When Quantization Affects Confidence of Large Language Models?
2405.00632
0
0
Abstract
Recent studies introduced effective compression techniques for Large Language Models (LLMs) via post-training quantization or low-bit weight representation. Although quantized weights offer storage efficiency and allow for faster inference, existing works have indicated that quantization might compromise performance and exacerbate biases in LLMs. This study investigates the confidence and calibration of quantized models, considering factors such as language model type and scale as contributors to quantization loss. Firstly, we reveal that quantization with GPTQ to 4-bit results in a decrease in confidence regarding true labels, with varying impacts observed among different language models. Secondly, we observe fluctuations in the impact on confidence across different scales. Finally, we propose an explanation for quantization loss based on confidence levels, indicating that quantization disproportionately affects samples where the full model exhibited low confidence levels in the first place.
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- This paper investigates how quantization, a technique used to compress and accelerate large language models, can affect the confidence of these models in their predictions.
- Quantization involves reducing the number of bits used to represent the model's parameters, which can lead to a loss of precision but also faster inference times and smaller model sizes.
- The researchers explore the relationship between quantization and model confidence, which is an important factor in real-world applications where users need to understand the reliability of the model's outputs.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models, such as GPT-3 and BERT, have become incredibly powerful tools for a wide range of natural language processing tasks. However, these models can be computationally expensive and resource-intensive, making them difficult to deploy on mobile devices or other constrained hardware.
One way to address this issue is through quantization, which involves reducing the precision of the model's parameters by using fewer bits to represent them. This can lead to a significant reduction in the model's size and inference time, making it more efficient and accessible. However, quantization can also affect the confidence of the model's predictions, which is an important consideration in real-world applications where users need to understand how reliable the model's outputs are.
In this paper, the researchers explore the relationship between quantization and model confidence. They investigate the factors that can influence how quantization affects the model's confidence, such as the level of quantization, the specific task being performed, and the architecture of the model itself. By understanding these relationships, the researchers hope to develop better strategies for deploying large language models in a wide range of applications while maintaining the reliability and trustworthiness of the models' outputs.
Technical Explanation
The researchers in this paper investigate the impact of quantization on the confidence of large language models. Quantization is a technique used to reduce the precision of a model's parameters, which can lead to faster inference times and smaller model sizes, but may also affect the model's performance and confidence in its predictions.
The researchers conducted a series of experiments to explore the relationship between quantization and model confidence. They used several different quantization techniques, including post-training quantization and cross-block quantization, and evaluated the models on a range of natural language processing tasks, such as sentiment analysis and question answering.
The results of the experiments showed that the impact of quantization on model confidence can be complex and dependent on a variety of factors. In some cases, quantization had little effect on the model's confidence, while in others it led to a significant reduction in confidence, even when the model's overall performance remained relatively high.
The researchers also found that the specific architecture of the language model can play a role in how quantization affects confidence. For example, models with more attention layers may be more sensitive to quantization, as these layers can be more prone to numerical instability when quantized.
Critical Analysis
The researchers in this paper have made an important contribution to the understanding of how quantization can affect the confidence of large language models. By exploring the relationship between quantization and model confidence, they have highlighted the need to consider not just the performance of these models, but also their reliability and trustworthiness in real-world applications.
However, the paper does have some limitations. For example, the researchers only evaluated a limited set of quantization techniques and language model architectures, and it's possible that other approaches or models may behave differently. Additionally, the paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the factors that can influence the relationship between quantization and confidence, such as the specific task being performed or the characteristics of the input data.
Furthermore, the paper does not address the potential impact of quantization on the adversarial robustness of language models, which is an important consideration for the deployment of these models in security-critical applications.
Despite these limitations, the findings of this paper are still valuable and serve as an important starting point for further research in this area. By continuing to investigate the relationship between quantization and model confidence, researchers can develop better strategies for deploying large language models in a wide range of applications while ensuring that the outputs of these models are reliable and trustworthy.
Conclusion
This paper explores the complex relationship between quantization and the confidence of large language models. The researchers have found that the impact of quantization on model confidence can vary depending on factors such as the specific quantization technique used, the architecture of the language model, and the task being performed.
These findings have important implications for the deployment of large language models in real-world applications, where the reliability and trustworthiness of the model's outputs are crucial. By understanding how quantization can affect model confidence, researchers and practitioners can develop better strategies for optimizing these models for efficiency while maintaining their accuracy and reliability.
Overall, this paper represents an important contribution to the ongoing research on large language models and their deployment in practical applications. By continuing to explore the relationship between quantization and model confidence, the field can work towards developing more robust and trustworthy AI systems that can be safely deployed in a wide range of settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
On the Compressibility of Quantized Large Language Models
Yu Mao, Weilan Wang, Hongchao Du, Nan Guan, Chun Jason Xue
0
0
Deploying Large Language Models (LLMs) on edge or mobile devices offers significant benefits, such as enhanced data privacy and real-time processing capabilities. However, it also faces critical challenges due to the substantial memory requirement of LLMs. Quantization is an effective way of reducing the model size while maintaining good performance. However, even after quantization, LLMs may still be too big to fit entirely into the limited memory of edge or mobile devices and have to be partially loaded from the storage to complete the inference. In this case, the I/O latency of model loading becomes the bottleneck of the LLM inference latency. In this work, we take a preliminary step of studying applying data compression techniques to reduce data movement and thus speed up the inference of quantized LLM on memory-constrained devices. In particular, we discussed the compressibility of quantized LLMs, the trade-off between the compressibility and performance of quantized LLMs, and opportunities to optimize both of them jointly.
5/7/2024
🐍
Combining multiple post-training techniques to achieve most efficient quantized LLMs
Sayeh Sharify, Zifei Xu, Wanzin Yazar, Xin Wang
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have distinguished themselves with outstanding performance in complex language modeling tasks, yet they come with significant computational and storage challenges. This paper explores the potential of quantization to mitigate these challenges. We systematically study the combined application of two well-known post-training techniques, SmoothQuant and GPTQ, and provide a comprehensive analysis of their interactions and implications for advancing LLM quantization. We enhance the versatility of both techniques by enabling quantization to microscaling (MX) formats, expanding their applicability beyond their initial fixed-point format targets. We show that by applying GPTQ and SmoothQuant, and employing MX formats for quantizing models, we can achieve a significant reduction in the size of OPT models by up to 4x and LLaMA models by up to 3x with a negligible perplexity increase of 1-3%.
5/14/2024
LLM-QBench: A Benchmark Towards the Best Practice for Post-training Quantization of Large Language Models
Ruihao Gong, Yang Yong, Shiqiao Gu, Yushi Huang, Yunchen Zhang, Xianglong Liu, Dacheng Tao
0
0
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) are propelling us toward artificial general intelligence, thanks to their remarkable emergent abilities and reasoning capabilities. However, the substantial computational and memory requirements of LLMs limit their widespread adoption. Quan- tization, a key compression technique, offers a viable solution to mitigate these demands by compressing and accelerating LLMs, albeit with poten- tial risks to model accuracy. Numerous studies have aimed to minimize the accuracy loss associated with quantization. However, the quantization configurations in these studies vary and may not be optimized for hard- ware compatibility. In this paper, we focus on identifying the most effective practices for quantizing LLMs, with the goal of balancing performance with computational efficiency. For a fair analysis, we develop a quantization toolkit LLMC, and design four crucial principles considering the inference efficiency, quantized accuracy, calibration cost, and modularization. By benchmarking on various models and datasets with over 500 experiments, three takeaways corresponding to calibration data, quantization algorithm, and quantization schemes are derived. Finally, a best practice of LLM PTQ pipeline is constructed. All the benchmark results and the toolkit can be found at https://github.com/ModelTC/llmc.
5/13/2024
💬
QLLM: Accurate and Efficient Low-Bitwidth Quantization for Large Language Models
Jing Liu, Ruihao Gong, Xiuying Wei, Zhiwei Dong, Jianfei Cai, Bohan Zhuang
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in NLP, but their demands hinder their widespread deployment. While Quantization-Aware Training (QAT) offers a solution, its extensive training costs make Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) a more practical approach for LLMs. In existing studies, activation outliers in particular channels are identified as the bottleneck to PTQ accuracy. They propose to transform the magnitudes from activations to weights, which however offers limited alleviation or suffers from unstable gradients, resulting in a severe performance drop at low-bitwidth. In this paper, we propose QLLM, an accurate and efficient low-bitwidth PTQ method designed for LLMs. QLLM introduces an adaptive channel reassembly technique that reallocates the magnitude of outliers to other channels, thereby mitigating their impact on the quantization range. This is achieved by channel disassembly and channel assembly, which first breaks down the outlier channels into several sub-channels to ensure a more balanced distribution of activation magnitudes. Then similar channels are merged to maintain the original channel number for efficiency. Additionally, an adaptive strategy is designed to autonomously determine the optimal number of sub-channels for channel disassembly. To further compensate for the performance loss caused by quantization, we propose an efficient tuning method that only learns a small number of low-rank weights while freezing the pre-trained quantized model. After training, these low-rank parameters can be fused into the frozen weights without affecting inference. Extensive experiments on LLaMA-1 and LLaMA-2 show that QLLM can obtain accurate quantized models efficiently. For example, QLLM quantizes the 4-bit LLaMA-2-70B within 10 hours on a single A100-80G GPU, outperforming the previous state-of-the-art method by 7.89% on the average accuracy across five zero-shot tasks.
4/9/2024