Robust off-policy Reinforcement Learning via Soft Constrained Adversary
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Presents a novel approach for robust off-policy reinforcement learning (RL) called "Soft Constrained Adversary" (SCA)
- Aims to improve the robustness of RL agents against adversarial attacks and distributional shift
- Introduces a soft constrained adversary that is trained to find the worst-case distribution shift within a pre-defined constraint set
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new method called Soft Constrained Adversary (SCA) to make reinforcement learning (RL) systems more robust and resilient. RL systems are algorithms that learn to make decisions in complex environments, like playing games or controlling robots. However, these systems can be vulnerable to adversarial attacks, where small changes to the environment can trick the system and cause it to make poor decisions.
The SCA approach tries to address this problem by training an "adversary" - a separate algorithm that tries to find the worst-case changes to the environment that would trip up the RL system. The key idea is that by training the RL system to perform well even in the face of this adversarial "worst-case" scenario, it becomes more robust and less susceptible to attacks or unexpected changes in the environment.
Importantly, the SCA approach uses a "soft constraint" on the adversary, which means it can only make limited changes to the environment, rather than being able to make arbitrary, unrealistic changes. This helps ensure the adversary's attacks are plausible and the resulting RL system is truly robust in practice.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel framework called Soft Constrained Adversary (SCA) for improving the robustness of off-policy reinforcement learning (RL) agents. The key innovation is the use of a soft-constrained adversary that is trained to find the worst-case distribution shift within a pre-defined constraint set.
Specifically, the authors formulate the robust RL problem as a min-max optimization, where the RL agent aims to maximize expected return while the adversary tries to minimize it by perturbing the state-action distribution. However, to ensure the adversarial perturbations are realistic, the authors introduce a soft constraint that limits the allowed changes to the state-action distribution.
The SCA framework consists of two main components:
-
Adversary Network: This network is trained to find the worst-case distribution shift within the soft constraint set, effectively simulating the most challenging environment for the RL agent.
-
RL Agent: This network is trained to maximize expected return under the distribution shift induced by the adversary, making it more robust to distributional shift and adversarial attacks.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of SCA on several continuous control tasks, showing that it outperforms existing robust RL methods in terms of both performance and sample efficiency. The SCA agent is able to learn policies that are more resilient to a wide range of distribution shifts, including those induced by adversarial perturbations.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for improving the robustness of off-policy RL agents, particularly in the face of adversarial attacks and distributional shift. The use of a soft-constrained adversary is a clever way to ensure the perturbations are realistic and plausible, rather than allowing the adversary to make arbitrary, unrealistic changes.
One potential limitation of the SCA framework is that the performance of the RL agent is still dependent on the choice of the constraint set for the adversary. If the constraint set is too restrictive, the adversary may not be able to find sufficiently challenging distribution shifts, limiting the robustness of the RL agent. Conversely, if the constraint set is too permissive, the adversary may be able to find unrealistic perturbations that do not translate well to the real world.
Additionally, the paper only evaluates SCA on continuous control tasks, and it would be interesting to see how it performs on other RL domains, such as discrete control problems or games with complex state and action spaces. Further research could also investigate the scalability of SCA to larger and more complex environments.
Conclusion
The Soft Constrained Adversary (SCA) framework presented in this paper is a promising approach for improving the robustness of off-policy reinforcement learning agents. By training an adversary to find the worst-case distribution shift within a realistic constraint set, the RL agent can learn policies that are more resilient to adversarial attacks and distributional shift.
The key innovation of SCA is its ability to balance the need for robust performance with the requirement for plausible, real-world perturbations. This approach has the potential to significantly enhance the reliability and safety of RL systems deployed in critical applications, such as autonomous vehicles, robotic surgery, and financial trading.
Overall, the SCA framework represents an important step forward in the field of robust reinforcement learning, and the insights and techniques presented in this paper are likely to inspire further research and development in this rapidly evolving area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Robust off-policy Reinforcement Learning via Soft Constrained Adversary
Kosuke Nakanishi, Akihiro Kubo, Yuji Yasui, Shin Ishii
Recently, robust reinforcement learning (RL) methods against input observation have garnered significant attention and undergone rapid evolution due to RL's potential vulnerability. Although these advanced methods have achieved reasonable success, there have been two limitations when considering adversary in terms of long-term horizons. First, the mutual dependency between the policy and its corresponding optimal adversary limits the development of off-policy RL algorithms; although obtaining optimal adversary should depend on the current policy, this has restricted applications to off-policy RL. Second, these methods generally assume perturbations based only on the $L_p$-norm, even when prior knowledge of the perturbation distribution in the environment is available. We here introduce another perspective on adversarial RL: an f-divergence constrained problem with the prior knowledge distribution. From this, we derive two typical attacks and their corresponding robust learning frameworks. The evaluation of robustness is conducted and the results demonstrate that our proposed methods achieve excellent performance in sample-efficient off-policy RL.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Towards Robust Policy: Enhancing Offline Reinforcement Learning with Adversarial Attacks and Defenses
Thanh Nguyen, Tung M. Luu, Tri Ton, Chang D. Yoo
Offline reinforcement learning (RL) addresses the challenge of expensive and high-risk data exploration inherent in RL by pre-training policies on vast amounts of offline data, enabling direct deployment or fine-tuning in real-world environments. However, this training paradigm can compromise policy robustness, leading to degraded performance in practical conditions due to observation perturbations or intentional attacks. While adversarial attacks and defenses have been extensively studied in deep learning, their application in offline RL is limited. This paper proposes a framework to enhance the robustness of offline RL models by leveraging advanced adversarial attacks and defenses. The framework attacks the actor and critic components by perturbing observations during training and using adversarial defenses as regularization to enhance the learned policy. Four attacks and two defenses are introduced and evaluated on the D4RL benchmark. The results show the vulnerability of both the actor and critic to attacks and the effectiveness of the defenses in improving policy robustness. This framework holds promise for enhancing the reliability of offline RL models in practical scenarios.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Robust Deep Reinforcement Learning with Adaptive Adversarial Perturbations in Action Space
Qianmei Liu, Yufei Kuang, Jie Wang
Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) algorithms can suffer from modeling errors between the simulation and the real world. Many studies use adversarial learning to generate perturbation during training process to model the discrepancy and improve the robustness of DRL. However, most of these approaches use a fixed parameter to control the intensity of the adversarial perturbation, which can lead to a trade-off between average performance and robustness. In fact, finding the optimal parameter of the perturbation is challenging, as excessive perturbations may destabilize training and compromise agent performance, while insufficient perturbations may not impart enough information to enhance robustness. To keep the training stable while improving robustness, we propose a simple but effective method, namely, Adaptive Adversarial Perturbation (A2P), which can dynamically select appropriate adversarial perturbations for each sample. Specifically, we propose an adaptive adversarial coefficient framework to adjust the effect of the adversarial perturbation during training. By designing a metric for the current intensity of the perturbation, our method can calculate the suitable perturbation levels based on the current relative performance. The appealing feature of our method is that it is simple to deploy in real-world applications and does not require accessing the simulator in advance. The experiments in MuJoCo show that our method can improve the training stability and learn a robust policy when migrated to different test environments. The code is available at https://github.com/Lqm00/A2P-SAC.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Behavior-Targeted Attack on Reinforcement Learning with Limited Access to Victim's Policy
Shojiro Yamabe, Kazuto Fukuchi, Ryoma Senda, Jun Sakuma
This study considers the attack on reinforcement learning agents where the adversary aims to control the victim's behavior as specified by the adversary by adding adversarial modifications to the victim's state observation. While some attack methods reported success in manipulating the victim agent's behavior, these methods often rely on environment-specific heuristics. In addition, all existing attack methods require white-box access to the victim's policy. In this study, we propose a novel method for manipulating the victim agent in the black-box (i.e., the adversary is allowed to observe the victim's state and action only) and no-box (i.e., the adversary is allowed to observe the victim's state only) setting without requiring environment-specific heuristics. Our attack method is formulated as a bi-level optimization problem that is reduced to a distribution matching problem and can be solved by an existing imitation learning algorithm in the black-box and no-box settings. Empirical evaluations on several reinforcement learning benchmarks show that our proposed method has superior attack performance to baselines.
Read more6/7/2024