Theoretical Analysis of Submodular Information Measures for Targeted Data Subset Selection
2402.13454
0
0
Abstract
With increasing volume of data being used across machine learning tasks, the capability to target specific subsets of data becomes more important. To aid in this capability, the recently proposed Submodular Mutual Information (SMI) has been effectively applied across numerous tasks in literature to perform targeted subset selection with the aid of a exemplar query set. However, all such works are deficient in providing theoretical guarantees for SMI in terms of its sensitivity to a subset's relevance and coverage of the targeted data. For the first time, we provide such guarantees by deriving similarity-based bounds on quantities related to relevance and coverage of the targeted data. With these bounds, we show that the SMI functions, which have empirically shown success in multiple applications, are theoretically sound in achieving good query relevance and query coverage.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This research paper provides a theoretical analysis of submodular information measures for targeted data subset selection.
- It explores the use of submodular functions to efficiently select informative data subsets for machine learning tasks, such as hypothesis testing and classification.
- The paper analyzes the mathematical properties of submodular information measures and their implications for data subset selection.
Plain English Explanation
Imagine you have a large dataset, but you don't need to use all of it for your machine learning model. The goal is to find the most informative subset of the data that will give you the best performance, without wasting time and resources on unnecessary data.
The researchers in this paper use a mathematical concept called "submodularity" to help solve this problem. Submodular functions have the property that adding an element to a smaller set provides more "value" than adding that same element to a larger set. This makes submodular functions well-suited for efficiently selecting the most informative data subsets.
The paper analyzes the theoretical properties of submodular information measures, such as mutual information, and how they can be used to identify the most valuable data points for tasks like hypothesis testing and classification. This can help machine learning models achieve better performance with less data, saving time and computational resources.
The researchers also discuss how submodular information measures can be used to enhance the robustness of machine learning systems by identifying the most informative data points for a given task.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the use of submodular information measures, such as mutual information, for targeted data subset selection. Submodular functions have the property that the marginal gain of adding an element to a set decreases as the set size increases. This makes them well-suited for efficiently selecting informative data subsets.
The researchers analyze the mathematical properties of submodular information measures and their implications for data subset selection. They explore how these measures can be used to identify the most valuable data points for tasks like hypothesis testing and classification, where the goal is to minimize misclassification penalties.
The paper also discusses how submodular information measures can be used to enhance the robustness of machine learning systems by identifying the most informative data points for a given task, even in the presence of distribution shifts or other sources of uncertainty.
The theoretical analysis provided in the paper offers insights into the strengths and limitations of submodular information measures for targeted data subset selection, paving the way for more efficient and effective machine learning models.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of submodular information measures and their application to data subset selection, but it does not present any empirical results or case studies. While the theoretical insights are valuable, it would be helpful to see how the proposed approaches perform in practical settings.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential challenges in scaling these techniques to large-scale, high-dimensional datasets, which are common in many real-world machine learning applications. Further research may be needed to understand the computational complexity and practical limitations of the proposed methods.
The paper also does not delve into the implications of using submodular information measures for ethical and fairness considerations in data subset selection. As these techniques become more widely adopted, it will be important to consider how they may impact the representativeness and inclusiveness of the selected data.
Conclusion
This research paper provides a theoretical analysis of submodular information measures and their potential for targeted data subset selection in machine learning tasks. The key insights include the use of submodular functions to efficiently identify the most informative data points, which can lead to improved model performance and robustness while reducing computational resources.
While the paper does not present empirical results, the theoretical analysis lays the groundwork for further research and development in this area. As the field of machine learning continues to evolve, techniques like those discussed in this paper may become increasingly important for building effective and responsible AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧪
Submodular Information Selection for Hypothesis Testing with Misclassification Penalties
Jayanth Bhargav, Mahsa Ghasemi, Shreyas Sundaram
0
0
We consider the problem of selecting an optimal subset of information sources for a hypothesis testing/classification task where the goal is to identify the true state of the world from a finite set of hypotheses, based on finite observation samples from the sources. In order to characterize the learning performance, we propose a misclassification penalty framework, which enables nonuniform treatment of different misclassification errors. In a centralized Bayesian learning setting, we study two variants of the subset selection problem: (i) selecting a minimum cost information set to ensure that the maximum penalty of misclassifying the true hypothesis is below a desired bound and (ii) selecting an optimal information set under a limited budget to minimize the maximum penalty of misclassifying the true hypothesis. Under certain assumptions, we prove that the objective (or constraints) of these combinatorial optimization problems are weak (or approximate) submodular, and establish high-probability performance guarantees for greedy algorithms. Further, we propose an alternate metric for information set selection which is based on the total penalty of misclassification. We prove that this metric is submodular and establish near-optimal guarantees for the greedy algorithms for both the information set selection problems. Finally, we present numerical simulations to validate our theoretical results over several randomly generated instances.
7/1/2024
🧠
Enhancing Neural Subset Selection: Integrating Background Information into Set Representations
Binghui Xie, Yatao Bian, Kaiwen zhou, Yongqiang Chen, Peilin Zhao, Bo Han, Wei Meng, James Cheng
0
0
Learning neural subset selection tasks, such as compound selection in AI-aided drug discovery, have become increasingly pivotal across diverse applications. The existing methodologies in the field primarily concentrate on constructing models that capture the relationship between utility function values and subsets within their respective supersets. However, these approaches tend to overlook the valuable information contained within the superset when utilizing neural networks to model set functions. In this work, we address this oversight by adopting a probabilistic perspective. Our theoretical findings demonstrate that when the target value is conditioned on both the input set and subset, it is essential to incorporate an textit{invariant sufficient statistic} of the superset into the subset of interest for effective learning. This ensures that the output value remains invariant to permutations of the subset and its corresponding superset, enabling identification of the specific superset from which the subset originated. Motivated by these insights, we propose a simple yet effective information aggregation module designed to merge the representations of subsets and supersets from a permutation invariance perspective. Comprehensive empirical evaluations across diverse tasks and datasets validate the enhanced efficacy of our approach over conventional methods, underscoring the practicality and potency of our proposed strategies in real-world contexts.
6/11/2024
Slicing Mutual Information Generalization Bounds for Neural Networks
Kimia Nadjahi, Kristjan Greenewald, Rickard Bruel Gabrielsson, Justin Solomon
0
0
The ability of machine learning (ML) algorithms to generalize well to unseen data has been studied through the lens of information theory, by bounding the generalization error with the input-output mutual information (MI), i.e., the MI between the training data and the learned hypothesis. Yet, these bounds have limited practicality for modern ML applications (e.g., deep learning), due to the difficulty of evaluating MI in high dimensions. Motivated by recent findings on the compressibility of neural networks, we consider algorithms that operate by slicing the parameter space, i.e., trained on random lower-dimensional subspaces. We introduce new, tighter information-theoretic generalization bounds tailored for such algorithms, demonstrating that slicing improves generalization. Our bounds offer significant computational and statistical advantages over standard MI bounds, as they rely on scalable alternative measures of dependence, i.e., disintegrated mutual information and $k$-sliced mutual information. Then, we extend our analysis to algorithms whose parameters do not need to exactly lie on random subspaces, by leveraging rate-distortion theory. This strategy yields generalization bounds that incorporate a distortion term measuring model compressibility under slicing, thereby tightening existing bounds without compromising performance or requiring model compression. Building on this, we propose a regularization scheme enabling practitioners to control generalization through compressibility. Finally, we empirically validate our results and achieve the computation of non-vacuous information-theoretic generalization bounds for neural networks, a task that was previously out of reach.
6/7/2024
Semantic Membership Inference Attack against Large Language Models
Hamid Mozaffari, Virendra J. Marathe
0
0
Membership Inference Attacks (MIAs) determine whether a specific data point was included in the training set of a target model. In this paper, we introduce the Semantic Membership Inference Attack (SMIA), a novel approach that enhances MIA performance by leveraging the semantic content of inputs and their perturbations. SMIA trains a neural network to analyze the target model's behavior on perturbed inputs, effectively capturing variations in output probability distributions between members and non-members. We conduct comprehensive evaluations on the Pythia and GPT-Neo model families using the Wikipedia dataset. Our results show that SMIA significantly outperforms existing MIAs; for instance, SMIA achieves an AUC-ROC of 67.39% on Pythia-12B, compared to 58.90% by the second-best attack.
6/17/2024