Understanding and Addressing the Under-Translation Problem from the Perspective of Decoding Objective
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the under-translation problem in machine translation, where the generated translations are shorter than the reference translations.
- The authors propose a new decoding objective that aims to address this issue by encouraging the model to generate more complete translations.
- They conduct experiments on synthetic data to evaluate the effectiveness of their proposed approach.
Plain English Explanation
Machine translation is the process of automatically translating text from one language to another. However, a common problem with machine translation is the "under-translation" issue, where the generated translations are shorter than the reference translations provided by human translators.
This paper explores a new approach to address the under-translation problem from the perspective of the decoding objective, which is the goal the machine translation model is trying to optimize during the translation process. The authors propose a modified decoding objective that encourages the model to generate more complete and comprehensive translations, rather than shorter, potentially incomplete ones.
To test their approach, the researchers conduct experiments on synthetic data, which is artificially generated data designed to mimic real-world translation scenarios. By using synthetic data, they can more easily control and manipulate the factors that contribute to the under-translation problem, allowing them to thoroughly evaluate the effectiveness of their proposed decoding objective.
The key idea is to shift the model's focus from simply maximizing the likelihood of the next token in the translation to also considering the overall completeness and quality of the entire translation. This helps address the under-translation issue by incentivizing the model to generate more complete and accurate translations, rather than shorter ones that may be missing important information.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the under-translation problem in machine translation, where the generated translations are shorter than the reference translations provided by human translators. To address this issue, the authors propose a new decoding objective that aims to encourage the model to generate more complete translations.
The proposed decoding objective consists of two components: the standard log-likelihood of the target tokens, and a novel "translation completeness" term. This completeness term is designed to reward the model for generating translations that are closer in length to the reference translations, thereby discouraging under-translation.
The authors conduct experiments on synthetic data to evaluate the effectiveness of their proposed decoding objective. They create synthetic source and target language pairs where the target language is constrained to be a subset of the source language, simulating the under-translation scenario. They then compare the performance of models trained with the standard log-likelihood objective and the proposed decoding objective on this synthetic data.
The results show that the models trained with the proposed decoding objective generate translations that are significantly closer in length to the reference translations, demonstrating the effectiveness of their approach in addressing the under-translation problem. The authors also discuss the implications of their findings and suggest potential avenues for future research, such as extending their approach to real-world machine translation tasks.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to addressing the under-translation problem in machine translation. By incorporating a translation completeness term into the decoding objective, the authors have demonstrated the potential to encourage the model to generate more complete and comprehensive translations.
One strength of the paper is the use of synthetic data to thoroughly evaluate the proposed decoding objective. This allows the researchers to isolate the under-translation problem and study the effectiveness of their approach in a controlled setting. However, it will be important to also test the approach on real-world machine translation tasks to understand its performance and applicability in more realistic scenarios.
Additionally, the authors acknowledge that their experiments are limited to synthetic data and suggest that future work should explore the impact of the proposed decoding objective on existing machine translation benchmarks. This is a valid concern, as the characteristics of synthetic data may not fully capture the complexities of real-world language translation.
Furthermore, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the potential limitations or drawbacks of the proposed decoding objective. For example, it would be useful to understand how the approach might perform in scenarios where the source and target languages have significantly different structures or characteristics, or how it might interact with other machine translation techniques, such as context-aware machine translation or large language models.
Overall, the paper presents a promising step towards addressing the under-translation problem in machine translation. By focusing on the decoding objective, the authors have introduced a novel approach that has the potential to improve the completeness and quality of generated translations. However, further research and evaluation on real-world data are needed to fully assess the practical implications and limitations of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper explores a new approach to addressing the under-translation problem in machine translation, where the generated translations are shorter than the reference translations. The authors propose a modified decoding objective that incorporates a "translation completeness" term, aimed at encouraging the model to generate more complete and comprehensive translations.
Through experiments on synthetic data, the researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their proposed decoding objective in reducing the under-translation issue. By shifting the model's focus from simply maximizing the likelihood of the next token to also considering the overall completeness of the translation, the authors have shown the potential to generate translations that are more aligned with the reference translations.
While the results on synthetic data are promising, the authors acknowledge the need to further evaluate their approach on real-world machine translation tasks. Exploring the performance and limitations of the proposed decoding objective in more realistic scenarios, as well as its interactions with other machine translation techniques, will be important areas for future research.
Overall, this paper contributes a novel perspective and a promising approach to addressing the under-translation problem in machine translation, paving the way for further advancements in the field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Understanding and Addressing the Under-Translation Problem from the Perspective of Decoding Objective
Chenze Shao, Fandong Meng, Jiali Zeng, Jie Zhou
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) has made remarkable progress over the past years. However, under-translation and over-translation remain two challenging problems in state-of-the-art NMT systems. In this work, we conduct an in-depth analysis on the underlying cause of under-translation in NMT, providing an explanation from the perspective of decoding objective. To optimize the beam search objective, the model tends to overlook words it is less confident about, leading to the under-translation phenomenon. Correspondingly, the model's confidence in predicting the End Of Sentence (EOS) diminishes when under-translation occurs, serving as a mild penalty for under-translated candidates. Building upon this analysis, we propose employing the confidence of predicting EOS as a detector for under-translation, and strengthening the confidence-based penalty to penalize candidates with a high risk of under-translation. Experiments on both synthetic and real-world data show that our method can accurately detect and rectify under-translated outputs, with minor impact on other correct translations.
Read more5/30/2024
👀
0
Anti-LM Decoding for Zero-shot In-context Machine Translation
Suzanna Sia, Alexandra DeLucia, Kevin Duh
Zero-shot In-context learning is the phenomenon where models can perform the task simply given the instructions. However, pre-trained large language models are known to be poorly calibrated for this task. One of the most effective approaches to handling this bias is to adopt a contrastive decoding objective, which accounts for the prior probability of generating the next token by conditioning on some context. This work introduces an Anti-Language Model objective with a decay factor designed to address the weaknesses of In-context Machine Translation. We conduct our experiments across 3 model types and sizes, 3 language directions, and for both greedy decoding and beam search ($B=5$). The proposed method outperforms other state-of-art decoding objectives, with up to $20$ BLEU point improvement from the default objective observed in some settings.
Read more4/4/2024
💬
0
Improving Machine Translation with Large Language Models: A Preliminary Study with Cooperative Decoding
Jiali Zeng, Fandong Meng, Yongjing Yin, Jie Zhou
Contemporary translation engines based on the encoder-decoder framework have made significant strides in development. However, the emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has disrupted their position by presenting the potential for achieving superior translation quality. To uncover the circumstances in which LLMs excel and explore how their strengths can be harnessed to enhance translation quality, we first conduct a comprehensive analysis to assess the strengths and limitations of various commercial NMT systems and MT-oriented LLMs. Our findings indicate that neither NMT nor MT-oriented LLMs alone can effectively address all the translation issues, but MT-oriented LLMs show promise as a complementary solution to NMT systems. Building upon these insights, we propose Cooperative Decoding (CoDec), which treats NMT systems as a pretranslation model and MT-oriented LLMs as a supplemental solution to handle complex scenarios beyond the capability of NMT alone. Experimental results on the WMT22 test sets and a newly collected test set WebCrawl demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of CoDec, highlighting its potential as a robust solution for combining NMT systems with MT-oriented LLMs in the field of machine translation.
Read more5/28/2024
🛸
0
Quality-Aware Translation Models: Efficient Generation and Quality Estimation in a Single Model
Christian Tomani, David Vilar, Markus Freitag, Colin Cherry, Subhajit Naskar, Mara Finkelstein, Xavier Garcia, Daniel Cremers
Maximum-a-posteriori (MAP) decoding is the most widely used decoding strategy for neural machine translation (NMT) models. The underlying assumption is that model probability correlates well with human judgment, with better translations getting assigned a higher score by the model. However, research has shown that this assumption does not always hold, and generation quality can be improved by decoding to optimize a utility function backed by a metric or quality-estimation signal, as is done by Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) or quality-aware decoding. The main disadvantage of these approaches is that they require an additional model to calculate the utility function during decoding, significantly increasing the computational cost. In this paper, we propose to make the NMT models themselves quality-aware by training them to estimate the quality of their own output. Using this approach for MBR decoding we can drastically reduce the size of the candidate list, resulting in a speed-up of two-orders of magnitude. When applying our method to MAP decoding we obtain quality gains similar or even superior to quality reranking approaches, but with the efficiency of single pass decoding.
Read more7/12/2024