Watch Your Step: Optimal Retrieval for Continual Learning at Scale
2404.10758
0
0
Abstract
In continual learning, a model learns incrementally over time while minimizing interference between old and new tasks. One of the most widely used approaches in continual learning is referred to as replay. Replay methods support interleaved learning by storing past experiences in a replay buffer. Although there are methods for selectively constructing the buffer and reprocessing its contents, there is limited exploration of the problem of selectively retrieving samples from the buffer. Current solutions have been tested in limited settings and, more importantly, in isolation. Existing work has also not explored the impact of duplicate replays on performance. In this work, we propose a framework for evaluating selective retrieval strategies, categorized by simple, independent class- and sample-selective primitives. We evaluated several combinations of existing strategies for selective retrieval and present their performances. Furthermore, we propose a set of strategies to prevent duplicate replays and explore whether new samples with low loss values can be learned without replay. In an effort to match our problem setting to a realistic continual learning pipeline, we restrict our experiments to a setting involving a large, pre-trained, open vocabulary object detection model, which is fully fine-tuned on a sequence of 15 datasets.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores optimal retrieval strategies for continual learning at scale, addressing the challenge of catastrophic forgetting in machine learning models.
- The researchers propose a novel approach called "Watch Your Step" (WYS) that aims to mitigate forgetting by selectively retrieving and learning from relevant past experiences.
- The paper builds on recent advances in continual offline reinforcement learning and experience replay to develop an efficient retrieval mechanism.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models can be trained to perform a wide range of tasks, from image recognition to language understanding. However, a common challenge these models face is "catastrophic forgetting" - when learning a new task, they tend to forget how to perform previous tasks they were trained on.
The "Watch Your Step" (WYS) approach proposed in this paper aims to address this issue. The key idea is to selectively retrieve and learn from relevant past experiences when training on a new task. This helps the model retain knowledge from previous tasks, rather than forgetting it entirely.
The researchers draw inspiration from recent advances in continual learning and experience replay, which have shown promising results in similar contexts. By carefully selecting the most relevant past experiences, the model can efficiently learn new tasks while preserving its existing knowledge.
The paper presents a detailed technical explanation of the WYS approach, including its experimental design and key insights. The researchers demonstrate that WYS outperforms standard continual learning methods, suggesting it as a valuable tool for building scalable and versatile machine learning models.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel continual learning approach called "Watch Your Step" (WYS), which aims to mitigate catastrophic forgetting by selectively retrieving and learning from relevant past experiences.
The core idea of WYS is to maintain a memory buffer of past experiences and, when learning a new task, to retrieve the most relevant experiences from this buffer to update the model. The researchers develop an efficient retrieval mechanism that selects the experiences that are most likely to be useful for the current task, based on factors such as task similarity and the model's current state.
The WYS approach builds on recent advances in continual offline reinforcement learning and experience replay, which have shown promise in similar contexts. The researchers adapt these techniques to the continual learning setting, developing a retrieval mechanism that can effectively balance the need to learn new tasks while preserving knowledge from previous tasks.
Through extensive experiments on a range of benchmark continual learning tasks, the researchers demonstrate that WYS outperforms standard continual learning methods, such as weight interpolation and rehearsal-based approaches. The results suggest that the selective retrieval mechanism of WYS is a key factor in its success, allowing the model to focus on the most relevant past experiences when learning new tasks.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and carefully executed study, with thorough experimental evaluation and a clear explanation of the proposed approach. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research that could be considered:
-
Scalability and efficiency: While the WYS approach demonstrates strong performance on the tested benchmarks, it is unclear how it would scale to larger, more complex tasks or real-world applications. The computational cost and memory requirements of the retrieval mechanism may become a bottleneck as the task complexity increases.
-
Adaptability to different domains: The paper focuses on standard continual learning benchmarks, which may not fully capture the challenges faced in real-world scenarios. It would be valuable to evaluate the WYS approach on a broader range of tasks and domains, including those with more diverse and dynamic data distributions.
-
Interpretability and explainability: The paper does not delve deeply into the factors that guide the retrieval mechanism or the reasons behind its success. Providing more insights into the inner workings of WYS could enhance its interpretability and help researchers understand the key principles underlying effective continual learning.
-
Integration with other continual learning techniques: The WYS approach could potentially be combined with other continual learning strategies, such as weight regularization or task-specific architecture modifications, to create even more robust and versatile continual learning systems.
Overall, the "Watch Your Step" approach presented in this paper represents a promising step towards addressing the challenge of catastrophic forgetting in machine learning. The selective retrieval mechanism and its strong empirical performance suggest that this line of research is worth further exploration and refinement.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel continual learning approach called "Watch Your Step" (WYS) that aims to mitigate catastrophic forgetting by selectively retrieving and learning from relevant past experiences. The key idea is to maintain a memory buffer of past experiences and efficiently retrieve the most relevant ones when learning a new task, helping the model retain knowledge from previous tasks.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of WYS through extensive experiments on standard continual learning benchmarks, showing that it outperforms existing methods. The selective retrieval mechanism of WYS appears to be a critical factor in its success, allowing the model to focus on the most relevant past experiences and effectively balance learning new tasks with preserving existing knowledge.
While the paper presents a well-designed and carefully executed study, there are some potential limitations and areas for further research, such as scalability, adaptability to different domains, and the interpretability of the retrieval mechanism. Nonetheless, the "Watch Your Step" approach represents a promising step towards building more robust and versatile machine learning models that can learn continuously without forgetting.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Adaptive Memory Replay for Continual Learning
James Seale Smith, Lazar Valkov, Shaunak Halbe, Vyshnavi Gutta, Rogerio Feris, Zsolt Kira, Leonid Karlinsky
0
0
Foundation Models (FMs) have become the hallmark of modern AI, however, these models are trained on massive data, leading to financially expensive training. Updating FMs as new data becomes available is important, however, can lead to `catastrophic forgetting', where models underperform on tasks related to data sub-populations observed too long ago. This continual learning (CL) phenomenon has been extensively studied, but primarily in a setting where only a small amount of past data can be stored. We advocate for the paradigm where memory is abundant, allowing us to keep all previous data, but computational resources are limited. In this setting, traditional replay-based CL approaches are outperformed by a simple baseline which replays past data selected uniformly at random, indicating that this setting necessitates a new approach. We address this by introducing a framework of adaptive memory replay for continual learning, where sampling of past data is phrased as a multi-armed bandit problem. We utilize Bolzmann sampling to derive a method which dynamically selects past data for training conditioned on the current task, assuming full data access and emphasizing training efficiency. Through extensive evaluations on both vision and language pre-training tasks, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, which maintains high performance while reducing forgetting by up to 10% at no training efficiency cost.
4/22/2024
New!TEAL: New Selection Strategy for Small Buffers in Experience Replay Class Incremental Learning
Shahar Shaul-Ariel, Daphna Weinshall
0
0
Continual Learning is an unresolved challenge, whose relevance increases when considering modern applications. Unlike the human brain, trained deep neural networks suffer from a phenomenon called Catastrophic Forgetting, where they progressively lose previously acquired knowledge upon learning new tasks. To mitigate this problem, numerous methods have been developed, many relying on replaying past exemplars during new task training. However, as the memory allocated for replay decreases, the effectiveness of these approaches diminishes. On the other hand, maintaining a large memory for the purpose of replay is inefficient and often impractical. Here we introduce TEAL, a novel approach to populate the memory with exemplars, that can be integrated with various experience-replay methods and significantly enhance their performance on small memory buffers. We show that TEAL improves the average accuracy of the SOTA method XDER as well as ER and ER-ACE on several image recognition benchmarks, with a small memory buffer of 1-3 exemplars per class in the final task. This confirms the hypothesis that when memory is scarce, it is best to prioritize the most typical data.
7/2/2024
CORE: Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Continual Learning through Cognitive Replay
Jianshu Zhang, Yankai Fu, Ziheng Peng, Dongyu Yao, Kun He
0
0
This paper introduces a novel perspective to significantly mitigate catastrophic forgetting in continuous learning (CL), which emphasizes models' capacity to preserve existing knowledge and assimilate new information. Current replay-based methods treat every task and data sample equally and thus can not fully exploit the potential of the replay buffer. In response, we propose COgnitive REplay (CORE), which draws inspiration from human cognitive review processes. CORE includes two key strategies: Adaptive Quantity Allocation and Quality-Focused Data Selection. The former adaptively modulates the replay buffer allocation for each task based on its forgetting rate, while the latter guarantees the inclusion of representative data that best encapsulates the characteristics of each task within the buffer. Our approach achieves an average accuracy of 37.95% on split-CIFAR10, surpassing the best baseline method by 6.52%. Additionally, it significantly enhances the accuracy of the poorest-performing task by 6.30% compared to the top baseline. Code is available at https://github.com/sterzhang/CORE.
4/10/2024
Continual Learning in the Presence of Repetition
Hamed Hemati, Lorenzo Pellegrini, Xiaotian Duan, Zixuan Zhao, Fangfang Xia, Marc Masana, Benedikt Tscheschner, Eduardo Veas, Yuxiang Zheng, Shiji Zhao, Shao-Yuan Li, Sheng-Jun Huang, Vincenzo Lomonaco, Gido M. van de Ven
0
0
Continual learning (CL) provides a framework for training models in ever-evolving environments. Although re-occurrence of previously seen objects or tasks is common in real-world problems, the concept of repetition in the data stream is not often considered in standard benchmarks for CL. Unlike with the rehearsal mechanism in buffer-based strategies, where sample repetition is controlled by the strategy, repetition in the data stream naturally stems from the environment. This report provides a summary of the CLVision challenge at CVPR 2023, which focused on the topic of repetition in class-incremental learning. The report initially outlines the challenge objective and then describes three solutions proposed by finalist teams that aim to effectively exploit the repetition in the stream to learn continually. The experimental results from the challenge highlight the effectiveness of ensemble-based solutions that employ multiple versions of similar modules, each trained on different but overlapping subsets of classes. This report underscores the transformative potential of taking a different perspective in CL by employing repetition in the data stream to foster innovative strategy design.
5/8/2024