AgentCoder: Multi-Agent-based Code Generation with Iterative Testing and Optimisation
2312.13010
0
0
Abstract
The advancement of natural language processing (NLP) has been significantly boosted by the development of transformer-based large language models (LLMs). These models have revolutionized NLP tasks, particularly in code generation, aiding developers in creating software with enhanced efficiency. Despite their advancements, challenges in balancing code snippet generation with effective test case generation and execution persist. To address these issues, this paper introduces Multi-Agent Assistant Code Generation (AgentCoder), a novel solution comprising a multi-agent framework with specialized agents: the programmer agent, the test designer agent, and the test executor agent. During the coding procedure, the programmer agent will focus on the code generation and refinement based on the test executor agent's feedback. The test designer agent will generate test cases for the generated code, and the test executor agent will run the code with the test cases and write the feedback to the programmer. This collaborative system ensures robust code generation, surpassing the limitations of single-agent models and traditional methodologies. Our extensive experiments on 9 code generation models and 12 enhancement approaches showcase AgentCoder's superior performance over existing code generation models and prompt engineering techniques across various benchmarks. For example, AgentCoder (GPT-4) achieves 96.3% and 91.8% pass@1 in HumanEval and MBPP datasets with an overall token overhead of 56.9K and 66.3K, while state-of-the-art obtains only 90.2% and 78.9% pass@1 with an overall token overhead of 138.2K and 206.5K.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces "AgentCoder", a multi-agent system for code generation that uses iterative testing and optimization.
- The system employs a team of specialized agents that collaboratively generate, test, and refine code to solve given programming tasks.
- The key ideas behind AgentCoder include using a multi-agent approach, incorporating iterative testing, and optimizing the generated code through competition.
Plain English Explanation
The AgentCoder paper describes a new way to generate computer code using a team of artificial intelligence (AI) agents. Instead of relying on a single AI system, the researchers developed a group of specialized AI agents that work together to create, test, and improve the code.
The agents have different roles, like one agent that generates the initial code, another that tests it, and a third that tries to make the code better. They compete with each other to see who can come up with the best solution. This iterative process of testing and optimization helps the agents create high-quality code that can solve the given programming tasks.
The key idea behind this approach is that by using multiple AI agents with different skills, the system can be more effective at generating code than a single AI model. The agents can learn from each other and collaborate to overcome the limitations of any individual agent. This multi-agent approach, combined with the iterative testing and optimization, allows the system to produce better code than previous methods.
Technical Explanation
The AgentCoder system is a multi-agent architecture for code generation that incorporates iterative testing and optimization. The system consists of several specialized agents, each with a different role in the code generation process.
The first agent is responsible for generating the initial code based on a given programming task. This agent uses a large language model to produce the initial code.
The second agent is the testing agent, which evaluates the code generated by the first agent. It checks the code for correctness, efficiency, and other desired properties. The testing agent provides feedback to the first agent on how the code can be improved.
The third agent is the optimization agent, which takes the feedback from the testing agent and modifies the code to improve its performance. This agent competes with the first agent, trying to generate a better solution to the programming task.
The iterative process of code generation, testing, and optimization continues until a satisfactory solution is found. The competition between the agents encourages them to continuously improve the code, leading to better-quality solutions.
Critical Analysis
The AgentCoder paper presents an innovative approach to code generation, but there are some potential limitations and areas for further research.
One concern is the scalability of the multi-agent system. As the complexity of the programming tasks increases, the number of agents and the coordination required may become unwieldy. The researchers acknowledge this challenge and suggest exploring techniques like hierarchical agent organization to address it.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a thorough analysis of the security and robustness of the generated code. It is essential to ensure that the code produced by the AgentCoder system is not susceptible to vulnerabilities or adversarial attacks, which is an important consideration for real-world applications. Techniques for detecting code generated by language models could be explored to address this concern.
Further research could also investigate ways to enhance the code generation capabilities of large language models and integrate them more effectively into the AgentCoder system, potentially leading to even better-performing code generation.
Conclusion
The AgentCoder paper presents a novel approach to code generation that uses a team of specialized AI agents to collaboratively generate, test, and optimize code. This multi-agent system, with its iterative testing and optimization process, demonstrates the potential for improved code quality and performance compared to traditional approaches.
While the paper highlights several promising aspects of the AgentCoder system, it also identifies areas for further research and improvement, such as addressing scalability challenges and ensuring the security and robustness of the generated code. As the field of AI-assisted code generation continues to evolve, the ideas and techniques introduced in this paper could pave the way for more advanced and reliable code generation systems in the future.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Code Agents are State of the Art Software Testers
Niels Mundler, Mark Niklas Muller, Jingxuan He, Martin Vechev
0
0
Rigorous software testing is crucial for developing and maintaining high-quality code, making automated test generation a promising avenue for both improving software quality and boosting the effectiveness of code generation methods. However, while code generation with Large Language Models (LLMs) is an extraordinarily active research area, test generation remains relatively unexplored. We address this gap and investigate the capability of LLM-based Code Agents for formalizing user issues into test cases. To this end, we propose a novel benchmark based on popular GitHub repositories, containing real-world issues, ground-truth patches, and golden tests. We find that LLMs generally perform surprisingly well at generating relevant test cases with Code Agents designed for code repair exceeding the performance of systems designed specifically for test generation. Further, as test generation is a similar but more structured task than code generation, it allows for a more fine-grained analysis using fail-to-pass rate and coverage metrics, providing a dual metric for analyzing systems designed for code repair. Finally, we find that generated tests are an effective filter for proposed code fixes, doubling the precision of SWE-Agent.
6/21/2024
MapCoder: Multi-Agent Code Generation for Competitive Problem Solving
Md. Ashraful Islam, Mohammed Eunus Ali, Md Rizwan Parvez
0
0
Code synthesis, which requires a deep understanding of complex natural language problem descriptions, generation of code instructions for complex algorithms and data structures, and the successful execution of comprehensive unit tests, presents a significant challenge. While large language models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive proficiency in natural language processing, their performance in code generation tasks remains limited. In this paper, we introduce a new approach to code generation tasks leveraging multi-agent prompting that uniquely replicates the full cycle of program synthesis as observed in human developers. Our framework, MapCoder, consists of four LLM agents specifically designed to emulate the stages of this cycle: recalling relevant examples, planning, code generation, and debugging. After conducting thorough experiments, with multiple LLM ablations and analyses across eight challenging competitive problem-solving and program synthesis benchmarks, MapCoder showcases remarkable code generation capabilities, achieving new state-of-the-art results (pass@1) on HumanEval (93.9%), MBPP (83.1%), APPS (22.0%), CodeContests (28.5%), and xCodeEval (45.3%). Moreover, our method consistently delivers superior performance across various programming languages and varying problem difficulties. We open-source our framework at https://github.com/Md-Ashraful-Pramanik/MapCoder.
5/21/2024
Large Language Models as Test Case Generators: Performance Evaluation and Enhancement
Kefan Li, Yuan Yuan
0
0
Code generation with Large Language Models (LLMs) has been extensively studied and achieved remarkable progress. As a complementary aspect to code generation, test case generation is of crucial importance in ensuring the quality and reliability of code. However, using LLMs as test case generators has been much less explored. Current research along this line primarily focuses on enhancing code generation with assistance from test cases generated by LLMs, while the performance of LLMs in test case generation alone has not been comprehensively examined. To bridge this gap, we conduct extensive experiments to study how well LLMs can generate high-quality test cases. We find that as the problem difficulty increases, state-of-the-art LLMs struggle to generate correct test cases, largely due to their inherent limitations in computation and reasoning. To mitigate this issue, we further propose a multi-agent framework called emph{TestChain} that decouples the generation of test inputs and test outputs. Notably, TestChain uses a ReAct format conversation chain for LLMs to interact with a Python interpreter in order to provide more accurate test outputs. Our results indicate that TestChain outperforms the baseline by a large margin. Particularly, in terms of the accuracy of test cases, TestChain using GPT-4 as the backbone achieves a 13.84% improvement over the baseline on the LeetCode-hard dataset.
4/23/2024
AgileCoder: Dynamic Collaborative Agents for Software Development based on Agile Methodology
Minh Huynh Nguyen, Thang Phan Chau, Phong X. Nguyen, Nghi D. Q. Bui
0
0
Software agents have emerged as promising tools for addressing complex software engineering tasks. However, existing works oversimplify software development workflows by following the waterfall model. Thus, we propose AgileCoder, a multi-agent system that integrates Agile Methodology (AM) into the framework. This system assigns specific AM roles such as Product Manager, Developer, and Tester to different agents, who then collaboratively develop software based on user inputs. AgileCoder enhances development efficiency by organizing work into sprints, focusing on incrementally developing software through sprints. Additionally, we introduce Dynamic Code Graph Generator, a module that creates a Code Dependency Graph dynamically as updates are made to the codebase. This allows agents to better comprehend the codebase, leading to more precise code generation and modifications throughout the software development process. AgileCoder surpasses existing benchmarks, like ChatDev and MetaGPT, establishing a new standard and showcasing the capabilities of multi-agent systems in advanced software engineering environments. Our source code can be found at https://github.com/FSoft-AI4Code/AgileCoder.
6/19/2024