Seg-LSTM: Performance of xLSTM for Semantic Segmentation of Remotely Sensed Images
2406.14086
0
0
🚀
Abstract
Recent advancements in autoregressive networks with linear complexity have driven significant research progress, demonstrating exceptional performance in large language models. A representative model is the Extended Long Short-Term Memory (xLSTM), which incorporates gating mechanisms and memory structures, performing comparably to Transformer architectures in long-sequence language tasks. Autoregressive networks such as xLSTM can utilize image serialization to extend their application to visual tasks such as classification and segmentation. Although existing studies have demonstrated Vision-LSTM's impressive results in image classification, its performance in image semantic segmentation remains unverified. Our study represents the first attempt to evaluate the effectiveness of Vision-LSTM in the semantic segmentation of remotely sensed images. This evaluation is based on a specifically designed encoder-decoder architecture named Seg-LSTM, and comparisons with state-of-the-art segmentation networks. Our study found that Vision-LSTM's performance in semantic segmentation was limited and generally inferior to Vision-Transformers-based and Vision-Mamba-based models in most comparative tests. Future research directions for enhancing Vision-LSTM are recommended. The source code is available from https://github.com/zhuqinfeng1999/Seg-LSTM.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Recent research has made significant progress in autoregressive networks with linear complexity, such as the Extended Long Short-Term Memory (xLSTM) model, which performs well on long-sequence language tasks.
- These autoregressive networks can be extended to visual tasks like image classification and segmentation through techniques like image serialization.
- While Vision-LSTM, an autoregressive network, has shown impressive results in image classification, its performance in the more complex task of image semantic segmentation remains unverified.
- This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of Vision-LSTM for semantic segmentation of remotely sensed images, using a specifically designed encoder-decoder architecture called Seg-LSTM and comparing it to state-of-the-art segmentation networks.
Plain English Explanation
Researchers have developed a type of artificial neural network called an autoregressive network that can handle long sequences of information, like the text in a book or a long video. One example of this is the Extended Long Short-Term Memory (xLSTM) model, which has performed well on language tasks.
These autoregressive networks can also be applied to visual tasks, like recognizing objects in an image or determining the content of an image. This is done by converting the image into a long sequence of information that the network can process. A model called Vision-LSTM has shown good results in image classification, which is the task of identifying what's in an image.
However, the researchers wanted to see how well Vision-LSTM would perform on a more complex visual task called semantic segmentation. In semantic segmentation, the goal is to not just identify what's in an image, but to actually outline and label the different objects, regions, and features in the image. This is a more challenging task than simple image classification.
To test Vision-LSTM's performance on semantic segmentation, the researchers developed a new model called Seg-LSTM, which is based on the Vision-LSTM architecture. They compared Seg-LSTM's results on semantic segmentation of remote sensing images to other state-of-the-art segmentation models.
The researchers found that while Vision-LSTM worked well for image classification, its performance on semantic segmentation was limited and generally not as good as other more specialized segmentation models, like those based on Vision Transformers or the Samba architecture. The researchers provide recommendations for future research to try to enhance Vision-LSTM's capabilities for semantic segmentation tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper explores the use of autoregressive networks, specifically the Extended Long Short-Term Memory (xLSTM) model, as a generic vision backbone for tasks like image classification and segmentation. xLSTM is a variant of the LSTM architecture that incorporates gating mechanisms and memory structures, allowing it to perform comparably to Transformer architectures on long-sequence language tasks.
To extend the application of autoregressive networks to visual tasks, the researchers leverage image serialization techniques, which convert an image into a long sequence of data that can be processed by the network. This approach has been demonstrated by the Vision-LSTM model, which has achieved impressive results in image classification.
However, the performance of Vision-LSTM in the more complex task of image semantic segmentation remains unexplored. Semantic segmentation involves accurately outlining and labeling different objects, regions, and features within an image, which is a more challenging task than simple image classification.
To evaluate the effectiveness of Vision-LSTM for semantic segmentation, the researchers designed a new encoder-decoder architecture called Seg-LSTM, which is based on the Vision-LSTM approach. They compared the performance of Seg-LSTM on the semantic segmentation of remotely sensed images to that of state-of-the-art segmentation networks, such as those based on Vision Transformers and the Samba architecture.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the limitations of using autoregressive networks like Vision-LSTM for the task of image semantic segmentation. While Vision-LSTM has demonstrated strong performance in image classification, the researchers found that its abilities in the more complex segmentation task were generally inferior to specialized segmentation models based on Vision Transformers and the Samba architecture.
One potential limitation of the study is that it focuses solely on the semantic segmentation of remotely sensed images, which may have unique characteristics or challenges compared to other image domains. Further research would be needed to assess the generalizability of these findings to other image segmentation tasks.
Additionally, the researchers acknowledge that their study represents the first attempt to evaluate Vision-LSTM's effectiveness in image semantic segmentation. As such, there may be opportunities to explore alternative architectural designs or training approaches that could potentially enhance the performance of autoregressive networks like Vision-LSTM in this domain.
Overall, the study raises important questions about the suitability of generic vision backbones, like those based on autoregressive networks, for more specialized computer vision tasks. It suggests that domain-specific architectures and techniques may be necessary to achieve state-of-the-art performance in complex visual understanding problems, such as image semantic segmentation.
Conclusion
This study represents an important exploration of the capabilities and limitations of autoregressive networks, specifically the Vision-LSTM model, in the domain of image semantic segmentation. While Vision-LSTM has shown impressive results in image classification, the researchers found that its performance was limited and generally inferior to specialized segmentation models when applied to the task of semantic segmentation of remotely sensed images.
The findings highlight the need for further research to enhance the capabilities of autoregressive networks like Vision-LSTM for more complex visual tasks, or to explore the development of alternative architectures and techniques that can effectively handle the challenges of image semantic segmentation. As the field of computer vision continues to advance, studies like this one will play a crucial role in guiding the development of robust and versatile visual understanding systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Vision-LSTM: xLSTM as Generic Vision Backbone
Benedikt Alkin, Maximilian Beck, Korbinian Poppel, Sepp Hochreiter, Johannes Brandstetter
0
0
Transformers are widely used as generic backbones in computer vision, despite initially introduced for natural language processing. Recently, the Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) has been extended to a scalable and performant architecture - the xLSTM - which overcomes long-standing LSTM limitations via exponential gating and parallelizable matrix memory structure. In this report, we introduce Vision-LSTM (ViL), an adaption of the xLSTM building blocks to computer vision. ViL comprises a stack of xLSTM blocks where odd blocks process the sequence of patch tokens from top to bottom while even blocks go from bottom to top. Experiments show that ViL holds promise to be further deployed as new generic backbone for computer vision architectures.
6/7/2024
👀
New!Are Vision xLSTM Embedded UNet More Reliable in Medical 3D Image Segmentation?
Pallabi Dutta, Soham Bose, Swalpa Kumar Roy, Sushmita Mitra
0
0
The advancement of developing efficient medical image segmentation has evolved from initial dependence on Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) to the present investigation of hybrid models that combine CNNs with Vision Transformers. Furthermore, there is an increasing focus on creating architectures that are both high-performing in medical image segmentation tasks and computationally efficient to be deployed on systems with limited resources. Although transformers have several advantages like capturing global dependencies in the input data, they face challenges such as high computational and memory complexity. This paper investigates the integration of CNNs and Vision Extended Long Short-Term Memory (Vision-xLSTM) models by introducing a novel approach called UVixLSTM. The Vision-xLSTM blocks captures temporal and global relationships within the patches extracted from the CNN feature maps. The convolutional feature reconstruction path upsamples the output volume from the Vision-xLSTM blocks to produce the segmentation output. Our primary objective is to propose that Vision-xLSTM forms a reliable backbone for medical image segmentation tasks, offering excellent segmentation performance and reduced computational complexity. UVixLSTM exhibits superior performance compared to state-of-the-art networks on the publicly-available Synapse dataset. Code is available at: https://github.com/duttapallabi2907/UVixLSTM
6/26/2024
🏷️
xLSTM: Extended Long Short-Term Memory
Maximilian Beck, Korbinian Poppel, Markus Spanring, Andreas Auer, Oleksandra Prudnikova, Michael Kopp, Gunter Klambauer, Johannes Brandstetter, Sepp Hochreiter
0
0
In the 1990s, the constant error carousel and gating were introduced as the central ideas of the Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM). Since then, LSTMs have stood the test of time and contributed to numerous deep learning success stories, in particular they constituted the first Large Language Models (LLMs). However, the advent of the Transformer technology with parallelizable self-attention at its core marked the dawn of a new era, outpacing LSTMs at scale. We now raise a simple question: How far do we get in language modeling when scaling LSTMs to billions of parameters, leveraging the latest techniques from modern LLMs, but mitigating known limitations of LSTMs? Firstly, we introduce exponential gating with appropriate normalization and stabilization techniques. Secondly, we modify the LSTM memory structure, obtaining: (i) sLSTM with a scalar memory, a scalar update, and new memory mixing, (ii) mLSTM that is fully parallelizable with a matrix memory and a covariance update rule. Integrating these LSTM extensions into residual block backbones yields xLSTM blocks that are then residually stacked into xLSTM architectures. Exponential gating and modified memory structures boost xLSTM capabilities to perform favorably when compared to state-of-the-art Transformers and State Space Models, both in performance and scaling.
5/8/2024
🏋️
CLIP as RNN: Segment Countless Visual Concepts without Training Endeavor
Shuyang Sun, Runjia Li, Philip Torr, Xiuye Gu, Siyang Li
0
0
Existing open-vocabulary image segmentation methods require a fine-tuning step on mask labels and/or image-text datasets. Mask labels are labor-intensive, which limits the number of categories in segmentation datasets. Consequently, the vocabulary capacity of pre-trained VLMs is severely reduced after fine-tuning. However, without fine-tuning, VLMs trained under weak image-text supervision tend to make suboptimal mask predictions. To alleviate these issues, we introduce a novel recurrent framework that progressively filters out irrelevant texts and enhances mask quality without training efforts. The recurrent unit is a two-stage segmenter built upon a frozen VLM. Thus, our model retains the VLM's broad vocabulary space and equips it with segmentation ability. Experiments show that our method outperforms not only the training-free counterparts, but also those fine-tuned with millions of data samples, and sets the new state-of-the-art records for both zero-shot semantic and referring segmentation. Concretely, we improve the current record by 28.8, 16.0, and 6.9 mIoU on Pascal VOC, COCO Object, and Pascal Context.
5/8/2024