Safe Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning with Bilevel Optimization in Autonomous Driving
2405.18209
0
0
Abstract
Ensuring safety in MARL, particularly when deploying it in real-world applications such as autonomous driving, emerges as a critical challenge. To address this challenge, traditional safe MARL methods extend MARL approaches to incorporate safety considerations, aiming to minimize safety risk values. However, these safe MARL algorithms often fail to model other agents and lack convergence guarantees, particularly in dynamically complex environments. In this study, we propose a safe MARL method grounded in a Stackelberg model with bi-level optimization, for which convergence analysis is provided. Derived from our theoretical analysis, we develop two practical algorithms, namely Constrained Stackelberg Q-learning (CSQ) and Constrained Stackelberg Multi-Agent Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient (CS-MADDPG), designed to facilitate MARL decision-making in autonomous driving applications. To evaluate the effectiveness of our algorithms, we developed a safe MARL autonomous driving benchmark and conducted experiments on challenging autonomous driving scenarios, such as merges, roundabouts, intersections, and racetracks. The experimental results indicate that our algorithms, CSQ and CS-MADDPG, outperform several strong MARL baselines, such as Bi-AC, MACPO, and MAPPO-L, regarding reward and safety performance. The demos and source code are available at {https://github.com/SafeRL-Lab/Safe-MARL-in-Autonomous-Driving.git}.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a safe multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) framework for autonomous driving scenarios using bilevel optimization.
- The approach aims to learn safe policies for autonomous vehicles while accounting for the strategic interactions between multiple agents on the road.
- The authors introduce a novel bilevel optimization formulation that separates the learning of safe policies from the training of individual agents.
Plain English Explanation
In the world of autonomous driving, multiple self-driving cars often need to navigate and interact on the same roads. This can lead to complex strategic interactions between the vehicles, which can make it challenging to ensure the safety of all the agents.
The researchers in this paper have developed a new approach to address this problem. They use a technique called multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) to train the autonomous vehicles, but with an added focus on safety.
Specifically, they use a bilevel optimization formulation, which separates the learning of safe policies from the training of the individual agents. This allows the system to prioritize safety while still enabling the vehicles to learn how to navigate effectively in the presence of other autonomous cars.
By taking this approach, the researchers aim to develop autonomous driving systems that can safely coordinate the behavior of multiple vehicles on the road, even in complex, dynamic environments. This could help make self-driving cars a more viable and trustworthy technology for widespread adoption.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a safe multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) framework for autonomous driving scenarios using a bilevel optimization approach.
The key elements of the framework are:
-
Bilevel Optimization: The authors introduce a novel bilevel optimization formulation that separates the learning of safe policies from the training of individual agents. The upper-level optimization problem learns a safe policy that ensures the safety of all agents, while the lower-level optimization problem trains the individual agents to optimize their own rewards.
-
Safety Constraints: The upper-level optimization problem incorporates safety constraints to ensure that the learned policies maintain a safe distance between vehicles and avoid collisions.
-
Multi-Agent Interaction: The framework accounts for the strategic interactions between multiple autonomous agents on the road by modeling the problem as a multi-agent system.
-
Experiment Design: The authors evaluate their approach on a simulated autonomous driving scenario with multiple agents, demonstrating the ability to learn safe policies that outperform baseline methods in terms of safety and performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and technically sound approach to addressing the challenge of safe multi-agent reinforcement learning in autonomous driving scenarios. The authors' use of bilevel optimization to separate the learning of safe policies from the training of individual agents is a novel and promising solution.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the approach. For example, the simulation environment used in the experiments may not fully capture the complexity and unpredictability of real-world driving scenarios, which could pose challenges for the deployment of the proposed system in the real world.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the scalability of the approach as the number of agents increases, or how the framework might handle situations with heterogeneous agent capabilities or objectives.
Future research could explore these areas and investigate ways to further enhance the robustness and generalizability of the proposed safe MARL framework for autonomous driving applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel bilevel optimization-based safe multi-agent reinforcement learning framework for autonomous driving scenarios. The approach separates the learning of safe policies from the training of individual agents, allowing for the development of autonomous driving systems that can safely coordinate the behavior of multiple vehicles on the road.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their framework through simulated experiments, showcasing its ability to learn safe policies that outperform baseline methods. While the paper does not address all potential limitations, it represents an important step towards making autonomous driving a more reliable and trustworthy technology for the future.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning with Control-Theoretic Safety Guarantees for Dynamic Network Bridging
Raffaele Galliera, Konstantinos Mitsopoulos, Niranjan Suri, Raffaele Romagnoli
0
0
Addressing complex cooperative tasks in safety-critical environments poses significant challenges for Multi-Agent Systems, especially under conditions of partial observability. This work introduces a hybrid approach that integrates Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning with control-theoretic methods to ensure safe and efficient distributed strategies. Our contributions include a novel setpoint update algorithm that dynamically adjusts agents' positions to preserve safety conditions without compromising the mission's objectives. Through experimental validation, we demonstrate significant advantages over conventional MARL strategies, achieving comparable task performance with zero safety violations. Our findings indicate that integrating safe control with learning approaches not only enhances safety compliance but also achieves good performance in mission objectives.
4/3/2024
🏅
Safety Constrained Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning for Active Voltage Control
Yang Qu, Jinming Ma, Feng Wu
0
0
Active voltage control presents a promising avenue for relieving power congestion and enhancing voltage quality, taking advantage of the distributed controllable generators in the power network, such as roof-top photovoltaics. While Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) has emerged as a compelling approach to address this challenge, existing MARL approaches tend to overlook the constrained optimization nature of this problem, failing in guaranteeing safety constraints. In this paper, we formalize the active voltage control problem as a constrained Markov game and propose a safety-constrained MARL algorithm. We expand the primal-dual optimization RL method to multi-agent settings, and augment it with a novel approach of double safety estimation to learn the policy and to update the Lagrange-multiplier. In addition, we proposed different cost functions and investigated their influences on the behavior of our constrained MARL method. We evaluate our approach in the power distribution network simulation environment with real-world scale scenarios. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method compared with the state-of-the-art MARL methods.
5/15/2024
🏅
Safe Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning with Natural Language Constraints
Ziyan Wang, Meng Fang, Tristan Tomilin, Fei Fang, Yali Du
0
0
The role of natural language constraints in Safe Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) is crucial, yet often overlooked. While Safe MARL has vast potential, especially in fields like robotics and autonomous vehicles, its full potential is limited by the need to define constraints in pre-designed mathematical terms, which requires extensive domain expertise and reinforcement learning knowledge, hindering its broader adoption. To address this limitation and make Safe MARL more accessible and adaptable, we propose a novel approach named Safe Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning with Natural Language constraints (SMALL). Our method leverages fine-tuned language models to interpret and process free-form textual constraints, converting them into semantic embeddings that capture the essence of prohibited states and behaviours. These embeddings are then integrated into the multi-agent policy learning process, enabling agents to learn policies that minimize constraint violations while optimizing rewards. To evaluate the effectiveness of SMALL, we introduce the LaMaSafe, a multi-task benchmark designed to assess the performance of multiple agents in adhering to natural language constraints. Empirical evaluations across various environments demonstrate that SMALL achieves comparable rewards and significantly fewer constraint violations, highlighting its effectiveness in understanding and enforcing natural language constraints.
5/31/2024
Safe Deep Model-Based Reinforcement Learning with Lyapunov Functions
Harry Zhang
0
0
Model-based Reinforcement Learning (MBRL) has shown many desirable properties for intelligent control tasks. However, satisfying safety and stability constraints during training and rollout remains an open question. We propose a new Model-based RL framework to enable efficient policy learning with unknown dynamics based on learning model predictive control (LMPC) framework with mathematically provable guarantees of stability. We introduce and explore a novel method for adding safety constraints for model-based RL during training and policy learning. The new stability-augmented framework consists of a neural-network-based learner that learns to construct a Lyapunov function, and a model-based RL agent to consistently complete the tasks while satisfying user-specified constraints given only sub-optimal demonstrations and sparse-cost feedback. We demonstrate the capability of the proposed framework through simulated experiments.
5/28/2024