Active Statistical Inference
2403.03208
0
0
Abstract
Inspired by the concept of active learning, we propose active inference$unicode{x2013}$a methodology for statistical inference with machine-learning-assisted data collection. Assuming a budget on the number of labels that can be collected, the methodology uses a machine learning model to identify which data points would be most beneficial to label, thus effectively utilizing the budget. It operates on a simple yet powerful intuition: prioritize the collection of labels for data points where the model exhibits uncertainty, and rely on the model's predictions where it is confident. Active inference constructs provably valid confidence intervals and hypothesis tests while leveraging any black-box machine learning model and handling any data distribution. The key point is that it achieves the same level of accuracy with far fewer samples than existing baselines relying on non-adaptively-collected data. This means that for the same number of collected samples, active inference enables smaller confidence intervals and more powerful p-values. We evaluate active inference on datasets from public opinion research, census analysis, and proteomics.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces "active statistical inference", a framework for adaptive data collection and analysis to improve the efficiency and accuracy of statistical inference.
- The authors propose algorithms for actively selecting data points to sample in order to maximize the information gained about the underlying statistical model.
- The paper covers both Bayesian and frequentist approaches to active inference, demonstrating the benefits of adaptively choosing which data to collect.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a new approach called "active statistical inference" that aims to make the process of statistical analysis more efficient and accurate. Rather than passively collecting a fixed dataset and then analyzing it, the active inference framework allows the analysis to guide the data collection process.
The paper on transductive active learning is an example of active learning, where the model can intelligently select which data points to label in order to improve its performance. Similarly, this paper proposes algorithms that can decide which new data points to sample in order to maximize the information gained about the underlying statistical model.
This active approach can be beneficial in situations where data collection is expensive or time-consuming, as it allows the researcher to focus on collecting the most informative data. The authors demonstrate active inference techniques for both Bayesian and frequentist statistical methods, showing how the adaptive data collection process can lead to better model estimates and inferences.
By actively guiding the data collection process based on the current state of the analysis, this framework has the potential to make statistical inference more efficient and reliable compared to traditional passive data collection.
Technical Explanation
The core idea behind active statistical inference is to adaptively select which data points to sample in order to maximize the information gained about the underlying statistical model. This is in contrast to the traditional approach of passively collecting a fixed dataset and then performing the statistical analysis.
The paper on making better use of unlabeled data with Bayesian active learning provides a relevant example of how active learning can improve model performance. Similarly, this paper explores active inference algorithms for both Bayesian and frequentist statistical frameworks.
For the Bayesian case, the authors propose an acquisition function that selects the next data point to sample in order to maximize the expected reduction in posterior uncertainty. This allows the analysis to focus on collecting the most informative data to refine the model estimates.
In the frequentist setting, the authors develop an active inference algorithm that selects samples to minimize the asymptotic mean squared error of the parameter estimates. This frequentist approach does not require placing a full Bayesian prior on the parameters, and can be applied in a wider range of statistical modeling scenarios.
The paper on classification tree-based active learning demonstrates how active learning can be used to efficiently label data for classification tasks. Similarly, this active inference framework can be applied to a variety of statistical estimation and hypothesis testing problems to improve the efficiency and accuracy of the inferences.
The authors provide theoretical analysis and empirical results showing the benefits of active data collection compared to passive approaches, particularly in settings with limited data or expensive data collection. This work has implications for applications where resource-efficient statistical inference is crucial, such as fair active learning in insurance applications.
Critical Analysis
The active inference framework introduced in this paper represents a promising direction for improving the efficiency and reliability of statistical analysis. By adaptively selecting which data to collect, the method can focus the limited data collection resources on the most informative samples, leading to better model estimates and inferences.
However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research. The theoretical analysis assumes certain regularity conditions on the statistical models, and the empirical demonstrations are limited to relatively simple examples. Extending the active inference approach to more complex, high-dimensional modeling scenarios remains an open challenge.
Additionally, the active data collection process may introduce potential sources of bias if not implemented carefully. The authors briefly discuss this issue, but more work is needed to understand the robustness of active inference methods to various forms of bias and to develop principled techniques for mitigating such concerns.
The paper on non-parametric active learning for choice models highlights the importance of addressing potential biases in active learning settings. Similarly, the active inference framework would benefit from further research on ensuring the reliability and fairness of the resulting statistical inferences.
Overall, this paper presents a compelling new perspective on statistical inference, with promising theoretical and empirical results. However, the practical implementation and widespread adoption of active inference techniques will likely require additional advancements to address the remaining challenges and limitations.
Conclusion
This paper introduces the concept of "active statistical inference", a framework for adaptively collecting data to improve the efficiency and accuracy of statistical analysis. By actively selecting which data points to sample, the method can focus limited data collection resources on the most informative samples, leading to better model estimates and inferences.
The authors demonstrate active inference algorithms for both Bayesian and frequentist statistical settings, showing the potential benefits compared to traditional passive data collection approaches. This work has implications for a variety of applications where resource-efficient statistical inference is crucial, such as fair active learning in insurance applications.
While the active inference framework represents a promising direction, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research. Extending the methods to more complex, high-dimensional modeling scenarios, and addressing potential sources of bias, are important next steps to realize the full potential of this active approach to statistical inference.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Active Preference Inference using Language Models and Probabilistic Reasoning
Wasu Top Piriyakulkij, Volodymyr Kuleshov, Kevin Ellis
0
0
Actively inferring user preferences, for example by asking good questions, is important for any human-facing decision-making system. Active inference allows such systems to adapt and personalize themselves to nuanced individual preferences. To enable this ability for instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs), one may prompt them to ask users questions to infer their preferences, transforming the language models into more robust, interactive systems. However, out of the box, these models are not efficient at extracting preferences: the questions they generate are not informative, requiring a high number of user interactions and impeding the usability of the downstream system. In this work, we introduce an inference-time algorithm that helps LLMs quickly infer preferences by using more informative questions. Our algorithm uses a probabilistic model whose conditional distributions are defined by prompting an LLM, and returns questions that optimize expected entropy and expected model change. Results in a simplified interactive web shopping setting with real product items show that an LLM equipped with our entropy reduction algorithm outperforms baselines with the same underlying LLM on task performance while using fewer user interactions.
6/27/2024
Task-Agnostic Machine Learning-Assisted Inference
Jiacheng Miao, Qiongshi Lu
0
0
Machine learning (ML) is playing an increasingly important role in scientific research. In conjunction with classical statistical approaches, ML-assisted analytical strategies have shown great promise in accelerating research findings. This has also opened up a whole new field of methodological research focusing on integrative approaches that leverage both ML and statistics to tackle data science challenges. One type of study that has quickly gained popularity employs ML to predict unobserved outcomes in massive samples and then uses the predicted outcomes in downstream statistical inference. However, existing methods designed to ensure the validity of this type of post-prediction inference are limited to very basic tasks such as linear regression analysis. This is because any extension of these approaches to new, more sophisticated statistical tasks requires task-specific algebraic derivations and software implementations, which ignores the massive library of existing software tools already developed for complex inference tasks and severely constrains the scope of post-prediction inference in real applications. To address this challenge, we propose a novel statistical framework for task-agnostic ML-assisted inference. It provides a post-prediction inference solution that can be easily plugged into almost any established data analysis routine. It delivers valid and efficient inference that is robust to arbitrary choices of ML models, while allowing nearly all existing analytical frameworks to be incorporated into the analysis of ML-predicted outcomes. Through extensive experiments, we showcase the validity, versatility, and superiority of our method compared to existing approaches.
5/31/2024
Active Inference Meeting Energy-Efficient Control of Parallel and Identical Machines
Yavar Taheri Yeganeh, Mohsen Jafari, Andrea Matta
0
0
We investigate the application of active inference in developing energy-efficient control agents for manufacturing systems. Active inference, rooted in neuroscience, provides a unified probabilistic framework integrating perception, learning, and action, with inherent uncertainty quantification elements. Our study explores deep active inference, an emerging field that combines deep learning with the active inference decision-making framework. Leveraging a deep active inference agent, we focus on controlling parallel and identical machine workstations to enhance energy efficiency. We address challenges posed by the problem's stochastic nature and delayed policy response by introducing tailored enhancements to existing agent architectures. Specifically, we introduce multi-step transition and hybrid horizon methods to mitigate the need for complex planning. Our experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of these enhancements and highlight the potential of the active inference-based approach.
6/14/2024
🌿
Transductive Active Learning: Theory and Applications
Jonas Hubotter, Bhavya Sukhija, Lenart Treven, Yarden As, Andreas Krause
0
0
We generalize active learning to address real-world settings with concrete prediction targets where sampling is restricted to an accessible region of the domain, while prediction targets may lie outside this region. We analyze a family of decision rules that sample adaptively to minimize uncertainty about prediction targets. We are the first to show, under general regularity assumptions, that such decision rules converge uniformly to the smallest possible uncertainty obtainable from the accessible data. We demonstrate their strong sample efficiency in two key applications: Active few-shot fine-tuning of large neural networks and safe Bayesian optimization, where they improve significantly upon the state-of-the-art.
5/24/2024