Bayesian Uncertainty for Gradient Aggregation in Multi-Task Learning

Read original: arXiv:2402.04005 - Published 5/14/2024 by Idan Achituve, Idit Diamant, Arnon Netzer, Gal Chechik, Ethan Fetaya
Total Score

0

🏷️

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • As machine learning becomes more widely used, there is a growing need to perform multiple inference tasks simultaneously.
  • Running a separate model for each task is computationally expensive, so there is significant interest in multi-task learning (MTL).
  • MTL aims to learn a single model that can efficiently solve multiple tasks.
  • Optimizing MTL models often involves computing a single gradient per task and combining them for an overall update.
  • However, these approaches do not consider the sensitivity or uncertainty in the gradient dimensions.
  • This paper introduces a novel gradient aggregation method using Bayesian inference to quantify the uncertainty in each gradient dimension.

Plain English Explanation

Machine learning is becoming more prominent in many applications, and there is a need to perform multiple tasks or inferences at the same time. Running a separate model for each task can be computationally expensive, so researchers are interested in multi-task learning (MTL). MTL tries to build a single model that can handle multiple tasks efficiently.

When training MTL models, the common approach is to compute a gradient for each task and then combine them to update the model. However, this doesn't consider how sensitive or uncertain the gradients are in different dimensions. This paper introduces a new way to aggregate the gradients using Bayesian inference. The key idea is to place a probability distribution over the task-specific parameters, which then induces a distribution over the gradients. This allows the method to quantify the uncertainty in each gradient dimension and factor that in when combining them. The authors show that this approach outperforms existing MTL methods on various datasets.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a novel gradient aggregation method for multi-task learning (MTL). In MTL, the goal is to learn a single model that can solve multiple tasks efficiently, rather than running a separate model for each task.

Traditionally, MTL optimization involves computing a single gradient per task and then aggregating them to obtain a combined update direction. However, these approaches do not consider the sensitivity or uncertainty in the different gradient dimensions.

The key innovation in this paper is to use Bayesian inference to quantify the uncertainty in each gradient dimension. The authors place a probability distribution over the task-specific parameters, which in turn induces a distribution over the gradients of the tasks. This additional information allows the method to weigh the gradients based on their uncertainty when aggregating them.

The authors evaluate their approach on a variety of datasets and show that it achieves state-of-the-art performance compared to other MTL methods. This demonstrates the benefits of considering gradient uncertainty when optimizing MTL models.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of accounting for gradient uncertainty in multi-task learning (MTL). The proposed Bayesian approach is a novel contribution and the empirical results are promising.

However, the authors do not discuss any potential limitations or caveats of their method. For example, it's unclear how the method would scale to very large models or a large number of tasks. Additionally, the computational overhead of the Bayesian inference process is not analyzed.

It would also be valuable to see the method tested on a wider range of task types and datasets to further validate its effectiveness. Applying it to real-world applications with high stakes, such as healthcare or finance, could provide insights into its practical implications.

Overall, this is a well-executed piece of research that introduces an interesting and potentially impactful technique for improving multi-task learning. Further exploration of the method's capabilities and limitations would be a useful next step.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel gradient aggregation approach for multi-task learning that leverages Bayesian inference to quantify the uncertainty in the gradient dimensions. By considering this uncertainty, the method is able to outperform existing MTL techniques on a variety of datasets.

The key insight is that accounting for the sensitivity and reliability of the gradients can lead to more effective model optimization for tasks solved jointly. This work highlights the importance of uncertainty awareness in machine learning and demonstrates its potential benefits.

As machine learning becomes more pervasive, techniques like this that enable efficient multi-task learning will be increasingly valuable. The authors' Bayesian approach represents an important step forward in this direction and is likely to inspire further research in this area.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏷️

Total Score

0

Bayesian Uncertainty for Gradient Aggregation in Multi-Task Learning

Idan Achituve, Idit Diamant, Arnon Netzer, Gal Chechik, Ethan Fetaya

As machine learning becomes more prominent there is a growing demand to perform several inference tasks in parallel. Running a dedicated model for each task is computationally expensive and therefore there is a great interest in multi-task learning (MTL). MTL aims at learning a single model that solves several tasks efficiently. Optimizing MTL models is often achieved by computing a single gradient per task and aggregating them for obtaining a combined update direction. However, these approaches do not consider an important aspect, the sensitivity in the gradient dimensions. Here, we introduce a novel gradient aggregation approach using Bayesian inference. We place a probability distribution over the task-specific parameters, which in turn induce a distribution over the gradients of the tasks. This additional valuable information allows us to quantify the uncertainty in each of the gradients dimensions, which can then be factored in when aggregating them. We empirically demonstrate the benefits of our approach in a variety of datasets, achieving state-of-the-art performance.

Read more

5/14/2024

Interpetable Target-Feature Aggregation for Multi-Task Learning based on Bias-Variance Analysis
Total Score

0

Interpetable Target-Feature Aggregation for Multi-Task Learning based on Bias-Variance Analysis

Paolo Bonetti, Alberto Maria Metelli, Marcello Restelli

Multi-task learning (MTL) is a powerful machine learning paradigm designed to leverage shared knowledge across tasks to improve generalization and performance. Previous works have proposed approaches to MTL that can be divided into feature learning, focused on the identification of a common feature representation, and task clustering, where similar tasks are grouped together. In this paper, we propose an MTL approach at the intersection between task clustering and feature transformation based on a two-phase iterative aggregation of targets and features. First, we propose a bias-variance analysis for regression models with additive Gaussian noise, where we provide a general expression of the asymptotic bias and variance of a task, considering a linear regression trained on aggregated input features and an aggregated target. Then, we exploit this analysis to provide a two-phase MTL algorithm (NonLinCTFA). Firstly, this method partitions the tasks into clusters and aggregates each obtained group of targets with their mean. Then, for each aggregated task, it aggregates subsets of features with their mean in a dimensionality reduction fashion. In both phases, a key aspect is to preserve the interpretability of the reduced targets and features through the aggregation with the mean, which is further motivated by applications to Earth science. Finally, we validate the algorithms on synthetic data, showing the effect of different parameters and real-world datasets, exploring the validity of the proposed methodology on classical datasets, recent baselines, and Earth science applications.

Read more

6/13/2024

Analytical Uncertainty-Based Loss Weighting in Multi-Task Learning
Total Score

0

Analytical Uncertainty-Based Loss Weighting in Multi-Task Learning

Lukas Kirchdorfer, Cathrin Elich, Simon Kutsche, Heiner Stuckenschmidt, Lukas Schott, Jan M. Kohler

With the rise of neural networks in various domains, multi-task learning (MTL) gained significant relevance. A key challenge in MTL is balancing individual task losses during neural network training to improve performance and efficiency through knowledge sharing across tasks. To address these challenges, we propose a novel task-weighting method by building on the most prevalent approach of Uncertainty Weighting and computing analytically optimal uncertainty-based weights, normalized by a softmax function with tunable temperature. Our approach yields comparable results to the combinatorially prohibitive, brute-force approach of Scalarization while offering a more cost-effective yet high-performing alternative. We conduct an extensive benchmark on various datasets and architectures. Our method consistently outperforms six other common weighting methods. Furthermore, we report noteworthy experimental findings for the practical application of MTL. For example, larger networks diminish the influence of weighting methods, and tuning the weight decay has a low impact compared to the learning rate.

Read more

8/16/2024

Scalable Multitask Learning Using Gradient-based Estimation of Task Affinity
Total Score

0

Scalable Multitask Learning Using Gradient-based Estimation of Task Affinity

Dongyue Li, Aneesh Sharma, Hongyang R. Zhang

Multitask learning is a widely used paradigm for training models on diverse tasks, with applications ranging from graph neural networks to language model fine-tuning. Since tasks may interfere with each other, a key notion for modeling their relationships is task affinity. This includes pairwise task affinity, computed among pairs of tasks, and higher-order affinity, computed among subsets of tasks. Naively computing either of them requires repeatedly training on data from various task combinations, which is computationally intensive. We present a new algorithm Grad-TAG that can estimate task affinities without this repeated training. The key idea of Grad-TAG is to train a base model for all tasks and then use a linearization technique to estimate the loss of the model for a specific task combination. The linearization works by computing a gradient-based approximation of the loss, using low-dimensional projections of gradients as features in a logistic regression to predict labels for the task combination. We show that the linearized model can provably approximate the loss when the gradient-based approximation is accurate, and also empirically verify that on several large models. Then, given the estimated task affinity, we design a semi-definite program for clustering similar tasks by maximizing the average density of clusters. We evaluate Grad-TAG's performance across seven datasets, including multi-label classification on graphs, and instruction fine-tuning of language models. Our task affinity estimates are within 2.7% distance to the true affinities while needing only 3% of FLOPs in full training. On our largest graph with 21M edges and 500 labeling tasks, our algorithm delivers estimates within 5% distance to the true affinities, using only 112 GPU hours. Our results show that Grad-TAG achieves excellent performance and runtime tradeoffs compared to existing approaches.

Read more

9/11/2024