Whole Page Unbiased Learning to Rank
0
🚀
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper discusses the challenge of "page presentation biases" in information retrieval systems, where the way search results are displayed can influence user click behavior and hinder the performance of ranking models.
- Existing Unbiased Learning to Rank (ULTR) algorithms are designed to mitigate position-related biases, but they do not consider other types of biases, such as those induced by multimedia content.
- The paper introduces a new problem called "whole-page Unbiased Learning to Rank (WP-ULTR)," which aims to handle biases induced by various features in the search engine results page (SERP) simultaneously.
- The key challenges are finding a suitable user behavior model and addressing complex biases that cannot be handled by existing algorithms.
Plain English Explanation
When people use search engines, the way the search results are displayed can influence their behavior and clicks. This is known as "page presentation biases," and it can make it harder for search engines to improve their ranking models based on user feedback.
Existing unbiased learning to rank algorithms have focused on addressing biases related to the position of search results, such as the "trust bias" where users are more likely to click on results higher up on the page. However, there are other types of biases, like the "attractive bias" where users may be more likely to click on results with multimedia content.
The researchers in this paper introduce a new problem called "whole-page Unbiased Learning to Rank (WP-ULTR)," which aims to address all the different types of biases that can be introduced by the way the search results are displayed. This is a challenging problem because it can be difficult to find a good model of how users actually behave, and the biases can be quite complex and varied.
To tackle this problem, the researchers propose a new algorithm called "Bias Agnostic whole-page unbiased Learning to rank (BAL)." This algorithm is designed to automatically find the best user behavior model using causal discovery techniques and then mitigate the various biases without needing to be specifically designed for each type of bias.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new problem called "whole-page Unbiased Learning to Rank (WP-ULTR)," which aims to address biases induced by various features in the search engine results page (SERP) simultaneously. This is in contrast to existing Unbiased Learning to Rank (ULTR) algorithms, which primarily focus on mitigating position-related biases, such as trust bias.
The key challenges in WP-ULTR are:
- Finding a suitable user behavior model (user behavior hypothesis) that can capture the complex biases induced by different SERP features.
- Developing algorithms that can effectively mitigate these complex biases, which cannot be handled by existing ULTR algorithms.
To address these challenges, the researchers propose a Bias Agnostic whole-page unbiased Learning to rank algorithm, named BAL. BAL automatically finds the user behavior model using causal discovery techniques and then mitigates the biases induced by multiple SERP features without any specific design. This is a departure from previous ULTR algorithms, which often required the user behavior model to be specified a priori.
The researchers evaluate the effectiveness of BAL on a real-world dataset and demonstrate its superiority over existing ULTR algorithms in terms of unbiased ranking performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents an important and timely problem, as biases in information retrieval systems can lead to unsatisfactory search experiences and reinforce societal biases. The introduction of the WP-ULTR problem is a valuable contribution, as it expands the scope of existing ULTR research to consider a wider range of biases beyond just position-related ones.
The proposed BAL algorithm is a promising approach, as its ability to automatically discover the user behavior model and mitigate complex biases without specific design is a significant advancement over prior ULTR methods. However, the paper does not provide a deep analysis of the limitations of BAL or the potential challenges that may arise in real-world deployment.
For example, the paper does not discuss the identifiability issues that can arise when trying to infer causal relationships from observational data, or the potential issues with indexical bias that may not be fully addressed by the proposed approach.
Additionally, the paper could benefit from a more thorough discussion of the implications of the WP-ULTR problem and the BAL algorithm, particularly in terms of their impact on user experience and the broader societal consequences of addressing biases in information retrieval systems.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new problem, whole-page Unbiased Learning to Rank (WP-ULTR), which aims to address biases induced by various features in the search engine results page (SERP) simultaneously. To tackle this challenge, the researchers propose the Bias Agnostic whole-page unbiased Learning to rank (BAL) algorithm, which can automatically discover the user behavior model and mitigate complex biases without specific design.
The work represents an important advancement in the field of unbiased learning to rank, as it expands the scope of existing research to consider a wider range of biases that can impact search engine performance and user experience. While the paper presents promising results, it also highlights the need for further research to address the potential limitations and broader implications of the WP-ULTR problem and the BAL algorithm.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🚀
0
Whole Page Unbiased Learning to Rank
Haitao Mao, Lixin Zou, Yujia Zheng, Jiliang Tang, Xiaokai Chu, Jiashu Zhao, Qian Wang, Dawei Yin
The page presentation biases in the information retrieval system, especially on the click behavior, is a well-known challenge that hinders improving ranking models' performance with implicit user feedback. Unbiased Learning to Rank~(ULTR) algorithms are then proposed to learn an unbiased ranking model with biased click data. However, most existing algorithms are specifically designed to mitigate position-related bias, e.g., trust bias, without considering biases induced by other features in search result page presentation(SERP), e.g. attractive bias induced by the multimedia. Unfortunately, those biases widely exist in industrial systems and may lead to an unsatisfactory search experience. Therefore, we introduce a new problem, i.e., whole-page Unbiased Learning to Rank(WP-ULTR), aiming to handle biases induced by whole-page SERP features simultaneously. It presents tremendous challenges: (1) a suitable user behavior model (user behavior hypothesis) can be hard to find; and (2) complex biases cannot be handled by existing algorithms. To address the above challenges, we propose a Bias Agnostic whole-page unbiased Learning to rank algorithm, named BAL, to automatically find the user behavior model with causal discovery and mitigate the biases induced by multiple SERP features with no specific design. Experimental results on a real-world dataset verify the effectiveness of the BAL.
Read more6/14/2024
0
Unbiased Learning to Rank Meets Reality: Lessons from Baidu's Large-Scale Search Dataset
Philipp Hager, Romain Deffayet, Jean-Michel Renders, Onno Zoeter, Maarten de Rijke
Unbiased learning-to-rank (ULTR) is a well-established framework for learning from user clicks, which are often biased by the ranker collecting the data. While theoretically justified and extensively tested in simulation, ULTR techniques lack empirical validation, especially on modern search engines. The Baidu-ULTR dataset released for the WSDM Cup 2023, collected from Baidu's search engine, offers a rare opportunity to assess the real-world performance of prominent ULTR techniques. Despite multiple submissions during the WSDM Cup 2023 and the subsequent NTCIR ULTRE-2 task, it remains unclear whether the observed improvements stem from applying ULTR or other learning techniques. In this work, we revisit and extend the available experiments on the Baidu-ULTR dataset. We find that standard unbiased learning-to-rank techniques robustly improve click predictions but struggle to consistently improve ranking performance, especially considering the stark differences obtained by choice of ranking loss and query-document features. Our experiments reveal that gains in click prediction do not necessarily translate to enhanced ranking performance on expert relevance annotations, implying that conclusions strongly depend on how success is measured in this benchmark.
Read more5/16/2024
0
Contextual Dual Learning Algorithm with Listwise Distillation for Unbiased Learning to Rank
Lulu Yu, Keping Bi, Shiyu Ni, Jiafeng Guo
Unbiased Learning to Rank (ULTR) aims to leverage biased implicit user feedback (e.g., click) to optimize an unbiased ranking model. The effectiveness of the existing ULTR methods has primarily been validated on synthetic datasets. However, their performance on real-world click data remains unclear. Recently, Baidu released a large publicly available dataset of their web search logs. Subsequently, the NTCIR-17 ULTRE-2 task released a subset dataset extracted from it. We conduct experiments on commonly used or effective ULTR methods on this subset to determine whether they maintain their effectiveness. In this paper, we propose a Contextual Dual Learning Algorithm with Listwise Distillation (CDLA-LD) to simultaneously address both position bias and contextual bias. We utilize a listwise-input ranking model to obtain reconstructed feature vectors incorporating local contextual information and employ the Dual Learning Algorithm (DLA) method to jointly train this ranking model and a propensity model to address position bias. As this ranking model learns the interaction information within the documents list of the training set, to enhance the ranking model's generalization ability, we additionally train a pointwise-input ranking model to learn the listwise-input ranking model's capability for relevance judgment in a listwise manner. Extensive experiments and analysis confirm the effectiveness of our approach.
Read more8/20/2024
🤖
0
Identifiability Matters: Revealing the Hidden Recoverable Condition in Unbiased Learning to Rank
Mouxiang Chen, Chenghao Liu, Zemin Liu, Zhuo Li, Jianling Sun
Unbiased Learning to Rank (ULTR) aims to train unbiased ranking models from biased click logs, by explicitly modeling a generation process for user behavior and fitting click data based on examination hypothesis. Previous research found empirically that the true latent relevance is mostly recoverable through click fitting. However, we demonstrate that this is not always achievable, resulting in a significant reduction in ranking performance. This research investigates the conditions under which relevance can be recovered from click data in the first principle. We initially characterize a ranking model as identifiable if it can recover the true relevance up to a scaling transformation, a criterion sufficient for the pairwise ranking objective. Subsequently, we investigate an equivalent condition for identifiability, articulated as a graph connectivity test problem: the recovery of relevance is feasible if and only if the identifiability graph (IG), derived from the underlying structure of the dataset, is connected. The presence of a disconnected IG may lead to degenerate cases and suboptimal ranking performance. To tackle this challenge, we introduce two methods, namely node intervention and node merging, designed to modify the dataset and restore the connectivity of the IG. Empirical results derived from a simulated dataset and two real-world LTR benchmark datasets not only validate our proposed theory but also demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods in alleviating data bias when the relevance model is unidentifiable.
Read more5/27/2024