Task Weighting through Gradient Projection for Multitask Learning

Read original: arXiv:2409.01793 - Published 9/4/2024 by Christian Bohn, Ido Freeman, Hasan Tercan, Tobias Meisen
Total Score

0

Task Weighting through Gradient Projection for Multitask Learning

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Task weighting through gradient projection for multitask learning
  • Aims to prioritize more important tasks during training
  • Proposes a method that assigns dynamic task weights based on the gradient magnitudes

Plain English Explanation

When training models to perform multiple tasks at once (known as multitask learning), it's often important to prioritize the more important tasks over the less important ones. This paper introduces a method called Task Weighting through Gradient Projection that dynamically adjusts the weights assigned to each task during training based on the magnitudes of the gradients for each task.

The key idea is that the tasks with larger gradient magnitudes are likely more important, so the model should focus more on learning those tasks. By adjusting the task weights accordingly, the model can prioritize the more impactful tasks and improve overall performance. This approach aims to be more effective than manually setting fixed task weights, which can be challenging to tune.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes an optimization-based method for determining dynamic task weights. During training, the gradients for each task are projected onto a shared parameter space. The magnitudes of these projected gradients are then used to compute the task weights, with higher weights given to tasks with larger gradient magnitudes.

Specifically, the authors formulate an optimization problem that aims to find the task weights that maximize the alignment between the gradients and the shared parameter updates. This is achieved by solving a constrained quadratic program, which can be done efficiently.

The authors evaluate their method on several multitask learning benchmarks, including computer vision and natural language processing tasks. The results show that their Task Weighting through Gradient Projection approach outperforms baseline methods that use fixed task weights or learnable task weights.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and theoretically grounded approach for automatically determining task weights in multitask learning. The authors acknowledge that manually setting task weights can be challenging, and their gradient-based method provides a principled way to adaptively prioritize tasks during training.

One potential limitation is that the method assumes the tasks are well-aligned in the shared parameter space, which may not always be the case in practice. The authors mention that further research is needed to handle more complex task relationships, such as when tasks are in conflict or have different levels of difficulty.

Additionally, the paper focuses on a single-head architecture, where all tasks share a common set of parameters. It would be interesting to see how the Task Weighting through Gradient Projection approach could be extended to more flexible multitask learning architectures, such as those with task-specific branches or experts.

Overall, this paper presents a promising direction for improving multitask learning by dynamically adjusting task priorities based on gradient information. The critical analysis and further research suggestions provide useful guidance for advancing the field of multitask learning.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel method called Task Weighting through Gradient Projection for prioritizing tasks in multitask learning. By dynamically adjusting the task weights based on the magnitudes of the gradients, the method aims to improve the model's performance on the more important tasks.

The technical approach and empirical results demonstrate the potential of this method to enhance multitask learning, which is a crucial capability for building AI systems that can handle a diverse range of tasks efficiently. While the paper identifies some limitations and areas for future research, the Task Weighting through Gradient Projection method represents an important step forward in the field of multitask learning.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Task Weighting through Gradient Projection for Multitask Learning
Total Score

0

Task Weighting through Gradient Projection for Multitask Learning

Christian Bohn, Ido Freeman, Hasan Tercan, Tobias Meisen

In multitask learning, conflicts between task gradients are a frequent issue degrading a model's training performance. This is commonly addressed by using the Gradient Projection algorithm PCGrad that often leads to faster convergence and improved performance metrics. In this work, we present a method to adapt this algorithm to simultaneously also perform task prioritization. Our approach differs from traditional task weighting performed by scaling task losses in that our weighting scheme applies only in cases where tasks are in conflict, but lets the training proceed unhindered otherwise. We replace task weighting factors by a probability distribution that determines which task gradients get projected in conflict cases. Our experiments on the nuScenes, CIFAR-100, and CelebA datasets confirm that our approach is a practical method for task weighting. Paired with multiple different task weighting schemes, we observe a significant improvement in the performance metrics of most tasks compared to Gradient Projection with uniform projection probabilities.

Read more

9/4/2024

Quantifying Task Priority for Multi-Task Optimization
Total Score

0

Quantifying Task Priority for Multi-Task Optimization

Wooseong Jeong, Kuk-Jin Yoon

The goal of multi-task learning is to learn diverse tasks within a single unified network. As each task has its own unique objective function, conflicts emerge during training, resulting in negative transfer among them. Earlier research identified these conflicting gradients in shared parameters between tasks and attempted to realign them in the same direction. However, we prove that such optimization strategies lead to sub-optimal Pareto solutions due to their inability to accurately determine the individual contributions of each parameter across various tasks. In this paper, we propose the concept of task priority to evaluate parameter contributions across different tasks. To learn task priority, we identify the type of connections related to links between parameters influenced by task-specific losses during backpropagation. The strength of connections is gauged by the magnitude of parameters to determine task priority. Based on these, we present a new method named connection strength-based optimization for multi-task learning which consists of two phases. The first phase learns the task priority within the network, while the second phase modifies the gradients while upholding this priority. This ultimately leads to finding new Pareto optimal solutions for multiple tasks. Through extensive experiments, we show that our approach greatly enhances multi-task performance in comparison to earlier gradient manipulation methods.

Read more

6/6/2024

Analytical Uncertainty-Based Loss Weighting in Multi-Task Learning
Total Score

0

Analytical Uncertainty-Based Loss Weighting in Multi-Task Learning

Lukas Kirchdorfer, Cathrin Elich, Simon Kutsche, Heiner Stuckenschmidt, Lukas Schott, Jan M. Kohler

With the rise of neural networks in various domains, multi-task learning (MTL) gained significant relevance. A key challenge in MTL is balancing individual task losses during neural network training to improve performance and efficiency through knowledge sharing across tasks. To address these challenges, we propose a novel task-weighting method by building on the most prevalent approach of Uncertainty Weighting and computing analytically optimal uncertainty-based weights, normalized by a softmax function with tunable temperature. Our approach yields comparable results to the combinatorially prohibitive, brute-force approach of Scalarization while offering a more cost-effective yet high-performing alternative. We conduct an extensive benchmark on various datasets and architectures. Our method consistently outperforms six other common weighting methods. Furthermore, we report noteworthy experimental findings for the practical application of MTL. For example, larger networks diminish the influence of weighting methods, and tuning the weight decay has a low impact compared to the learning rate.

Read more

8/16/2024

📈

Total Score

0

Localizing Task Information for Improved Model Merging and Compression

Ke Wang, Nikolaos Dimitriadis, Guillermo Ortiz-Jimenez, Franc{c}ois Fleuret, Pascal Frossard

Model merging and task arithmetic have emerged as promising scalable approaches to merge multiple single-task checkpoints to one multi-task model, but their applicability is reduced by significant performance loss. Previous works have linked these drops to interference in the weight space and erasure of important task-specific features. Instead, in this work we show that the information required to solve each task is still preserved after merging as different tasks mostly use non-overlapping sets of weights. We propose TALL-masks, a method to identify these task supports given a collection of task vectors and show that one can retrieve >99% of the single task accuracy by applying our masks to the multi-task vector, effectively compressing the individual checkpoints. We study the statistics of intersections among constructed masks and reveal the existence of selfish and catastrophic weights, i.e., parameters that are important exclusively to one task and irrelevant to all tasks but detrimental to multi-task fusion. For this reason, we propose Consensus Merging, an algorithm that eliminates such weights and improves the general performance of existing model merging approaches. Our experiments in vision and NLP benchmarks with up to 20 tasks, show that Consensus Merging consistently improves existing approaches. Furthermore, our proposed compression scheme reduces storage from 57Gb to 8.2Gb while retaining 99.7% of original performance.

Read more

5/14/2024