VisRuler: Visual Analytics for Extracting Decision Rules from Bagged and Boosted Decision Trees
2112.00334
0
0
🤿
Abstract
Bagging and boosting are two popular ensemble methods in machine learning (ML) that produce many individual decision trees. Due to the inherent ensemble characteristic of these methods, they typically outperform single decision trees or other ML models in predictive performance. However, numerous decision paths are generated for each decision tree, increasing the overall complexity of the model and hindering its use in domains that require trustworthy and explainable decisions, such as finance, social care, and health care. Thus, the interpretability of bagging and boosting algorithms, such as random forest and adaptive boosting, reduces as the number of decisions rises. In this paper, we propose a visual analytics tool that aims to assist users in extracting decisions from such ML models via a thorough visual inspection workflow that includes selecting a set of robust and diverse models (originating from different ensemble learning algorithms), choosing important features according to their global contribution, and deciding which decisions are essential for global explanation (or locally, for specific cases). The outcome is a final decision based on the class agreement of several models and the explored manual decisions exported by users. We evaluated the applicability and effectiveness of VisRuler via a use case, a usage scenario, and a user study. The evaluation revealed that most users managed to successfully use our system to explore decision rules visually, performing the proposed tasks and answering the given questions in a satisfying way.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Bagging and boosting are ensemble methods in machine learning that combine multiple decision trees to improve predictive performance.
- However, the increased complexity of these models can make them less interpretable, which is important for applications like finance, social care, and healthcare.
- This paper proposes a visual analytics tool to help users understand the decisions made by ensemble models like random forest and AdaBoost.
Plain English Explanation
Ensemble methods in machine learning, such as bagging and boosting, work by combining multiple decision trees to make predictions. These methods typically outperform single decision trees or other machine learning models because the combined decisions of many trees are more accurate.
However, the large number of decision paths generated by these ensemble models can make them complex and difficult to understand. This is a problem for applications that require trustworthy and explainable decisions, like in finance, social care, and healthcare.
To address this, the researchers developed a visual analytics tool that helps users explore and understand the decisions made by ensemble models. The tool allows users to select a set of robust and diverse models, identify the most important features, and explore the key decisions driving the model's predictions.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a visual analytics tool that assists users in extracting and understanding the decisions made by ensemble machine learning models, such as random forest and AdaBoost.
The tool allows users to:
- Select a set of robust and diverse ensemble models
- Identify the most important features for the model's decisions
- Explore the key decisions that are essential for global or local explanation of the model's predictions
The researchers evaluated the tool through a use case, a usage scenario, and a user study. The evaluation showed that most users were able to successfully use the system to visually explore the decision rules of the ensemble models and answer questions about the models' behavior.
Critical Analysis
The paper addresses an important challenge in the use of ensemble machine learning models, which is the inherent trade-off between predictive performance and model interpretability. The proposed visual analytics tool provides a promising approach to help users understand the complex decisions made by these models, which is crucial for applications where transparency and explainability are essential.
However, the paper does not provide a detailed discussion of the limitations of the tool or the potential issues that may arise in its practical application. For example, the tool's performance and scalability when dealing with large and high-dimensional datasets, or the potential biases that may be introduced in the model selection and feature importance analysis, are not addressed.
Additionally, the paper could have provided a more critical analysis of the evaluation methodology and the potential biases or limitations of the user study. It would be valuable to understand the extent to which the tool's effectiveness depends on the users' prior knowledge and experience in machine learning and data analysis.
Conclusion
This paper presents a visual analytics tool that aims to improve the interpretability of ensemble machine learning models, such as random forest and AdaBoost. By allowing users to explore the key decisions driving the model's predictions, the tool can help address the challenge of balancing predictive performance and model explainability, which is crucial for applications in domains like finance, social care, and healthcare.
While the paper demonstrates the tool's effectiveness through user evaluations, further research is needed to address the potential limitations and explore its applicability in real-world scenarios. Nonetheless, the proposed approach represents a significant step towards improving the transparency and trustworthiness of complex machine learning models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
DeforestVis: Behavior Analysis of Machine Learning Models with Surrogate Decision Stumps
Angelos Chatzimparmpas, Rafael M. Martins, Alexandru C. Telea, Andreas Kerren
0
0
As the complexity of machine learning (ML) models increases and their application in different (and critical) domains grows, there is a strong demand for more interpretable and trustworthy ML. A direct, model-agnostic, way to interpret such models is to train surrogate models-such as rule sets and decision trees-that sufficiently approximate the original ones while being simpler and easier-to-explain. Yet, rule sets can become very lengthy, with many if-else statements, and decision tree depth grows rapidly when accurately emulating complex ML models. In such cases, both approaches can fail to meet their core goal-providing users with model interpretability. To tackle this, we propose DeforestVis, a visual analytics tool that offers summarization of the behaviour of complex ML models by providing surrogate decision stumps (one-level decision trees) generated with the Adaptive Boosting (AdaBoost) technique. DeforestVis helps users to explore the complexity versus fidelity trade-off by incrementally generating more stumps, creating attribute-based explanations with weighted stumps to justify decision making, and analysing the impact of rule overriding on training instance allocation between one or more stumps. An independent test set allows users to monitor the effectiveness of manual rule changes and form hypotheses based on case-by-case analyses. We show the applicability and usefulness of DeforestVis with two use cases and expert interviews with data analysts and model developers.
4/19/2024
New!A Unified Approach to Extract Intepretable Rules from Tree Ensembles via Integer Programming
Lorenzo Bonasera, Emilio Carrizosa
0
0
Tree ensemble methods represent a popular machine learning model, known for their effectiveness in supervised classification and regression tasks. Their performance derives from aggregating predictions of multiple decision trees, which are renowned for their interpretability properties. However, tree ensemble methods do not reliably exhibit interpretable output. Our work aims to extract an optimized list of rules from a trained tree ensemble, providing the user with a condensed, interpretable model that retains most of the predictive power of the full model. Our approach consists of solving a clean and neat set partitioning problem formulated through Integer Programming. The proposed method works with either tabular or time series data, for both classification and regression tasks, and does not require parameter tuning under the most common setting. Through rigorous computational experiments, we offer statistically significant evidence that our method is competitive with other rule extraction methods and effectively handles time series.
7/2/2024
Fiper: a Visual-based Explanation Combining Rules and Feature Importance
Eleonora Cappuccio, Daniele Fadda, Rosa Lanzilotti, Salvatore Rinzivillo
0
0
Artificial Intelligence algorithms have now become pervasive in multiple high-stakes domains. However, their internal logic can be obscure to humans. Explainable Artificial Intelligence aims to design tools and techniques to illustrate the predictions of the so-called black-box algorithms. The Human-Computer Interaction community has long stressed the need for a more user-centered approach to Explainable AI. This approach can benefit from research in user interface, user experience, and visual analytics. This paper proposes a visual-based method to illustrate rules paired with feature importance. A user study with 15 participants was conducted comparing our visual method with the original output of the algorithm and textual representation to test its effectiveness with users.
4/29/2024
DimVis: Interpreting Visual Clusters in Dimensionality Reduction With Explainable Boosting Machine
Parisa Salmanian, Angelos Chatzimparmpas, Ali Can Karaca, Rafael M. Martins
0
0
Dimensionality Reduction (DR) techniques such as t-SNE and UMAP are popular for transforming complex datasets into simpler visual representations. However, while effective in uncovering general dataset patterns, these methods may introduce artifacts and suffer from interpretability issues. This paper presents DimVis, a visualization tool that employs supervised Explainable Boosting Machine (EBM) models (trained on user-selected data of interest) as an interpretation assistant for DR projections. Our tool facilitates high-dimensional data analysis by providing an interpretation of feature relevance in visual clusters through interactive exploration of UMAP projections. Specifically, DimVis uses a contrastive EBM model that is trained in real time to differentiate between the data inside and outside a cluster of interest. Taking advantage of the inherent explainable nature of the EBM, we then use this model to interpret the cluster itself via single and pairwise feature comparisons in a ranking based on the EBM model's feature importance. The applicability and effectiveness of DimVis are demonstrated via a use case and a usage scenario with real-world data. We also discuss the limitations and potential directions for future research.
4/19/2024