Weakly Supervised Learning for Facial Behavior Analysis : A Review

Read original: arXiv:2101.09858 - Published 7/9/2024 by R. Gnana Praveen, Eric Granger, Patrick Cardinal

👨‍🏫

Overview

This paper explores the challenges of facial behavior analysis in real-world, "in-the-wild" conditions, as opposed to controlled laboratory settings.
The performance of deep learning methods for facial behavior analysis relies on large amounts of training data, which is difficult to obtain due to the need for extensive annotations by human experts.
The paper reviews weakly supervised learning (WSL) approaches that can address the challenge of limited annotated data for facial behavior analysis.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses the shift in facial behavior analysis from controlled lab settings to more challenging real-world or "in-the-wild" conditions. Deep learning models have shown superior performance in many real-world applications, but they require large amounts of training data with detailed annotations. However, getting these annotations is difficult and time-consuming, as it requires a lot of human effort and expertise in areas like facial expressions or action units.

Moreover, the labeling process can be subjective and prone to bias, especially when it comes to assessing the intensity of expressions or actions. To address this challenge, the paper reviews weakly supervised learning (WSL) approaches for facial behavior analysis. These methods can work with limited or imprecise annotations, which could make facial behavior analysis more accessible in real-life situations.

Technical Explanation

The paper first introduces the various types of weak annotations that can be used for facial behavior analysis, such as categorical labels (e.g., basic emotions) or dimensional labels (e.g., valence and arousal). It then systematically reviews the existing state-of-the-art WSL approaches for facial behavior analysis, providing a taxonomy and insights into their strengths and limitations.

The paper also summarizes the widely used datasets in this area and the performance of the reviewed WSL approaches, along with the evaluation principles used. Finally, the paper discusses the remaining challenges and opportunities for applying facial behavior analysis with weak labels in real-life scenarios, such as improving medical image-based cancer detection or [localizing pain in animal behavior analysis.

Critical Analysis

The paper highlights the importance of addressing the data annotation challenge in facial behavior analysis, as it can limit the real-world application of deep learning models. The review of WSL approaches is comprehensive and provides a solid foundation for researchers to explore this area further.

However, the paper does not provide a deeper critical analysis of the limitations of the existing WSL approaches, such as their potential convergence issues or their ability to adapt to different domains. Addressing these limitations could be crucial for developing more robust and practical facial behavior analysis systems.

Conclusion

This paper provides a valuable overview of the challenges and emerging solutions for facial behavior analysis in real-world conditions. The review of weakly supervised learning approaches offers a promising path forward, as it can reduce the burden of data annotation and make facial behavior analysis more accessible for a wider range of applications. Further research and development in this area could have significant implications for fields like healthcare, human-computer interaction, and behavioral analysis.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

👨‍🏫

Weakly Supervised Learning for Facial Behavior Analysis : A Review

R. Gnana Praveen, Eric Granger, Patrick Cardinal

In the recent years, there has been a shift in facial behavior analysis from the laboratory-controlled conditions to the challenging in-the-wild conditions due to the superior performance of deep learning based approaches for many real world applications.However, the performance of deep learning approaches relies on the amount of training data. One of the major problems with data acquisition is the requirement of annotations for large amount of training data. Labeling process of huge training data demands lot of human support with strong domain expertise for facial expressions or action units, which is difficult to obtain in real-time environments.Moreover, labeling process is highly vulnerable to ambiguity of expressions or action units, especially for intensities due to the bias induced by the domain experts. Therefore, there is an imperative need to address the problem of facial behavior analysis with weak annotations. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive review of weakly supervised learning (WSL) approaches for facial behavior analysis with both categorical as well as dimensional labels along with the challenges and potential research directions associated with it. First, we introduce various types of weak annotations in the context of facial behavior analysis and the corresponding challenges associated with it. We then systematically review the existing state-of-the-art approaches and provide a taxonomy of these approaches along with their insights and limitations. In addition, widely used data-sets in the reviewed literature and the performance of these approaches along with evaluation principles are summarized. Finally, we discuss the remaining challenges and opportunities along with the potential research directions in order to apply facial behavior analysis with weak labels in real life situations.

7/9/2024

👁️

Rethinking the Learning Paradigm for Facial Expression Recognition

Weijie Wang, Nicu Sebe, Bruno Lepri

Due to the subjective crowdsourcing annotations and the inherent inter-class similarity of facial expressions, the real-world Facial Expression Recognition (FER) datasets usually exhibit ambiguous annotation. To simplify the learning paradigm, most previous methods convert ambiguous annotation results into precise one-hot annotations and train FER models in an end-to-end supervised manner. In this paper, we rethink the existing training paradigm and propose that it is better to use weakly supervised strategies to train FER models with original ambiguous annotation.

9/4/2024

Consistency Based Weakly Self-Supervised Learning for Human Activity Recognition with Wearables

Taoran Sheng, Manfred Huber

While the widely available embedded sensors in smartphones and other wearable devices make it easier to obtain data of human activities, recognizing different types of human activities from sensor-based data remains a difficult research topic in ubiquitous computing. One reason for this is that most of the collected data is unlabeled. However, many current human activity recognition (HAR) systems are based on supervised methods, which heavily rely on the labels of the data. We describe a weakly self-supervised approach in this paper that consists of two stages: (1) In stage one, the model learns from the nature of human activities by projecting the data into an embedding space where similar activities are grouped together; (2) In stage two, the model is fine-tuned using similarity information in a few-shot learning fashion using the similarity information of the data. This allows downstream classification or clustering tasks to benefit from the embeddings. Experiments on three benchmark datasets demonstrate the framework's effectiveness and show that our approach can help the clustering algorithm achieve comparable performance in identifying and categorizing the underlying human activities as pure supervised techniques applied directly to a corresponding fully labeled data set.

8/15/2024

🤿

Animal Behavior Analysis Methods Using Deep Learning: A Survey

Edoardo Fazzari, Donato Romano, Fabrizio Falchi, Cesare Stefanini

Animal behavior serves as a reliable indicator of the adaptation of organisms to their environment and their overall well-being. Through rigorous observation of animal actions and interactions, researchers and observers can glean valuable insights into diverse facets of their lives, encompassing health, social dynamics, ecological relationships, and neuroethological dimensions. Although state-of-the-art deep learning models have demonstrated remarkable accuracy in classifying various forms of animal data, their adoption in animal behavior studies remains limited. This survey article endeavors to comprehensively explore deep learning architectures and strategies applied to the identification of animal behavior, spanning auditory, visual, and audiovisual methodologies. Furthermore, the manuscript scrutinizes extant animal behavior datasets, offering a detailed examination of the principal challenges confronting this research domain. The article culminates in a comprehensive discussion of key research directions within deep learning that hold potential for advancing the field of animal behavior studies.

5/24/2024