This actually looks like that: Proto-BagNets for local and global interpretability-by-design
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new neural network architecture called Proto-BagNets that aims to be both locally and globally interpretable.
- Proto-BagNets combine the interpretable properties of prototype-based models with the robustness and performance of convolutional neural networks.
- The proposed approach allows for both local (feature-level) and global (class-level) interpretability, providing users with a better understanding of how the model makes decisions.
Plain English Explanation
This paper introduces a new type of neural network called Proto-BagNets that is designed to be more interpretable than standard deep learning models. Interpretability is important because it allows us to understand how the model is making its predictions, rather than treating the model like a "black box."
Proto-BagNets work by combining two key ideas: prototype-based models and convolutional neural networks (CNNs). Prototype-based models try to represent each class using a set of "prototypes" - examples that are representative of that class. CNNs, on the other hand, are very good at extracting useful visual features from images.
By combining these two approaches, Proto-BagNets can provide both local interpretability (understanding which specific features of the image are driving the prediction) and global interpretability (understanding how the overall set of prototypes leads to the final classification). This allows users to get a more complete understanding of how the model is working.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of Proto-BagNets on several image classification tasks, showing that they can achieve good performance while also providing clear explanations for their predictions.
Technical Explanation
Prototype-based models work by representing each class using a set of "prototypes" - examples that are typical of that class. This allows the model to provide explanations for its predictions by pointing to the most relevant prototypes. However, prototype-based models can struggle with complex visual tasks like image classification.
The Proto-BagNet architecture combines these two approaches. It uses a CNN backbone to extract visual features, but then aggregates these features into a set of "bag-of-prototypes" representations, one for each class. The final prediction is made by comparing the input image to these class-level prototypes.
This allows Proto-BagNets to provide both local interpretability (by highlighting the specific features that match the prototypes) and global interpretability (by showing which prototypes are most relevant for the final prediction).
The authors evaluate Proto-BagNets on several image classification tasks, including medical image classification for breast cancer prediction. They show that Proto-BagNets can achieve competitive performance while also providing meaningful explanations for its predictions.
Critical Analysis
The authors make a compelling case for the importance of interpretability in deep learning models, and the Proto-BagNet architecture represents an interesting approach to this challenge. By combining prototype-based reasoning with the feature extraction power of CNNs, the authors have created a model that can provide both local and global interpretability.
That said, the authors acknowledge several limitations of their approach. For example, the prototype-based reasoning can be sensitive to the specific choice of prototypes, and the overall model complexity may limit its scalability to very large datasets. Additionally, the authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the types of errors the model makes or the reliability of its explanations.
Further research would be needed to fully assess the practical impact and generalizability of Proto-BagNets. It would be valuable to see the model tested on a wider range of tasks and datasets, and to explore ways to make the prototype selection and aggregation more robust and efficient.
Overall, this paper represents an important step towards more interpretable deep learning models, and the Proto-BagNet architecture is a promising direction for future work in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel neural network architecture called Proto-BagNets that aims to provide both local and global interpretability for image classification tasks. By combining prototype-based reasoning with the feature extraction power of convolutional neural networks, Proto-BagNets can explain its predictions at both the feature level and the class level.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach on several image classification benchmarks, including medical imaging applications. While the model has some limitations, it represents an important step towards more transparent and explainable deep learning systems. Further research in this area could lead to significant advancements in the interpretability and trustworthiness of AI-powered decision-making.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
This actually looks like that: Proto-BagNets for local and global interpretability-by-design
Kerol Djoumessi, Bubacarr Bah, Laura Kuhlewein, Philipp Berens, Lisa Koch
Interpretability is a key requirement for the use of machine learning models in high-stakes applications, including medical diagnosis. Explaining black-box models mostly relies on post-hoc methods that do not faithfully reflect the model's behavior. As a remedy, prototype-based networks have been proposed, but their interpretability is limited as they have been shown to provide coarse, unreliable, and imprecise explanations. In this work, we introduce Proto-BagNets, an interpretable-by-design prototype-based model that combines the advantages of bag-of-local feature models and prototype learning to provide meaningful, coherent, and relevant prototypical parts needed for accurate and interpretable image classification tasks. We evaluated the Proto-BagNet for drusen detection on publicly available retinal OCT data. The Proto-BagNet performed comparably to the state-of-the-art interpretable and non-interpretable models while providing faithful, accurate, and clinically meaningful local and global explanations. The code is available at https://github.com/kdjoumessi/Proto-BagNets.
Read more6/26/2024
0
This Looks Better than That: Better Interpretable Models with ProtoPNeXt
Frank Willard, Luke Moffett, Emmanuel Mokel, Jon Donnelly, Stark Guo, Julia Yang, Giyoung Kim, Alina Jade Barnett, Cynthia Rudin
Prototypical-part models are a popular interpretable alternative to black-box deep learning models for computer vision. However, they are difficult to train, with high sensitivity to hyperparameter tuning, inhibiting their application to new datasets and our understanding of which methods truly improve their performance. To facilitate the careful study of prototypical-part networks (ProtoPNets), we create a new framework for integrating components of prototypical-part models -- ProtoPNeXt. Using ProtoPNeXt, we show that applying Bayesian hyperparameter tuning and an angular prototype similarity metric to the original ProtoPNet is sufficient to produce new state-of-the-art accuracy for prototypical-part models on CUB-200 across multiple backbones. We further deploy this framework to jointly optimize for accuracy and prototype interpretability as measured by metrics included in ProtoPNeXt. Using the same resources, this produces models with substantially superior semantics and changes in accuracy between +1.3% and -1.5%. The code and trained models will be made publicly available upon publication.
Read more6/24/2024
🖼️
0
Deformable ProtoPNet: An Interpretable Image Classifier Using Deformable Prototypes
Jon Donnelly, Alina Jade Barnett, Chaofan Chen
We present a deformable prototypical part network (Deformable ProtoPNet), an interpretable image classifier that integrates the power of deep learning and the interpretability of case-based reasoning. This model classifies input images by comparing them with prototypes learned during training, yielding explanations in the form of this looks like that. However, while previous methods use spatially rigid prototypes, we address this shortcoming by proposing spatially flexible prototypes. Each prototype is made up of several prototypical parts that adaptively change their relative spatial positions depending on the input image. Consequently, a Deformable ProtoPNet can explicitly capture pose variations and context, improving both model accuracy and the richness of explanations provided. Compared to other case-based interpretable models using prototypes, our approach achieves state-of-the-art accuracy and gives an explanation with greater context. The code is available at https://github.com/jdonnelly36/Deformable-ProtoPNet.
Read more5/6/2024
🌐
0
This Probably Looks Exactly Like That: An Invertible Prototypical Network
Zachariah Carmichael, Timothy Redgrave, Daniel Gonzalez Cedre, Walter J. Scheirer
We combine concept-based neural networks with generative, flow-based classifiers into a novel, intrinsically explainable, exactly invertible approach to supervised learning. Prototypical neural networks, a type of concept-based neural network, represent an exciting way forward in realizing human-comprehensible machine learning without concept annotations, but a human-machine semantic gap continues to haunt current approaches. We find that reliance on indirect interpretation functions for prototypical explanations imposes a severe limit on prototypes' informative power. From this, we posit that invertibly learning prototypes as distributions over the latent space provides more robust, expressive, and interpretable modeling. We propose one such model, called ProtoFlow, by composing a normalizing flow with Gaussian mixture models. ProtoFlow (1) sets a new state-of-the-art in joint generative and predictive modeling and (2) achieves predictive performance comparable to existing prototypical neural networks while enabling richer interpretation.
Read more7/18/2024