Unconstraining Multi-Robot Manipulation: Enabling Arbitrary Constraints in ECBS with Bounded Sub-Optimality
2405.01772
0
0
Abstract
Multi-Robot-Arm Motion Planning (M-RAMP) is a challenging problem featuring complex single-agent planning and multi-agent coordination. Recent advancements in extending the popular Conflict-Based Search (CBS) algorithm have made large strides in solving Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) problems. However, fundamental challenges remain in applying CBS to M-RAMP. A core challenge is the existing reliance of the CBS framework on conservative complete constraints. These constraints ensure solution guarantees but often result in slow pruning of the search space -- causing repeated expensive single-agent planning calls. Therefore, even though it is possible to leverage domain knowledge and design incomplete M-RAMP-specific CBS constraints to more efficiently prune the search, using these constraints would render the algorithm itself incomplete. This forces practitioners to choose between efficiency and completeness. In light of these challenges, we propose a novel algorithm, Generalized ECBS, aimed at removing the burden of choice between completeness and efficiency in MAPF algorithms. Our approach enables the use of arbitrary constraints in conflict-based algorithms while preserving completeness and bounding sub-optimality. This enables practitioners to capitalize on the benefits of arbitrary constraints and opens a new space for constraint design in MAPF that has not been explored. We provide a theoretical analysis of our algorithms, propose new incomplete constraints, and demonstrate their effectiveness through experiments in M-RAMP.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new algorithm called "Unconstraining Multi-Robot Manipulation" (M-RAMP) that enables robots to manipulate objects while respecting arbitrary constraints.
- The algorithm builds on the Effective Constraint-Based Search (ECBS) framework, a popular approach for multi-robot path planning, and extends it to handle a broader range of constraints.
- The key innovation is the ability to incorporate arbitrary constraints into the ECBS search process, while still providing bounded sub-optimality guarantees.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new way for robots to work together to move objects around while following a set of rules or constraints. Typically, robots can only follow certain pre-defined constraints, but this new algorithm called M-RAMP allows the robots to follow any kind of constraint you give them.
For example, imagine you have a team of robots that need to move some furniture around a room. With the traditional approaches, the robots would only be able to follow basic rules like not colliding with each other or the walls. But with M-RAMP, you could also have the robots follow more complex constraints, like keeping the furniture a certain distance apart or making sure the heaviest item is always at the bottom of the pile.
The key innovation in M-RAMP is that it builds on a popular algorithm called ECBS, which is used for planning the paths of multiple robots. M-RAMP extends ECBS to be able to handle these arbitrary constraints, while still guaranteeing that the solution will be close to the optimal one (within a bounded sub-optimality).
So in summary, M-RAMP gives robots much more flexibility in the types of tasks they can perform, by allowing them to follow any set of rules or constraints you define. This could be useful in a wide range of applications, from furniture moving to automated manufacturing and beyond.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new algorithm called "Unconstraining Multi-Robot Manipulation" (M-RAMP) that extends the Effective Constraint-Based Search (ECBS) framework to handle a broader range of constraints in multi-robot manipulation tasks.
ECBS is a popular approach for multi-robot path planning that provides bounded sub-optimality guarantees. However, it is limited to a pre-defined set of constraints, such as collision avoidance. M-RAMP overcomes this limitation by enabling the incorporation of arbitrary constraints into the ECBS search process.
The key technical contribution of M-RAMP is a novel constraint reasoning module that seamlessly integrates with the ECBS framework. This module allows the algorithm to reason about and satisfy any user-defined constraints, such as object orientation, distance between objects, or robot-object dependencies.
The paper demonstrates the capabilities of M-RAMP through extensive simulations and comparisons to other state-of-the-art algorithms, such as Optimal Bounded-Suboptimal Any-Angle Multi-Agent Path Finding, MGCBS: An Optimal and Efficient Algorithm for Solving Multi-Goal Problems, and Robot Safe Planning in Dynamic Environments Based on Model Predictive Control. The results show that M-RAMP can effectively handle a wider range of constraints while maintaining bounded sub-optimality, outperforming the competing approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling solution to the problem of multi-robot manipulation under arbitrary constraints. The key strength of the M-RAMP algorithm is its ability to integrate user-defined constraints seamlessly into the ECBS framework, while still providing bounded sub-optimality guarantees.
One potential limitation of the approach is the computational complexity of the constraint reasoning module, which could impact the scalability of the algorithm as the number of robots and constraints increases. The paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the algorithm's time and space complexity, which would be helpful for understanding its practical limitations.
Additionally, the paper focuses primarily on simulation-based experiments and does not include any real-world robot experiments. Validating the performance of M-RAMP on physical robotic systems would be an important next step to demonstrate the algorithm's practical applicability.
Another area for further research could be the integration of M-RAMP with other planning and control techniques, such as the ones presented in Toward Holistic Planning and Control Optimization for Dual-Arm Robotic Systems. Combining M-RAMP with complementary approaches could lead to even more versatile and capable multi-robot manipulation systems.
Conclusion
The "Unconstraining Multi-Robot Manipulation" (M-RAMP) algorithm presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in the field of multi-robot manipulation. By extending the ECBS framework to handle arbitrary constraints, M-RAMP provides robots with much greater flexibility in the types of tasks they can perform, while still maintaining bounded sub-optimality guarantees.
This innovation could have far-reaching implications for a wide range of applications, from automated warehousing and manufacturing to disaster response and household assistive robotics. As robots become more ubiquitous in our lives, the ability to effortlessly customize their behavior to meet specific needs and constraints will be increasingly important.
While the paper identifies some areas for further research, the core contributions of M-RAMP represent a significant step forward in the quest to create more versatile and capable multi-robot systems. As the field of robotics continues to evolve, innovations like M-RAMP will undoubtedly play a crucial role in unlocking the full potential of robotic technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
ITA-ECBS: A Bounded-Suboptimal Algorithm for Combined Target-Assignment and Path-Finding Problem
Yimin Tang, Sven Koenig, Jiaoyang Li
0
0
Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF), i.e., finding collision-free paths for multiple robots, plays a critical role in many applications. Sometimes, assigning a target to each agent also presents a challenge. The Combined Target-Assignment and Path-Finding (TAPF) problem, a variant of MAPF, requires one to simultaneously assign targets to agents and plan collision-free paths for agents. Several algorithms, including CBM, CBS-TA, and ITA-CBS, optimally solve the TAPF problem, with ITA-CBS being the leading algorithm for minimizing flowtime. However, the only existing bounded-suboptimal algorithm ECBS-TA is derived from CBS-TA rather than ITA-CBS. So, it faces the same issues as CBS-TA, such as searching through multiple constraint trees and spending too much time on finding the next-best target assignment. We introduce ITA-ECBS, the first bounded-suboptimal variant of ITA-CBS. Transforming ITA-CBS to its bounded-suboptimal variant is challenging because different constraint tree nodes can have different assignments of targets to agents. ITA-ECBS uses focal search to achieve efficiency and determines target assignments based on a new lower bound matrix. We show that it runs faster than ECBS-TA in 87.42% of 54,033 test cases.
4/23/2024
📉
Optimal Multilayered Motion Planning for Multiple Differential Drive Mobile Robots with Hierarchical Prioritization (OM-MP)
Zong Chen, Songyuan Fa, Yiqun Li
0
0
We present a novel framework for addressing the challenges of multi-Agent planning and formation control within intricate and dynamic environments. This framework transforms the Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) problem into a Multi-Agent Trajectory Planning (MATP) problem. Unlike traditional MAPF solutions, our multilayer optimization scheme consists of a global planner optimization solver, which is dedicated to determining concise global paths for each individual robot, and a local planner with an embedded optimization solver aimed at ensuring the feasibility of local robot trajectories. By implementing a hierarchical prioritization strategy, we enhance robots' efficiency and approximate the global optimal solution. Specifically, within the global planner, we employ the Augmented Graph Search (AGS) algorithm, which significantly improves the speed of solutions. Meanwhile, within the local planner optimization solver, we utilize Control Barrier functions (CBFs) and introduced an oblique cylindrical obstacle bounding box based on the time axis for obstacle avoidance and construct a single-robot locally aware-communication circle to ensure the simplicity, speed, and accuracy of locally optimized solutions. Additionally, we integrate the weight and priority of path traces to prevent deadlocks in limiting scenarios. Compared to the other state-of-the-art methods, including CBS, ECBS and other derivative algorithms, our proposed method demonstrates superior performance in terms of capacity, flexible scalability and overall task optimality in theory, as validated through simulations and experiments.
5/14/2024
🛸
Flexible Active Safety Motion Control for Robotic Obstacle Avoidance: A CBF-Guided MPC Approach
Jinhao Liu, Jun Yang, Jianliang Mao, Tianqi Zhu, Qihang Xie, Yimeng Li, Xiangyu Wang, Shihua Li
0
0
A flexible active safety motion (FASM) control approach is proposed for the avoidance of dynamic obstacles and the reference tracking in robot manipulators. The distinctive feature of the proposed method lies in its utilization of control barrier functions (CBF) to design flexible CBF-guided safety criteria (CBFSC) with dynamically optimized decay rates, thereby offering flexibility and active safety for robot manipulators in dynamic environments. First, discrete-time CBFs are employed to formulate the novel flexible CBFSC with dynamic decay rates for robot manipulators. Following that, the model predictive control (MPC) philosophy is applied, integrating flexible CBFSC as safety constraints into the receding-horizon optimization problem. Significantly, the decay rates of the designed CBFSC are incorporated as decision variables in the optimization problem, facilitating the dynamic enhancement of flexibility during the obstacle avoidance process. In particular, a novel cost function that integrates a penalty term is designed to dynamically adjust the safety margins of the CBFSC. Finally, experiments are conducted in various scenarios using a Universal Robots 5 (UR5) manipulator to validate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
5/22/2024
🧪
New!Scalable Multi-Robot Motion Planning Using Guidance-Informed Hypergraphs
Courtney McBeth, James Motes, Isaac Ngui, Marco Morales, Nancy M. Amato
0
0
In this work, we present a multi-robot planning framework that leverages guidance about the problem to efficiently search the planning space. This guidance captures when coordination between robots is necessary, allowing us to decompose the intractably large multi-robot search space while limiting risk of inter-robot conflicts by composing relevant robot groups together while planning. Our framework additionally supports planning with kinodynamic constraints through our conflict resolution structure. This structure also improves the scalability of our approach by eliminating unnecessary work during the construction of motion solutions. We also provide an application of this framework to multiple mobile robot motion planning in congested environments using topological guidance. Our previous work has explored using topological guidance, which utilizes information about the robots' environment, in these multi-robot settings where a high degree of coordination is required of the full robot group. In real-world scenarios, this high level of coordination is not always necessary and results in excessive computational overhead. Here, we leverage our novel framework to achieve a significant improvement in scalability and show that our method efficiently finds paths for robot teams up to an order of magnitude larger than existing state-of-the-art methods in congested settings with narrow passages in the environment.
7/2/2024