ULDP-FL: Federated Learning with Across Silo User-Level Differential Privacy

Overview

• Differentially Private Federated Learning (DP-FL) is a collaborative machine learning approach that ensures formal privacy.
• Most DP-FL methods ensure differential privacy (DP) at the record-level within each silo (group) for cross-silo federated learning.
• However, when a single user's data spans multiple silos, the desired user-level DP guarantee remains unknown.
• This study presents Uldp-FL, a novel federated learning framework designed to guarantee user-level DP in cross-silo federated learning scenarios where a user's data may belong to multiple silos.

Plain English Explanation

Federated learning is a way for different organizations to collaborate on training a machine learning model without directly sharing their sensitive data. Differentially Private Federated Learning (DP-FL) is an approach that adds extra privacy protections to this process.

Most DP-FL methods focus on ensuring privacy at the individual record level within each organization or "silo". However, in reality, a single person's data may be spread across multiple silos. The researchers behind this paper wanted to find a way to protect the privacy of individual users, even when their data is split up.

To do this, they developed a new federated learning framework called Uldp-FL. This system directly ensures user-level differential privacy, meaning it protects the privacy of individual users, rather than just individual records. It does this through a novel technique called "per-user weighted clipping," which is different from previous "group-privacy" approaches.

The researchers also came up with ways to improve the usefulness of the Uldp-FL system, by carefully weighting the contributions of different users based on how their data is distributed. And they designed a new private protocol to ensure that no extra information is revealed to the organizations or the central server during the federated learning process.

Through experiments on real-world datasets, the researchers showed that their Uldp-FL framework provides substantially better privacy-utility tradeoffs compared to existing methods, when the goal is to protect the privacy of individual users in cross-silo federated learning.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation in this paper is the Uldp-FL framework, which is designed to provide user-level differential privacy guarantees in cross-silo federated learning scenarios.

Unlike prior DP-FL approaches that focus on record-level privacy within each silo, Uldp-FL directly ensures user-level DP by using a "per-user weighted clipping" technique, rather than a group-privacy approach. This means that the system protects the privacy of individual users, even when their data is spread across multiple silos.

The researchers provide a theoretical analysis of Uldp-FL's privacy and utility guarantees. They also enhance the utility of the system through an improved weighting strategy that considers the distribution of each user's data records. Additionally, they design a novel private protocol that ensures no extra information is revealed to the silos or the central server during the federated learning process.

Experiments on real-world datasets demonstrate that Uldp-FL significantly outperforms baseline DP-FL methods in terms of privacy-utility tradeoffs when the goal is to achieve user-level differential privacy in cross-silo federated learning. Differentially Private Hierarchical Federated Learning, Noise-Aware Algorithm for Heterogeneous Differentially Private Federated, FedLAP: DP Federated Learning by Sharing Differentially, and Multi-Level Personalized Federated Learning for Heterogeneous Long are some related works in this space.

Critical Analysis

The paper acknowledges that while Uldp-FL provides user-level differential privacy guarantees, there may be some inherent limitations to this approach. For example, the researchers note that their weighting strategy, while improving utility, could potentially reveal additional information about user data distributions to the central server.

Additionally, the paper does not explore how Uldp-FL would perform in scenarios with highly skewed or imbalanced user data distributions across silos. This could be an important consideration, as unequal representation of user data could impact the overall model performance and privacy-utility tradeoffs.

Further research could also investigate the scalability of Uldp-FL as the number of users and silos increases, as well as its robustness to potential attacks or adversarial behavior from malicious actors within the federated learning system.

Conclusion

This study presents Uldp-FL, a novel federated learning framework that directly ensures user-level differential privacy in cross-silo federated learning scenarios. By using a per-user weighted clipping approach and an enhanced weighting strategy, Uldp-FL is able to achieve substantial improvements in privacy-utility tradeoffs compared to baseline DP-FL methods.

The authors' work is the first to effectively provide user-level differential privacy guarantees in the general cross-silo federated learning setting. This is a significant advancement, as it addresses a crucial limitation of prior DP-FL approaches and brings us closer to realizing the full potential of federated learning while maintaining strong privacy protections for individual users.