AutoBencher: Creating Salient, Novel, Difficult Datasets for Language Models

Overview

• The paper introduces "AutoBencher," a system for automatically creating challenging datasets for evaluating language models.
• The key goals are to generate datasets that are salient (relevant to real-world needs), novel (not covered by existing benchmarks), and difficult (challenging for current models).
• AutoBencher leverages large language models and human feedback to iteratively refine dataset generation, aiming to push the boundaries of model capabilities.

Plain English Explanation

AutoBencher is a tool that can automatically create new datasets for testing language AI models. The goal is to make these datasets particularly challenging, so that they really push the limits of what current models can do.

The researchers wanted the datasets to be relevant to real-world needs (salient), cover new ground that existing benchmarks don't (novel), and be genuinely difficult for models to perform well on. To achieve this, they used large language models and human feedback in an iterative process to generate and refine the datasets over time.

The idea is that by constantly creating more challenging benchmarks, the research community can drive progress in language AI and uncover new frontiers for model capabilities. This builds on other work in automating dataset updates and understanding benchmark sensitivity.

Technical Explanation

The core of AutoBencher is a dataset generation pipeline that uses large language models to propose novel text samples, which are then filtered and refined based on feedback from human raters. The process iterates, with the model learning to generate increasingly challenging and salient examples over time.

Key steps include:

• Initializing the dataset with a small set of high-quality, manually curated examples
• Using a large language model to propose new candidate examples, conditioned on the existing dataset
• Gathering human ratings on the candidate examples along dimensions like difficulty, novelty, and relevance
• Updating the dataset and fine-tuning the generation model based on the feedback

The researchers experimented with different language models, prompting strategies, and human rating interfaces to optimize the dataset creation process. They also developed techniques to ensure the generated datasets remain diverse and representative, rather than collapsing into narrow or biased subsets.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a compelling vision for advancing the state of language model benchmarking through automated, iterative dataset curation. By focusing on salient, novel, and difficult examples, AutoBencher has the potential to uncover new frontiers for model development.

That said, the approach does rely heavily on human ratings, which could introduce biases or inconsistencies. There are also open questions around how to best integrate AutoBencher with existing benchmark suites, and how to ensure the generated datasets remain representative of real-world language use over time.

Further research is needed to validate the generalizability of the AutoBencher approach, explore ways to reduce human labor, and investigate the long-term impacts on language model progress. Integrating AutoBencher with efforts like BIG-Bench could be a fruitful direction.

Conclusion

The AutoBencher paper introduces an innovative approach for automatically creating challenging datasets to push the boundaries of language model capabilities. By focusing on salience, novelty, and difficulty, the system aims to uncover new frontiers for model development and drive progress in the field of natural language processing.

While there are some open challenges and areas for further research, the core ideas behind AutoBencher represent an important step forward in benchmark curation and could have significant implications for the long-term advancement of language AI systems.