Selective Prediction for Semantic Segmentation using Post-Hoc Confidence Estimation and Its Performance under Distribution Shift
2402.10665
0
0
🔮
Abstract
Semantic segmentation plays a crucial role in various computer vision applications, yet its efficacy is often hindered by the lack of high-quality labeled data. To address this challenge, a common strategy is to leverage models trained on data from different populations, such as publicly available datasets. This approach, however, leads to the distribution shift problem, presenting a reduced performance on the population of interest. In scenarios where model errors can have significant consequences, selective prediction methods offer a means to mitigate risks and reduce reliance on expert supervision. This paper investigates selective prediction for semantic segmentation in low-resource settings, thus focusing on post-hoc confidence estimators applied to pre-trained models operating under distribution shift. We propose a novel image-level confidence measure tailored for semantic segmentation and demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on three medical imaging tasks. Our findings show that post-hoc confidence estimators offer a cost-effective approach to reducing the impacts of distribution shift.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the use of post-hoc confidence estimators to improve the performance of semantic segmentation models in low-resource settings, where there is a mismatch between the training data and the target population.
- The authors propose a novel image-level confidence measure tailored for semantic segmentation and demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on three medical imaging tasks.
- The key insight is that post-hoc confidence estimators can help mitigate the impacts of distribution shift, reducing the reliance on expert supervision and offering a cost-effective approach to improving model performance.
Plain English Explanation
Semantic segmentation is a crucial technique in computer vision that involves dividing an image into meaningful parts, such as identifying different objects, tissues, or structures. However, this approach often struggles when the model is applied to data that is different from the data it was trained on. This is known as the "distribution shift" problem.
To address this challenge, the researchers in this paper explored the use of "post-hoc confidence estimators." These are methods that can estimate how confident a pre-trained model is about its predictions, even when the model is being applied to data that is different from what it was trained on.
The researchers developed a new way to measure the confidence of a semantic segmentation model, which they tested on three different medical imaging tasks. The results showed that these post-hoc confidence estimators can help mitigate the effects of distribution shift, reducing the need for extensive human supervision and making the models more reliable and cost-effective.
This is an important development because in many real-world applications, such as medical diagnosis, it's crucial that the models make accurate and reliable predictions. The approach proposed in this paper offers a promising way to improve the performance of semantic segmentation models in low-resource settings, where high-quality labeled data may be scarce.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the problem of distribution shift in semantic segmentation, where models trained on data from one population perform poorly when applied to data from a different population. To address this, the authors investigate the use of post-hoc confidence estimators to selectively predict only when the model is confident in its predictions, reducing the reliance on expert supervision.
The key contributions of the paper are:
- A novel image-level confidence measure tailored for semantic segmentation, which the authors demonstrate to be effective in their experiments.
- An empirical evaluation of the proposed confidence measure on three medical imaging tasks, showing the potential of post-hoc confidence estimators to mitigate the impacts of distribution shift.
The proposed confidence measure is designed to capture the model's uncertainty at the image level, which is crucial for semantic segmentation tasks where the model needs to make predictions for each pixel in the image. The authors compare their approach to other uncertainty estimation methods, such as evidential learning and prototype-based learning, and demonstrate its superior performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful approach to addressing the distribution shift problem in semantic segmentation, which is a significant challenge in many real-world applications. The authors' focus on post-hoc confidence estimators is well-justified, as this can be a cost-effective way to improve model performance without requiring extensive retraining or additional data collection.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential limitations or caveats of their approach. For example, it would be useful to understand how the proposed confidence measure might perform in scenarios with different types of distribution shift, or how it compares to other confidence estimation methods in terms of computational complexity and inference time.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential ethical implications of using selective prediction in high-stakes applications, such as medical diagnosis. While the approach can help mitigate the impacts of distribution shift, it is essential to consider the fairness and accountability of the decision-making process, especially when the model is making predictions that can directly affect human lives.
Overall, the research presented in this paper is a valuable contribution to the field of semantic segmentation, but further exploration of the limitations and potential risks of the approach would strengthen the work and help guide future research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper investigates the use of post-hoc confidence estimators to improve the performance of semantic segmentation models in low-resource settings, where there is a mismatch between the training data and the target population. The authors propose a novel image-level confidence measure and demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on three medical imaging tasks.
The key insight is that post-hoc confidence estimators can help mitigate the impacts of distribution shift, reducing the reliance on expert supervision and offering a cost-effective approach to improving model performance. This is a significant development, as it can make semantic segmentation more accessible and reliable in a wide range of real-world applications, particularly in high-stakes domains like medical diagnosis.
While the paper presents a promising solution, it would be valuable to further explore the limitations and potential risks of the approach, as well as to investigate how it might perform in different types of distribution shift scenarios. By addressing these aspects, the research community can continue to advance the state of the art in semantic segmentation and ensure that these powerful techniques are deployed responsibly and equitably.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🖼️
Conformal Semantic Image Segmentation: Post-hoc Quantification of Predictive Uncertainty
Luca Mossina, Joseba Dalmau, L'eo and'eol
0
0
We propose a post-hoc, computationally lightweight method to quantify predictive uncertainty in semantic image segmentation. Our approach uses conformal prediction to generate statistically valid prediction sets that are guaranteed to include the ground-truth segmentation mask at a predefined confidence level. We introduce a novel visualization technique of conformalized predictions based on heatmaps, and provide metrics to assess their empirical validity. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on well-known benchmark datasets and image segmentation prediction models, and conclude with practical insights.
5/9/2024
🏷️
How to Fix a Broken Confidence Estimator: Evaluating Post-hoc Methods for Selective Classification with Deep Neural Networks
Lu'is Felipe P. Cattelan, Danilo Silva
0
0
This paper addresses the problem of selective classification for deep neural networks, where a model is allowed to abstain from low-confidence predictions to avoid potential errors. We focus on so-called post-hoc methods, which replace the confidence estimator of a given classifier without modifying or retraining it, thus being practically appealing. Considering neural networks with softmax outputs, our goal is to identify the best confidence estimator that can be computed directly from the unnormalized logits. This problem is motivated by the intriguing observation in recent work that many classifiers appear to have a broken confidence estimator, in the sense that their selective classification performance is much worse than what could be expected by their corresponding accuracies. We perform an extensive experimental study of many existing and proposed confidence estimators applied to 84 pretrained ImageNet classifiers available from popular repositories. Our results show that a simple $p$-norm normalization of the logits, followed by taking the maximum logit as the confidence estimator, can lead to considerable gains in selective classification performance, completely fixing the pathological behavior observed in many classifiers. As a consequence, the selective classification performance of any classifier becomes almost entirely determined by its corresponding accuracy. Moreover, these results are shown to be consistent under distribution shift. Our code is available at https://github.com/lfpc/FixSelectiveClassification.
5/27/2024
Hierarchical Selective Classification
Shani Goren, Ido Galil, Ran El-Yaniv
0
0
Deploying deep neural networks for risk-sensitive tasks necessitates an uncertainty estimation mechanism. This paper introduces hierarchical selective classification, extending selective classification to a hierarchical setting. Our approach leverages the inherent structure of class relationships, enabling models to reduce the specificity of their predictions when faced with uncertainty. In this paper, we first formalize hierarchical risk and coverage, and introduce hierarchical risk-coverage curves. Next, we develop algorithms for hierarchical selective classification (which we refer to as inference rules), and propose an efficient algorithm that guarantees a target accuracy constraint with high probability. Lastly, we conduct extensive empirical studies on over a thousand ImageNet classifiers, revealing that training regimes such as CLIP, pretraining on ImageNet21k and knowledge distillation boost hierarchical selective performance.
5/21/2024
🏷️
Selective Classification Under Distribution Shifts
Hengyue Liang, Le Peng, Ju Sun
0
0
In selective classification (SC), a classifier abstains from making predictions that are likely to be wrong to avoid excessive errors. To deploy imperfect classifiers -- imperfect either due to intrinsic statistical noise of data or for robustness issue of the classifier or beyond -- in high-stakes scenarios, SC appears to be an attractive and necessary path to follow. Despite decades of research in SC, most previous SC methods still focus on the ideal statistical setting only, i.e., the data distribution at deployment is the same as that of training, although practical data can come from the wild. To bridge this gap, in this paper, we propose an SC framework that takes into account distribution shifts, termed generalized selective classification, that covers label-shifted (or out-of-distribution) and covariate-shifted samples, in addition to typical in-distribution samples, the first of its kind in the SC literature. We focus on non-training-based confidence-score functions for generalized SC on deep learning (DL) classifiers and propose two novel margin-based score functions. Through extensive analysis and experiments, we show that our proposed score functions are more effective and reliable than the existing ones for generalized SC on a variety of classification tasks and DL classifiers.
5/9/2024