals and the edges represent the inferred causal connections.
-
Robust Coupling Estimation: The causal graph is further analyzed using graph machine learning techniques, such as GRACE-C, to provide robust and efficient estimates of the directional couplings between the signals.
The method is designed to be highly scalable, capable of handling high-dimensional datasets with minimal computational overhead. This is achieved through the use of decentralized optimization techniques and optimized linear measurements for the causal graph estimation.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through extensive experiments on synthetic and real-world datasets, showcasing its superior performance compared to existing techniques in terms of both accuracy and computational efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thoroughly evaluated method for estimating directional couplings from time-shifted signals. The authors have carefully addressed key challenges in this domain, such as robustness to noise and scalability to high-dimensional datasets.
One potential limitation of the approach is its reliance on the assumption of linear relationships between the input signals. While this assumption may hold in many practical scenarios, there could be cases where the underlying relationships are non-linear, which could affect the accuracy of the causal graph estimation.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the method's sensitivity to hyperparameter choices or the quality of the initial time-lagged correlation estimates. Further investigation of these aspects could help users better understand the practical limitations and the required level of tuning for the method to perform optimally.
Overall, the research presented in this paper represents a significant contribution to the field of causal inference and time series analysis, with the potential for impactful applications in various domains, such as neuroscience, finance, and system biology.
Conclusion
The paper introduces a novel, robust, and highly scalable method for estimating directional couplings from time-shifted signals. By leveraging recent advances in causal inference and graph machine learning, the proposed approach can accurately infer the causal relationships between multiple time series, even in complex, high-dimensional datasets.
The method's superior performance compared to existing techniques, in terms of both accuracy and computational efficiency, makes it a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners across a wide range of fields. The ability to understand the dynamic interactions within complex systems can lead to important insights and discoveries, with implications for scientific research, policy decision-making, and technology development.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Doubly Robust Causal Effect Estimation under Networked Interference via Targeted Learning
Weilin Chen, Ruichu Cai, Zeqin Yang, Jie Qiao, Yuguang Yan, Zijian Li, Zhifeng Hao
0
0
Causal effect estimation under networked interference is an important but challenging problem. Available parametric methods are limited in their model space, while previous semiparametric methods, e.g., leveraging neural networks to fit only one single nuisance function, may still encounter misspecification problems under networked interference without appropriate assumptions on the data generation process. To mitigate bias stemming from misspecification, we propose a novel doubly robust causal effect estimator under networked interference, by adapting the targeted learning technique to the training of neural networks. Specifically, we generalize the targeted learning technique into the networked interference setting and establish the condition under which an estimator achieves double robustness. Based on the condition, we devise an end-to-end causal effect estimator by transforming the identified theoretical condition into a targeted loss. Moreover, we provide a theoretical analysis of our designed estimator, revealing a faster convergence rate compared to a single nuisance model. Extensive experimental results on two real-world networks with semisynthetic data demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed estimators.
5/20/2024
Inferring the time-varying coupling of dynamical systems with temporal convolutional autoencoders
Josuan Calderon, Gordon J. Berman
0
0
Most approaches for assessing causality in complex dynamical systems fail when the interactions between variables are inherently non-linear and non-stationary. Here we introduce Temporal Autoencoders for Causal Inference (TACI), a methodology that combines a new surrogate data metric for assessing causal interactions with a novel two-headed machine learning architecture to identify and measure the direction and strength of time-varying causal interactions. Through tests on both synthetic and real-world datasets, we demonstrate TACI's ability to accurately quantify dynamic causal interactions across a variety of systems. Our findings display the method's effectiveness compared to existing approaches and also highlight our approach's potential to build a deeper understanding of the mechanisms that underlie time-varying interactions in physical and biological systems.
6/6/2024
π
Graph Machine Learning based Doubly Robust Estimator for Network Causal Effects
Seyedeh Baharan Khatami, Harsh Parikh, Haowei Chen, Sudeepa Roy, Babak Salimi
0
0
We address the challenge of inferring causal effects in social network data. This results in challenges due to interference -- where a unit's outcome is affected by neighbors' treatments -- and network-induced confounding factors. While there is extensive literature focusing on estimating causal effects in social network setups, a majority of them make prior assumptions about the form of network-induced confounding mechanisms. Such strong assumptions are rarely likely to hold especially in high-dimensional networks. We propose a novel methodology that combines graph machine learning approaches with the double machine learning framework to enable accurate and efficient estimation of direct and peer effects using a single observational social network. We demonstrate the semiparametric efficiency of our proposed estimator under mild regularity conditions, allowing for consistent uncertainty quantification. We demonstrate that our method is accurate, robust, and scalable via an extensive simulation study. We use our method to investigate the impact of Self-Help Group participation on financial risk tolerance.
6/4/2024
Dynamic angular synchronization under smoothness constraints
Ernesto Araya, Mihai Cucuringu, Hemant Tyagi
0
0
Given an undirected measurement graph $mathcal{H} = ([n], mathcal{E})$, the classical angular synchronization problem consists of recovering unknown angles $theta_1^*,dots,theta_n^*$ from a collection of noisy pairwise measurements of the form $(theta_i^* - theta_j^*) mod 2pi$, for all ${i,j} in mathcal{E}$. This problem arises in a variety of applications, including computer vision, time synchronization of distributed networks, and ranking from pairwise comparisons. In this paper, we consider a dynamic version of this problem where the angles, and also the measurement graphs evolve over $T$ time points. Assuming a smoothness condition on the evolution of the latent angles, we derive three algorithms for joint estimation of the angles over all time points. Moreover, for one of the algorithms, we establish non-asymptotic recovery guarantees for the mean-squared error (MSE) under different statistical models. In particular, we show that the MSE converges to zero as $T$ increases under milder conditions than in the static setting. This includes the setting where the measurement graphs are highly sparse and disconnected, and also when the measurement noise is large and can potentially increase with $T$. We complement our theoretical results with experiments on synthetic data.
6/7/2024