Selecting Large Language Model to Fine-tune via Rectified Scaling Law

Overview

• Selecting the best pre-trained large language model (LLM) to fine-tune can be challenging given the vast number of options available.
• This work formulates the resource-constrained model selection task as predicting fine-tuning performance and explores its connection with Scaling Law.
• The authors find that the fine-tuning scaling curve includes a previously unobserved "pre-power" phase, which existing Scaling Law fails to capture.
• To address this, they introduce the concept of "pre-learned data size" into a Rectified Scaling Law, which better fits the experimental results.
• Using their Rectified Scaling Law, the authors propose a novel, efficient LLM selection algorithm that requires far less computational resources compared to other methods.

Plain English Explanation

With the rapid growth of large language models (LLMs), researchers and developers are faced with the challenge of selecting the most appropriate pre-trained model to fine-tune for their specific tasks. Given the limited computational resources available, it's not practical to fine-tune all the models and then choose the best one.

This research paper tackles this problem by formulating it as a task of predicting the fine-tuning performance of different LLMs. The researchers explore the connection between this task and the well-known Scaling Law, which describes the relationship between a model's size and its performance.

Interestingly, the researchers found that the fine-tuning scaling curve includes not just the expected "power" phase, but also a previously unobserved "pre-power" phase. Existing Scaling Law models were unable to capture this transition between the two phases.

To address this, the researchers introduced a new concept called "pre-learned data size" into their Rectified Scaling Law. This allowed their model to better fit the experimental results and overcome the limitations of the previous Scaling Law approaches.

Using their Rectified Scaling Law, the researchers developed a novel algorithm that can select the near-optimal LLM to fine-tune with much less computational resources compared to other methods. This is a significant breakthrough, as it allows researchers and developers to efficiently identify the best model for their needs, even with limited computing power.

Technical Explanation

The paper explores the challenge of selecting the most appropriate pre-trained large language model (LLM) to fine-tune, given the ever-growing ecosystem of such models and constrained computational resources. The authors formulate this task as predicting the fine-tuning performance of different LLMs, and investigate its connection with Scaling Law.

Unlike pre-training, the researchers find that the fine-tuning scaling curve includes not just the well-known "power" phase, but also a previously unobserved "pre-power" phase. They explain why existing Scaling Law models fail to capture this phase transition, both theoretically and empirically.

To address this, the authors introduce the concept of "pre-learned data size" into their Rectified Scaling Law, which allows their model to better fit the experimental results and overcome the limitations of previous approaches. This is further supported by the Unraveling the Mystery of Scaling Laws framework.

The researchers then leverage their Rectified Scaling Law to propose a novel LLM selection algorithm that can identify the near-optimal model with hundreds of times less resource consumption compared to other methods. This is a significant improvement over existing techniques, which may provide negatively correlated selections.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the fine-tuning performance of large language models and the limitations of existing Scaling Law approaches. The introduction of the "pre-power" phase and the concept of "pre-learned data size" are interesting insights that expand our knowledge of the scaling behavior of LLMs.

However, the paper does not discuss the potential implications of this research for the broader field of machine learning and language modeling. It would be interesting to see how the Rectified Scaling Law and the proposed selection algorithm could be applied to other types of models or tasks, beyond just LLMs.

Additionally, the paper does not address the potential biases or limitations of the datasets and models used in the experiments. It would be important to understand how the Rectified Scaling Law and the selection algorithm might perform on more diverse and representative datasets, as well as the potential fairness and ethical considerations.

Finally, the paper could have benefited from a more detailed discussion of the practical applications and real-world impact of the proposed approach. While the resource-efficient model selection is a valuable contribution, the paper could have explored the specific use cases and the potential barriers to adoption by the broader research and development community.

Conclusion

This research paper presents a novel approach to selecting the most appropriate pre-trained large language model (LLM) for fine-tuning, addressing the challenge posed by the ever-growing ecosystem of such models and constrained computational resources.

By formulating the model selection task as predicting fine-tuning performance and exploring its connection with Scaling Law, the authors uncover a previously unobserved "pre-power" phase in the fine-tuning scaling curve. To capture this phase transition, they introduce the concept of "pre-learned data size" into their Rectified Scaling Law, which better fits the experimental results.

Leveraging their Rectified Scaling Law, the researchers propose a highly efficient LLM selection algorithm that can identify the near-optimal model with significantly less computational resources compared to other methods. This breakthrough has the potential to greatly improve the accessibility and practicality of fine-tuning large language models, especially for researchers and developers with limited computing power.

The findings of this paper expand our understanding of the scaling behavior of LLMs and pave the way for more efficient and informed decision-making in the selection and fine-tuning of these powerful language models.