Understanding Hallucinations in Diffusion Models through Mode Interpolation
2
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the issue of "hallucinations" in diffusion models, which are a type of machine learning model used to generate images.
- Hallucinations refer to the model generating content that does not align with the input data, such as creating objects or details that are not present in the original image.
- The researchers investigate this phenomenon through a technique called "mode interpolation", which allows them to better understand how diffusion models behave and the factors that contribute to hallucinations.
Plain English Explanation
Diffusion models are a powerful type of AI that can create new images from scratch. However, sometimes these models can generate content that doesn't quite match the original image - this is what's known as "hallucination." The researchers in this paper looked into hallucinations in diffusion models using a technique called "mode interpolation."
Mode interpolation allows the researchers to explore how diffusion models work under the hood and what factors might lead to hallucinations. By understanding this better, they hope to find ways to reduce or eliminate hallucinations in the future. This is an important issue because we want AI-generated images to be accurate and truthful representations, not something that's been "made up" by the model.
The paper dives into the technical details of how diffusion models and mode interpolation work, but the key takeaway is that the researchers are trying to shine a light on this hallucination problem in order to improve the reliability and trustworthiness of AI-generated images going forward. Looks too good to be true: Information
Technical Explanation
The researchers use a technique called "mode interpolation" to better understand hallucinations in diffusion models. Diffusion models work by adding noise to an image in a stepwise fashion, then learning to reverse that process to generate new images. However, this can sometimes lead to the model "hallucinating" content that isn't present in the original data.
Mode interpolation allows the researchers to visualize the different modes, or "subimages", that the diffusion model is learning. By interpolating between these modes, they can see how the model transitions between different types of content and where hallucinations might occur. Tackling Structural Hallucination in Image Translation with Local Diffusion
The paper provides detailed experiments and analysis of how mode interpolation reveals insights about hallucinations in diffusion models. For example, they find that hallucinations are more likely to occur when the model has to "bridge the gap" between different modes or types of content in the training data.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations in their work. For one, mode interpolation only provides a partial view into the inner workings of diffusion models - there may be other factors beyond just the modes that contribute to hallucinations. Hallucination in Multimodal Large Language Models: A Survey
Additionally, the experiments are conducted on a relatively simple image generation task, so it's unclear how well the insights would translate to more complex, real-world applications of diffusion models. Further research would be needed to validate the findings at scale.
That said, the mode interpolation technique does seem like a promising avenue for better understanding and potentially mitigating hallucinations in these types of generative models. The researchers outline some directions for future work, such as investigating the role of model architecture and training data in hallucination behavior. Alleviating Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models Through Prompting
Conclusion
This paper takes an important step towards unpacking the issue of hallucinations in diffusion models, a critical problem as these generative AI systems become more widely adopted. By leveraging mode interpolation, the researchers gain valuable insights into the inner workings of diffusion models and the factors that can lead to the generation of content that doesn't align with the input data.
While more research is needed, this work lays the groundwork for developing strategies to reduce or eliminate hallucinations, which will be crucial for ensuring the reliability and trustworthiness of AI-generated imagery. Prescribing the Right Remedy: Mitigating Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models As diffusion models and other generative AI continue to advance, addressing the challenge of hallucinations will only become more important for the field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
2
Understanding Hallucinations in Diffusion Models through Mode Interpolation
Sumukh K Aithal, Pratyush Maini, Zachary C. Lipton, J. Zico Kolter
Colloquially speaking, image generation models based upon diffusion processes are frequently said to exhibit hallucinations, samples that could never occur in the training data. But where do such hallucinations come from? In this paper, we study a particular failure mode in diffusion models, which we term mode interpolation. Specifically, we find that diffusion models smoothly interpolate between nearby data modes in the training set, to generate samples that are completely outside the support of the original training distribution; this phenomenon leads diffusion models to generate artifacts that never existed in real data (i.e., hallucinations). We systematically study the reasons for, and the manifestation of this phenomenon. Through experiments on 1D and 2D Gaussians, we show how a discontinuous loss landscape in the diffusion model's decoder leads to a region where any smooth approximation will cause such hallucinations. Through experiments on artificial datasets with various shapes, we show how hallucination leads to the generation of combinations of shapes that never existed. Finally, we show that diffusion models in fact know when they go out of support and hallucinate. This is captured by the high variance in the trajectory of the generated sample towards the final few backward sampling process. Using a simple metric to capture this variance, we can remove over 95% of hallucinations at generation time while retaining 96% of in-support samples. We conclude our exploration by showing the implications of such hallucination (and its removal) on the collapse (and stabilization) of recursive training on synthetic data with experiments on MNIST and 2D Gaussians dataset. We release our code at https://github.com/locuslab/diffusion-model-hallucination.
Read more8/27/2024
0
Tackling Structural Hallucination in Image Translation with Local Diffusion
Seunghoi Kim, Chen Jin, Tom Diethe, Matteo Figini, Henry F. J. Tregidgo, Asher Mullokandov, Philip Teare, Daniel C. Alexander
Recent developments in diffusion models have advanced conditioned image generation, yet they struggle with reconstructing out-of-distribution (OOD) images, such as unseen tumors in medical images, causing image hallucination and risking misdiagnosis. We hypothesize such hallucinations result from local OOD regions in the conditional images. We verify that partitioning the OOD region and conducting separate image generations alleviates hallucinations in several applications. From this, we propose a training-free diffusion framework that reduces hallucination with multiple Local Diffusion processes. Our approach involves OOD estimation followed by two modules: a branching module generates locally both within and outside OOD regions, and a fusion module integrates these predictions into one. Our evaluation shows our method mitigates hallucination over baseline models quantitatively and qualitatively, reducing misdiagnosis by 40% and 25% in the real-world medical and natural image datasets, respectively. It also demonstrates compatibility with various pre-trained diffusion models.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Hallucination Index: An Image Quality Metric for Generative Reconstruction Models
Matthew Tivnan, Siyeop Yoon, Zhennong Chen, Xiang Li, Dufan Wu, Quanzheng Li
Generative image reconstruction algorithms such as measurement conditioned diffusion models are increasingly popular in the field of medical imaging. These powerful models can transform low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) inputs into outputs with the appearance of high SNR. However, the outputs can have a new type of error called hallucinations. In medical imaging, these hallucinations may not be obvious to a Radiologist but could cause diagnostic errors. Generally, hallucination refers to error in estimation of object structure caused by a machine learning model, but there is no widely accepted method to evaluate hallucination magnitude. In this work, we propose a new image quality metric called the hallucination index. Our approach is to compute the Hellinger distance from the distribution of reconstructed images to a zero hallucination reference distribution. To evaluate our approach, we conducted a numerical experiment with electron microscopy images, simulated noisy measurements, and applied diffusion based reconstructions. We sampled the measurements and the generative reconstructions repeatedly to compute the sample mean and covariance. For the zero hallucination reference, we used the forward diffusion process applied to ground truth. Our results show that higher measurement SNR leads to lower hallucination index for the same apparent image quality. We also evaluated the impact of early stopping in the reverse diffusion process and found that more modest denoising strengths can reduce hallucination. We believe this metric could be useful for evaluation of generative image reconstructions or as a warning label to inform radiologists about the degree of hallucinations in medical images.
Read more7/18/2024
1
On Early Detection of Hallucinations in Factual Question Answering
Ben Snyder, Marius Moisescu, Muhammad Bilal Zafar
While large language models (LLMs) have taken great strides towards helping humans with a plethora of tasks, hallucinations remain a major impediment towards gaining user trust. The fluency and coherence of model generations even when hallucinating makes detection a difficult task. In this work, we explore if the artifacts associated with the model generations can provide hints that the generation will contain hallucinations. Specifically, we probe LLMs at 1) the inputs via Integrated Gradients based token attribution, 2) the outputs via the Softmax probabilities, and 3) the internal state via self-attention and fully-connected layer activations for signs of hallucinations on open-ended question answering tasks. Our results show that the distributions of these artifacts tend to differ between hallucinated and non-hallucinated generations. Building on this insight, we train binary classifiers that use these artifacts as input features to classify model generations into hallucinations and non-hallucinations. These hallucination classifiers achieve up to $0.80$ AUROC. We also show that tokens preceding a hallucination can already predict the subsequent hallucination even before it occurs.
Read more8/23/2024