SUBPLEX: Towards a Better Understanding of Black Box Model Explanations at the Subpopulation Level
0
🤔
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper discusses the importance of interpreting machine learning (ML) models, especially when making decisions that impact society.
- Current model interpretation methodologies focus on using locally linear functions or creating self-explanatory models, but they lack the ability to provide explanations at the subpopulation level.
- To address this, the authors propose SUBPLEX, a visual analytics system that helps users understand black-box model explanations with subpopulation visual analysis.
- The system is designed to support three real-life ML task scenarios: model debugging, feature selection, and bias detection.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models are increasingly being used to make important decisions that affect people's lives, such as in transportation, finance, and healthcare. It's crucial to understand how these models arrive at their predictions, especially when there could be societal impact.
While current methods focus on explaining individual predictions or creating models that are self-explanatory, they don't provide insights into how the model behaves across different subgroups within the dataset. SUBPLEX aims to address this by allowing users to explore model explanations at a subpopulation level.
Imagine you're trying to understand a machine learning model that predicts the risk of someone defaulting on a loan. Using SUBPLEX, you could analyze how the model's explanations differ for different demographic groups, such as age or income level. This could help you identify potential biases in the model and make more informed decisions about how to use it.
The system provides interactive visualizations that let users drill down into the model's behavior across various subgroups in the data. This can lead to more insightful interpretations and help users find creative ways to improve the model's performance and fairness.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces SUBPLEX, a visual analytics system designed to help users understand the interpretations of black-box machine learning models at the subpopulation level. This means analyzing how the model's explanations vary across different subgroups or segments within the dataset.
The system is developed through an iterative design process with machine learning researchers to address three real-world use cases: model debugging, feature selection, and bias detection. SUBPLEX applies novel subpopulation analysis techniques on the model's explanations and presents the results through interactive visualizations.
For example, the system could show how the relative importance of different features in the model changes for different age groups or income levels. This can help users identify potential biases or areas where the model is performing well or poorly for certain subpopulations.
The authors also conduct user evaluations to assess how understanding model interpretations at the subpopulation level influences the sense-making process for users. Their results suggest that SUBPLEX encourages users to generate more creative ideas for improving model interpretations and helps them better integrate programming and visual analytics workflows.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to addressing a crucial gap in current model interpretation methodologies. By focusing on subpopulation-level analysis, SUBPLEX offers a more comprehensive understanding of how machine learning models behave, which is essential for making informed decisions with societal impact.
One potential limitation is the reliance on novel subpopulation analysis techniques, which may require additional validation and testing to ensure their robustness and reliability. The authors acknowledge this and suggest further research to refine and expand these methods.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific techniques used for subpopulation analysis or the underlying algorithms powering the interactive visualizations. A more detailed technical discussion of these components could help readers better understand the system's inner workings and potential areas for improvement.
That said, the user evaluation results are promising, suggesting that SUBPLEX can indeed enhance users' ability to make sense of machine learning model interpretations and generate more insightful ideas for improving them. The focus on real-world use cases also highlights the practical relevance of this work.
Conclusion
The SUBPLEX system represents a significant advance in the field of machine learning model interpretation. By providing a means to explore model explanations at the subpopulation level, it addresses a critical gap in current methodologies and enables more comprehensive and nuanced understanding of model behavior.
The iterative design process and user evaluation results suggest that SUBPLEX can empower users to identify biases, select relevant features, and debug models more effectively. This, in turn, can lead to more trustworthy and equitable deployment of machine learning systems in high-stakes domains.
As the field of machine learning continues to advance, tools like SUBPLEX will become increasingly crucial for ensuring the responsible and transparent use of these powerful technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤔
0
SUBPLEX: Towards a Better Understanding of Black Box Model Explanations at the Subpopulation Level
Jun Yuan, Gromit Yeuk-Yin Chan, Brian Barr, Kyle Overton, Kim Rees, Luis Gustavo Nonato, Enrico Bertini, Claudio T. Silva
Understanding the interpretation of machine learning (ML) models has been of paramount importance when making decisions with societal impacts such as transport control, financial activities, and medical diagnosis. While current model interpretation methodologies focus on using locally linear functions to approximate the models or creating self-explanatory models that give explanations to each input instance, they do not focus on model interpretation at the subpopulation level, which is the understanding of model interpretations across different subset aggregations in a dataset. To address the challenges of providing explanations of an ML model across the whole dataset, we propose SUBPLEX, a visual analytics system to help users understand black-box model explanations with subpopulation visual analysis. SUBPLEX is designed through an iterative design process with machine learning researchers to address three usage scenarios of real-life machine learning tasks: model debugging, feature selection, and bias detection. The system applies novel subpopulation analysis on ML model explanations and interactive visualization to explore the explanations on a dataset with different levels of granularity. Based on the system, we conduct user evaluation to assess how understanding the interpretation at a subpopulation level influences the sense-making process of interpreting ML models from a user's perspective. Our results suggest that by providing model explanations for different groups of data, SUBPLEX encourages users to generate more ingenious ideas to enrich the interpretations. It also helps users to acquire a tight integration between programming workflow and visual analytics workflow. Last but not least, we summarize the considerations observed in applying visualization to machine learning interpretations.
Read more5/7/2024
🚀
0
Achieving interpretable machine learning by functional decomposition of black-box models into explainable predictor effects
David Kohler (Institute for Medical Biometry, Informatics and Epidemiology, University of Bonn), David Rugamer (Department of Statistics, LMU Munich, Munich Center for Machine Learning), Matthias Schmid (Institute for Medical Biometry, Informatics and Epidemiology, University of Bonn)
Machine learning (ML) has seen significant growth in both popularity and importance. The high prediction accuracy of ML models is often achieved through complex black-box architectures that are difficult to interpret. This interpretability problem has been hindering the use of ML in fields like medicine, ecology and insurance, where an understanding of the inner workings of the model is paramount to ensure user acceptance and fairness. The need for interpretable ML models has boosted research in the field of interpretable machine learning (IML). Here we propose a novel approach for the functional decomposition of black-box predictions, which is considered a core concept of IML. The idea of our method is to replace the prediction function by a surrogate model consisting of simpler subfunctions. Similar to additive regression models, these functions provide insights into the direction and strength of the main feature contributions and their interactions. Our method is based on a novel concept termed stacked orthogonality, which ensures that the main effects capture as much functional behavior as possible and do not contain information explained by higher-order interactions. Unlike earlier functional IML approaches, it is neither affected by extrapolation nor by hidden feature interactions. To compute the subfunctions, we propose an algorithm based on neural additive modeling and an efficient post-hoc orthogonalization procedure.
Read more7/29/2024
🧠
0
Disentangled Explanations of Neural Network Predictions by Finding Relevant Subspaces
Pattarawat Chormai, Jan Herrmann, Klaus-Robert Muller, Gr'egoire Montavon
Explainable AI aims to overcome the black-box nature of complex ML models like neural networks by generating explanations for their predictions. Explanations often take the form of a heatmap identifying input features (e.g. pixels) that are relevant to the model's decision. These explanations, however, entangle the potentially multiple factors that enter into the overall complex decision strategy. We propose to disentangle explanations by extracting at some intermediate layer of a neural network, subspaces that capture the multiple and distinct activation patterns (e.g. visual concepts) that are relevant to the prediction. To automatically extract these subspaces, we propose two new analyses, extending principles found in PCA or ICA to explanations. These novel analyses, which we call principal relevant component analysis (PRCA) and disentangled relevant subspace analysis (DRSA), maximize relevance instead of e.g. variance or kurtosis. This allows for a much stronger focus of the analysis on what the ML model actually uses for predicting, ignoring activations or concepts to which the model is invariant. Our approach is general enough to work alongside common attribution techniques such as Shapley Value, Integrated Gradients, or LRP. Our proposed methods show to be practically useful and compare favorably to the state of the art as demonstrated on benchmarks and three use cases.
Read more4/16/2024
0
New!XSub: Explanation-Driven Adversarial Attack against Blackbox Classifiers via Feature Substitution
Kiana Vu, Phung Lai, Truc Nguyen
Despite its significant benefits in enhancing the transparency and trustworthiness of artificial intelligence (AI) systems, explainable AI (XAI) has yet to reach its full potential in real-world applications. One key challenge is that XAI can unintentionally provide adversaries with insights into black-box models, inevitably increasing their vulnerability to various attacks. In this paper, we develop a novel explanation-driven adversarial attack against black-box classifiers based on feature substitution, called XSub. The key idea of XSub is to strategically replace important features (identified via XAI) in the original sample with corresponding important features from a golden sample of a different label, thereby increasing the likelihood of the model misclassifying the perturbed sample. The degree of feature substitution is adjustable, allowing us to control how much of the original samples information is replaced. This flexibility effectively balances a trade-off between the attacks effectiveness and its stealthiness. XSub is also highly cost-effective in that the number of required queries to the prediction model and the explanation model in conducting the attack is in O(1). In addition, XSub can be easily extended to launch backdoor attacks in case the attacker has access to the models training data. Our evaluation demonstrates that XSub is not only effective and stealthy but also cost-effective, enabling its application across a wide range of AI models.
Read more9/16/2024