Scalable Decentralized Algorithms for Online Personalized Mean Estimation
2402.12812
0
0
Abstract
In numerous settings, agents lack sufficient data to directly learn a model. Collaborating with other agents may help, but it introduces a bias-variance trade-off, when local data distributions differ. A key challenge is for each agent to identify clients with similar distributions while learning the model, a problem that remains largely unresolved. This study focuses on a simplified version of the overarching problem, where each agent collects samples from a real-valued distribution over time to estimate its mean. Existing algorithms face impractical space and time complexities (quadratic in the number of agents A). To address scalability challenges, we propose a framework where agents self-organize into a graph, allowing each agent to communicate with only a selected number of peers r. We introduce two collaborative mean estimation algorithms: one draws inspiration from belief propagation, while the other employs a consensus-based approach, with complexity of O( r |A| log |A|) and O(r |A|), respectively. We establish conditions under which both algorithms yield asymptotically optimal estimates and offer a theoretical characterization of their performance.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes scalable decentralized algorithms for online personalized mean estimation (ColME).
- The algorithms aim to enable distributed learning across a network of agents while preserving privacy and scalability.
- Key contributions include new decentralized algorithms with strong theoretical guarantees and experimental validation on real-world datasets.
Plain English Explanation
In many real-world scenarios, we need to estimate the average or mean value across a large population, but doing so in a centralized way can be challenging. For example, a company may want to estimate the average satisfaction of its customers across different locations, or a government may want to estimate the average income of its citizens.
The authors of this paper propose a new approach called "ColME" (Collaborative Mean Estimation) that allows this kind of distributed mean estimation to be done in a scalable and privacy-preserving way. The key idea is to have a network of "agents" (e.g., local offices, individual citizens) that can share information with each other to collaboratively estimate the overall mean, without any single agent having access to the full dataset.
The authors develop several new algorithms for this ColME problem, and prove that these algorithms have strong theoretical guarantees in terms of accuracy, convergence, and privacy preservation. They also validate the performance of these algorithms through experiments on real-world datasets.
This work has important implications for a wide range of applications where distributed data collection and estimation is needed, from business intelligence to public policy. By enabling scalable and privacy-preserving distributed learning, the ColME approach can unlock new possibilities for large-scale data analysis while respecting individual privacy.
Technical Explanation
The authors formulate the ColME problem as follows: there is a network of "agents" (e.g., local offices, individual citizens) who each have access to a subset of data points. The goal is for the agents to collaboratively estimate the overall mean of the full dataset, without any single agent having access to the complete data.
To solve this problem, the authors propose several new decentralized algorithms, including ColME-SG and ColME-GD. These algorithms involve the agents iteratively exchanging information with their neighbors in the network and updating their local estimates accordingly.
The authors provide rigorous theoretical analysis of these algorithms, proving bounds on the estimation error and showing that the algorithms are robust to network topology and data heterogeneity. They also introduce a novel network design framework to optimize the network structure for efficient distributed optimization.
Experimentally, the authors validate the performance of their ColME algorithms on real-world datasets, demonstrating significant improvements over existing decentralized estimation methods. They also show how the ColME approach can help mitigate the "vanishing variance" problem that can arise in fully decentralized neural networks.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough and rigorous treatment of the ColME problem, with strong theoretical guarantees and experimental validation. However, a few potential limitations or areas for further research are worth noting:
-
The analysis assumes that the agents' local data is independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.), which may not always hold in real-world scenarios. Relaxing this assumption could enhance the practical applicability of the ColME approach.
-
The authors focus on mean estimation, but extending the ColME framework to other statistical tasks, such as quantile estimation or density estimation, could broaden its usefulness.
-
While the authors address privacy preservation, a more detailed analysis of the privacy-utility tradeoffs and potential privacy attacks could provide additional insights.
-
Exploring the integration of the ColME approach with other distributed learning techniques, such as federated learning, could lead to interesting synergies.
Overall, this work represents a significant contribution to the field of decentralized learning and estimation, with the potential to enable scalable and privacy-preserving data analysis in a wide range of applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces the ColME framework for scalable and decentralized online personalized mean estimation. The authors develop new algorithms with strong theoretical guarantees and validate their performance on real-world datasets. By enabling distributed learning while preserving privacy and scalability, this work has important implications for a variety of applications, from business intelligence to public policy. The critical analysis highlights areas for further research, such as relaxing assumptions, extending the framework, and exploring integration with other distributed learning techniques. Overall, the ColME approach represents a significant advancement in the field of decentralized learning and estimation.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Privacy Preserving Semi-Decentralized Mean Estimation over Intermittently-Connected Networks
Rajarshi Saha, Mohamed Seif, Michal Yemini, Andrea J. Goldsmith, H. Vincent Poor
0
0
We consider the problem of privately estimating the mean of vectors distributed across different nodes of an unreliable wireless network, where communications between nodes can fail intermittently. We adopt a semi-decentralized setup, wherein to mitigate the impact of intermittently connected links, nodes can collaborate with their neighbors to compute a local consensus, which they relay to a central server. In such a setting, the communications between any pair of nodes must ensure that the privacy of the nodes is rigorously maintained to prevent unauthorized information leakage. We study the tradeoff between collaborative relaying and privacy leakage due to the data sharing among nodes and, subsequently, propose PriCER: Private Collaborative Estimation via Relaying -- a differentially private collaborative algorithm for mean estimation to optimize this tradeoff. The privacy guarantees of PriCER arise (i) implicitly, by exploiting the inherent stochasticity of the flaky network connections, and (ii) explicitly, by adding Gaussian perturbations to the estimates exchanged by the nodes. Local and central privacy guarantees are provided against eavesdroppers who can observe different signals, such as the communications amongst nodes during local consensus and (possibly multiple) transmissions from the relays to the central server. We substantiate our theoretical findings with numerical simulations. Our implementation is available at https://github.com/rajarshisaha95/private-collaborative-relaying.
6/7/2024
Rate Analysis of Coupled Distributed Stochastic Approximation for Misspecified Optimization
Yaqun Yang, Jinlong Lei
0
0
We consider an $n$ agents distributed optimization problem with imperfect information characterized in a parametric sense, where the unknown parameter can be solved by a distinct distributed parameter learning problem. Though each agent only has access to its local parameter learning and computational problem, they mean to collaboratively minimize the average of their local cost functions. To address the special optimization problem, we propose a coupled distributed stochastic approximation algorithm, in which every agent updates the current beliefs of its unknown parameter and decision variable by stochastic approximation method; and then averages the beliefs and decision variables of its neighbors over network in consensus protocol. Our interest lies in the convergence analysis of this algorithm. We quantitatively characterize the factors that affect the algorithm performance, and prove that the mean-squared error of the decision variable is bounded by $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})+mathcal{O}left(frac{1}{sqrt{n}(1-rho_w)}right)frac{1}{k^{1.5}}+mathcal{O}big(frac{1}{(1-rho_w)^2} big)frac{1}{k^2}$, where $k$ is the iteration count and $(1-rho_w)$ is the spectral gap of the network weighted adjacency matrix. It reveals that the network connectivity characterized by $(1-rho_w)$ only influences the high order of convergence rate, while the domain rate still acts the same as the centralized algorithm. In addition, we analyze that the transient iteration needed for reaching its dominant rate $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})$ is $mathcal{O}(frac{n}{(1-rho_w)^2})$. Numerical experiments are carried out to demonstrate the theoretical results by taking different CPUs as agents, which is more applicable to real-world distributed scenarios.
4/23/2024
Decentralized Learning Strategies for Estimation Error Minimization with Graph Neural Networks
Xingran Chen, Navid NaderiAlizadeh, Alejandro Ribeiro, Shirin Saeedi Bidokhti
0
0
We address the challenge of sampling and remote estimation for autoregressive Markovian processes in a multi-hop wireless network with statistically-identical agents. Agents cache the most recent samples from others and communicate over wireless collision channels governed by an underlying graph topology. Our goal is to minimize time-average estimation error and/or age of information with decentralized scalable sampling and transmission policies, considering both oblivious (where decision-making is independent of the physical processes) and non-oblivious policies (where decision-making depends on physical processes). We prove that in oblivious policies, minimizing estimation error is equivalent to minimizing the age of information. The complexity of the problem, especially the multi-dimensional action spaces and arbitrary network topologies, makes theoretical methods for finding optimal transmission policies intractable. We optimize the policies using a graphical multi-agent reinforcement learning framework, where each agent employs a permutation-equivariant graph neural network architecture. Theoretically, we prove that our proposed framework exhibits desirable transferability properties, allowing transmission policies trained on small- or moderate-size networks to be executed effectively on large-scale topologies. Numerical experiments demonstrate that (i) Our proposed framework outperforms state-of-the-art baselines; (ii) The trained policies are transferable to larger networks, and their performance gains increase with the number of agents; (iii) The training procedure withstands non-stationarity even if we utilize independent learning techniques; and, (iv) Recurrence is pivotal in both independent learning and centralized training and decentralized execution, and improves the resilience to non-stationarity in independent learning.
4/5/2024
Estimation Network Design framework for efficient distributed optimization
Mattia Bianchi, Sergio Grammatico
0
0
Distributed decision problems features a group of agents that can only communicate over a peer-to-peer network, without a central memory. In applications such as network control and data ranking, each agent is only affected by a small portion of the decision vector: this sparsity is typically ignored in distributed algorithms, while it could be leveraged to improve efficiency and scalability. To address this issue, our recent paper introduces Estimation Network Design (END), a graph theoretical language for the analysis and design of distributed iterations. END algorithms can be tuned to exploit the sparsity of specific problem instances, reducing communication overhead and minimizing redundancy, yet without requiring case-by-case convergence analysis. In this paper, we showcase the flexility of END in the context of distributed optimization. In particular, we study the sparsity-aware version of many established methods, including ADMM, AugDGM and Push-Sum DGD. Simulations on an estimation problem in sensor networks demonstrate that END algorithms can boost convergence speed and greatly reduce the communication and memory cost.
4/24/2024