Stacking Your Transformers: A Closer Look at Model Growth for Efficient LLM Pre-Training

Overview

• Large language models (LLMs) are computationally expensive to pre-train due to their large scale.
• Model growth is a promising approach to accelerate the training of larger LLMs by leveraging smaller models.
• However, the viability of these model growth methods in efficient LLM pre-training remains underexplored.

Plain English Explanation

Building large, powerful language models is a computationally intensive process that requires a lot of computing power and time. Researchers have explored a technique called "model growth" as a way to speed up this process. The idea is to start with smaller, simpler models and then gradually expand and refine them to create larger, more capable models.

This paper examines three key challenges that need to be addressed to make model growth a viable approach for efficiently pre-training large language models:

1. Lack of comprehensive evaluation: There hasn't been a thorough, standardized evaluation of the different model growth techniques that have been proposed.
2. Untested viability for scaling: It's unclear whether these model growth methods can actually work when scaling up to very large language models.
3. Lack of empirical guidelines: There's a need for clear guidance on how to best apply these model growth techniques in practice.

The researchers tackle these challenges by systematically evaluating different model growth operators, conducting extensive experiments to understand the scalability of the most promising approach, and developing empirical guidelines to make it practical for general large language model pre-training.

Technical Explanation

The researchers summarize existing model growth approaches into four atomic operators and evaluate them in a standardized large language model pre-training setting. They find that a "depthwise stacking" operator, called $G_{text{stack}}$, exhibits remarkable acceleration in training, leading to decreased loss and improved performance on various natural language processing benchmarks compared to strong baselines.

Motivated by these promising results, the researchers conduct extensive experiments to further understand the scalability and practical guidelines for using the $G_{text{stack}}$ operator. Their study shows that $G_{text{stack}}$ is scalable and consistently performs well, even for very large 7B-parameter language models. For example, compared to a conventionally trained 7B model using 300B tokens, their $G_{text{stack}}$ model converges to the same loss with only 194B tokens, resulting in a 54.6% speedup.

The researchers also provide empirical guidelines for determining the optimal growth timing and growth factor for the $G_{text{stack}}$ operator, making it more practical for general large language model pre-training. They include comprehensive ablation studies and discussions of the $G_{text{stack}}$ operator to further understand its inner workings.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough and rigorous evaluation of model growth techniques for accelerating large language model pre-training. The researchers have identified key challenges in this area and designed experiments to systematically address them. The results demonstrating the scalability and effectiveness of the $G_{text{stack}}$ operator are quite promising.

However, the paper does not delve into the potential limitations or caveats of the proposed approach. For example, it would be helpful to understand how the $G_{text{stack}}$ operator performs on specific tasks or datasets, or how it compares to other model scaling techniques, such as those discussed in related work, Masked Structural Growth, Efficient Inference, Sparse LLMs, or Sheared LLMs. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational and memory requirements of the $G_{text{stack}}$ operator, which could be an important consideration for practical deployments.

Conclusion

This paper presents a comprehensive study of model growth techniques for accelerating the pre-training of large language models. The researchers have identified key challenges in this area and systematically evaluated different growth operators, with the $G_{text{stack}}$ operator showing remarkable performance improvements. The extensive experiments on scalability and the development of empirical guidelines make this work a valuable contribution to the field of efficient large language model development.

The findings in this paper could have significant implications for the research and development of next-generation language models, potentially leading to more cost-effective and accessible approaches for building powerful AI systems. However, further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and practical considerations of the proposed techniques.