SHED: Shapley-Based Automated Dataset Refinement for Instruction Fine-Tuning

Overview

• Large Language Models (LLMs) can be fine-tuned for various tasks and aligned with human preferences
• Recent studies have found that LLMs can perform well with small, high-quality datasets, suggesting large datasets may contain redundant or harmful data
• Identifying high-quality data from large datasets is a critical challenge
• This paper introduces SHED, an automated dataset refinement framework based on Shapley value for instruction fine-tuning

Plain English Explanation

Large language models are powerful AI systems that can be trained on vast amounts of text data to understand and generate human-like language. While these models can be adapted for many different tasks, it's been discovered that they can often achieve desirable performance with only a small amount of high-quality data. This suggests that a lot of the data in these extensive datasets may be unnecessary or even detrimental to the model's performance.

The key challenge is figuring out how to identify the most valuable, high-quality data from these large datasets to create smaller, more effective training sets. The paper introduces a new framework called SHED (Short for "Shapley value-based dataset refinement") that aims to automatically refine datasets by selecting the most important data points. SHED uses a mathematical concept called Shapley value to evaluate the contribution of each data point to the model's performance, and then selects the most valuable ones to create a smaller, more targeted dataset.

The researchers found that the datasets curated by SHED not only performed well on the specific task they were trained for, but could also be reused effectively across different language models. This suggests that SHED is able to identify fundamental, transferable knowledge that is valuable for a wide range of language-based applications.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces SHED, an automated dataset refinement framework based on Shapley value for instruction fine-tuning of large language models (LLMs). SHED aims to identify high-quality data from vast datasets to create smaller, more effective training sets.

The key innovation of SHED is its use of Shapley value, a concept from cooperative game theory, to evaluate the contribution of each data point to the model's performance. Shapley value provides a principled way to quantify the importance of each data point, allowing SHED to select the most valuable ones and discard the redundant or harmful data.

The researchers conduct extensive experiments to evaluate the datasets curated by SHED across various tasks and LLMs, including GPT-3, CodeCLM, and GenIXER. The results demonstrate that SHED outperforms state-of-the-art dataset refinement methods, with the curated datasets comprising only 10% of the original data achieving comparable or even superior performance to the full datasets.

Notably, the researchers also find that the datasets curated by SHED exhibit transferability, meaning they can be reused across different LLMs with consistently high performance. This suggests that SHED is able to identify fundamental, task-agnostic knowledge that is valuable for a wide range of language-based applications.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to dataset refinement for large language models, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

1. Computational complexity: The Shapley value calculation used in SHED can be computationally expensive, especially for large datasets. The authors mention that they used approximation techniques to make the process more efficient, but the scalability of SHED for truly massive datasets remains an open question.

2. Potential biases in the original data: While SHED can identify high-quality data points, it doesn't address the issue of biases or flaws that may be present in the original dataset. Auditing large language models for problematic content or biases is an important area that is not covered in this paper.

3. Interpretability and transparency: The Shapley value calculations used in SHED can be complex and difficult to interpret, which may limit the transparency and explainability of the dataset refinement process. Further research into more interpretable methods for dataset curation could be valuable.

Despite these potential limitations, the paper makes a significant contribution to the field of large language model optimization by introducing a principled and effective approach to dataset refinement. The transferability of the curated datasets across different LLMs is a particularly promising finding, suggesting that SHED could have broad applications in the development of robust and efficient language models.

Conclusion

This paper presents SHED, an automated dataset refinement framework based on Shapley value, as a solution to the challenge of identifying high-quality data from vast datasets for fine-tuning large language models. The key innovation of SHED is its use of Shapley value to quantify the importance of each data point, allowing it to select the most valuable ones and create smaller, more effective training sets.

The extensive experiments conducted by the researchers demonstrate that SHED outperforms state-of-the-art dataset refinement methods, with the curated datasets comprising only 10% of the original data achieving comparable or even superior performance to the full datasets. Notably, the transferability of the SHED-curated datasets across different language models suggests that the framework is able to identify fundamental, task-agnostic knowledge that is valuable for a wide range of language-based applications.

While the paper presents a promising approach, there are some potential limitations and areas for further research, such as computational complexity, addressing biases in the original data, and improving the interpretability of the dataset refinement process. Overall, the SHED framework represents a significant step forward in optimizing the performance of large language models through targeted dataset curation, with potential implications for a wide range of natural language processing tasks.