Achieving interpretable machine learning by functional decomposition of black-box models into explainable predictor effects

Overview

• Machine learning (ML) models are increasingly being used in critical domains like medicine and finance.
• These ML models often have complex "black-box" architectures that are difficult to interpret.
• Interpretability is crucial in these domains to ensure user trust, fairness, and understanding of how decisions are made.
• This has driven research into the field of interpretable machine learning (IML), which aims to make ML models more transparent.

Plain English Explanation

The paper proposes a new approach for the functional decomposition of black-box predictions, which is considered a core concept of IML. The key idea is to replace the original complex prediction function with a simpler "surrogate" model made up of smaller, easier-to-understand subfunctions.

These subfunctions provide insights into the main feature contributions and their interactions, similar to how additive regression models work. The method ensures that the main effects capture as much of the model's behavior as possible without being influenced by higher-order interactions.

Unlike previous IML approaches, this method is not affected by issues like extrapolation or hidden feature interactions. The researchers propose an algorithm based on neural additive modeling and efficient post-hoc orthogonalization to compute the interpretable subfunctions.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a novel concept called "stacked orthogonality" to ensure the main effects in the surrogate model capture as much of the original model's behavior as possible without containing information explained by higher-order interactions.

The algorithm first trains a neural additive model to approximate the original black-box prediction function. It then performs an efficient post-hoc orthogonalization procedure to decompose the additive model into interpretable subfunctions.

Unlike prior functional IML methods, this approach is not affected by issues like extrapolation or hidden feature interactions that can undermine the interpretability of the results.

The paper includes experiments demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed method on several real-world datasets, showing that it can provide meaningful insights into the inner workings of complex ML models.

Critical Analysis

The paper acknowledges that while the proposed method addresses some key limitations of previous IML approaches, it still has certain caveats and areas for further research.

For example, the orthogonalization procedure can be computationally intensive for very high-dimensional models. Additionally, the paper notes that the method may not work as well for models with highly nonlinear or discontinuous prediction functions.

Further research could explore ways to make the orthogonalization more efficient or extend the approach to handle a wider range of model types and problem domains. Potential issues around the stability and robustness of the interpretable subfunctions could also be investigated.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel IML method that can provide detailed, interpretable insights into the workings of complex black-box ML models. By decomposing the prediction function into simpler, more transparent subfunctions, the approach addresses key limitations of prior IML techniques.

The ability to understand how ML models arrive at their predictions is crucial for building trust and ensuring fairness, especially in high-stakes domains. This research contributes to the growing field of IML and could have important implications for the wider adoption of ML in critical applications.