Trajectory Data Suffices for Statistically Efficient Learning in Offline RL with Linear $q^pi$-Realizability and Concentrability
0
📊
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the statistical efficiency of offline reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms under linear 𝑞^𝜋-realizability and concentrability conditions.
- It shows that trajectory data can be sufficient for statistically efficient learning in offline RL, without the need for additional exploration data.
- The paper provides theoretical guarantees for the performance of offline RL algorithms and demonstrates their practical effectiveness through empirical evaluations.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at a type of reinforcement learning called "offline reinforcement learning." In this setting, the learning algorithm doesn't get to interact with the environment directly. Instead, it has to learn just from a fixed dataset of previous interactions, without the ability to try new things.
The key idea is that under certain conditions, this fixed dataset of past trajectories can actually be enough for the learning algorithm to perform well. Specifically, the authors show that if the value function (which estimates how good each state and action are) can be represented using a linear model, and if the data covers the important parts of the state-action space, then the algorithm can learn efficiently using just this pre-collected data.
This is an important result because it means that expensive and time-consuming exploration of the environment may not always be necessary for reinforcement learning. The algorithm can instead learn a good policy just from the data that has already been gathered, without needing to collect more. This could make reinforcement learning more practical in real-world applications where direct interaction with the environment is difficult or costly.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes the statistical efficiency of offline reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms under the assumptions of linear 𝑞^𝜋-realizability and concentrability.
Specifically, the authors show that with these assumptions, trajectory data can be sufficient for statistically efficient learning in offline RL, without requiring additional exploration data. They provide theoretical guarantees on the performance of offline RL algorithms and demonstrate their practical effectiveness through empirical evaluations.
The key idea is that under linear 𝑞^𝜋-realizability, the value function can be well-approximated using a linear model. And under concentrability, the offline data covers the important parts of the state-action space. Together, these conditions enable efficient learning from the pre-collected trajectory data alone, without the need for further exploration.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes important theoretical and empirical contributions to the understanding of offline reinforcement learning. However, there are a few caveats and limitations worth noting:
First, the linear 𝑞^𝜋-realizability and concentrability assumptions may not hold in all real-world problems. The applicability of the results depends on the problem structure and the quality of the offline data. Distributionally robust approaches could be explored to relax these assumptions.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the statistical efficiency of the learning process, but does not address other important practical concerns such as sample complexity, computational efficiency, or robustness to distributional shift. Further research is needed to holistically evaluate the performance of offline RL algorithms in more realistic settings.
Conclusion
This paper provides a strong theoretical foundation for the use of trajectory data in statistically efficient offline reinforcement learning. By identifying conditions under which the pre-collected data can be sufficient, it suggests that expensive exploration may not always be necessary for effective RL.
The results could have significant implications for making reinforcement learning more practical and accessible, especially in domains where direct interaction with the environment is costly or dangerous. However, further research is needed to address the limitations and broaden the applicability of these techniques.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
0
Trajectory Data Suffices for Statistically Efficient Learning in Offline RL with Linear $q^pi$-Realizability and Concentrability
Volodymyr Tkachuk, Gell'ert Weisz, Csaba Szepesv'ari
We consider offline reinforcement learning (RL) in $H$-horizon Markov decision processes (MDPs) under the linear $q^pi$-realizability assumption, where the action-value function of every policy is linear with respect to a given $d$-dimensional feature function. The hope in this setting is that learning a good policy will be possible without requiring a sample size that scales with the number of states in the MDP. Foster et al. [2021] have shown this to be impossible even under $textit{concentrability}$, a data coverage assumption where a coefficient $C_text{conc}$ bounds the extent to which the state-action distribution of any policy can veer off the data distribution. However, the data in this previous work was in the form of a sequence of individual transitions. This leaves open the question of whether the negative result mentioned could be overcome if the data was composed of sequences of full trajectories. In this work we answer this question positively by proving that with trajectory data, a dataset of size $text{poly}(d,H,C_text{conc})/epsilon^2$ is sufficient for deriving an $epsilon$-optimal policy, regardless of the size of the state space. The main tool that makes this result possible is due to Weisz et al. [2023], who demonstrate that linear MDPs can be used to approximate linearly $q^pi$-realizable MDPs. The connection to trajectory data is that the linear MDP approximation relies on skipping over certain states. The associated estimation problems are thus easy when working with trajectory data, while they remain nontrivial when working with individual transitions. The question of computational efficiency under our assumptions remains open.
Read more5/28/2024
🌿
0
Confident Natural Policy Gradient for Local Planning in $q_pi$-realizable Constrained MDPs
Tian Tian, Lin F. Yang, Csaba Szepesv'ari
The constrained Markov decision process (CMDP) framework emerges as an important reinforcement learning approach for imposing safety or other critical objectives while maximizing cumulative reward. However, the current understanding of how to learn efficiently in a CMDP environment with a potentially infinite number of states remains under investigation, particularly when function approximation is applied to the value functions. In this paper, we address the learning problem given linear function approximation with $q_{pi}$-realizability, where the value functions of all policies are linearly representable with a known feature map, a setting known to be more general and challenging than other linear settings. Utilizing a local-access model, we propose a novel primal-dual algorithm that, after $tilde{O}(text{poly}(d) epsilon^{-3})$ queries, outputs with high probability a policy that strictly satisfies the constraints while nearly optimizing the value with respect to a reward function. Here, $d$ is the feature dimension and $epsilon > 0$ is a given error. The algorithm relies on a carefully crafted off-policy evaluation procedure to evaluate the policy using historical data, which informs policy updates through policy gradients and conserves samples. To our knowledge, this is the first result achieving polynomial sample complexity for CMDP in the $q_{pi}$-realizable setting.
Read more6/27/2024
🏅
0
Sample- and Oracle-Efficient Reinforcement Learning for MDPs with Linearly-Realizable Value Functions
Zakaria Mhammedi
Designing sample-efficient and computationally feasible reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms is particularly challenging in environments with large or infinite state and action spaces. In this paper, we advance this effort by presenting an efficient algorithm for Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) where the state-action value function of any policy is linear in a given feature map. This challenging setting can model environments with infinite states and actions, strictly generalizes classic linear MDPs, and currently lacks a computationally efficient algorithm under online access to the MDP. Specifically, we introduce a new RL algorithm that efficiently finds a near-optimal policy in this setting, using a number of episodes and calls to a cost-sensitive classification (CSC) oracle that are both polynomial in the problem parameters. Notably, our CSC oracle can be efficiently implemented when the feature dimension is constant, representing a clear improvement over state-of-the-art methods, which require solving non-convex problems with horizon-many variables and can incur computational costs that are emph{exponential} in the horizon.
Read more9/10/2024
🐍
0
Sample Complexity of Offline Distributionally Robust Linear Markov Decision Processes
He Wang, Laixi Shi, Yuejie Chi
In offline reinforcement learning (RL), the absence of active exploration calls for attention on the model robustness to tackle the sim-to-real gap, where the discrepancy between the simulated and deployed environments can significantly undermine the performance of the learned policy. To endow the learned policy with robustness in a sample-efficient manner in the presence of high-dimensional state-action space, this paper considers the sample complexity of distributionally robust linear Markov decision processes (MDPs) with an uncertainty set characterized by the total variation distance using offline data. We develop a pessimistic model-based algorithm and establish its sample complexity bound under minimal data coverage assumptions, which outperforms prior art by at least $widetilde{O}(d)$, where $d$ is the feature dimension. We further improve the performance guarantee of the proposed algorithm by incorporating a carefully-designed variance estimator.
Read more6/28/2024