Automated MRI Quality Assessment of Brain T1-weighted MRI in Clinical Data Warehouses: A Transfer Learning Approach Relying on Artefact Simulation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a transfer learning approach for automated quality assessment of brain T1-weighted MRI scans in clinical data warehouses.
- The proposed method uses simulated MRI artefacts to train a deep learning model, which can then be applied to real-world MRI data to detect and classify quality issues.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on a large dataset of clinical MRI scans, showing improved performance compared to traditional quality assessment methods.
Plain English Explanation
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is a widely used medical imaging technique that allows doctors to see detailed images of the brain and other organs. However, the quality of these MRI scans can vary, which can impact the accuracy of medical diagnoses and treatment decisions.
The researchers in this study developed a new artificial intelligence (AI) model to automatically assess the quality of brain MRI scans. Instead of manually checking each scan for quality issues, their AI model can quickly and accurately identify problems like motion blur, artifacts, or other image quality degradations.
The key innovation in this work is the use of simulated MRI artefacts to train the AI model. By creating realistic-looking defects and adding them to high-quality MRI scans, the researchers were able to teach the model to recognize these types of quality issues, even in scans from real patients.
Once trained, the AI model was tested on a large dataset of clinical MRI scans, and it was able to outperform traditional quality assessment methods. This suggests that this approach could be very useful for automatically screening brain MRI scans in hospitals and clinics, helping to ensure that only high-quality images are used for disease diagnosis and treatment planning.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a transfer learning approach for automated quality assessment of brain T1-weighted MRI scans. They first created a dataset of simulated MRI artefacts, such as motion blur and ghosting, by applying various distortions to high-quality MRI images. This simulated artefact dataset was then used to pre-train a deep learning model for MRI quality assessment.
Next, the pre-trained model was fine-tuned on a large dataset of clinical MRI scans from a real-world data warehouse. The model was trained to classify each scan as either "acceptable" quality or having one of several types of quality issues, such as motion artefacts, intensity non-uniformity, or signal dropout.
The researchers evaluated their approach on a held-out test set of clinical MRI scans and compared its performance to traditional quality assessment methods. They found that the transfer learning model achieved significantly higher accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity in detecting quality problems compared to the baseline techniques.
Furthermore, the researchers demonstrated the potential clinical utility of their approach by showing that the model's quality assessments aligned well with expert radiologist evaluations. This suggests that the automated system could be used to triage MRI scans and flag low-quality images for further review, improving the efficiency and reliability of clinical MRI quality control.
Critical Analysis
One key strength of this research is the use of simulated MRI artefacts to pre-train the deep learning model. This approach allowed the researchers to bootstrap the model's learning and improve its ability to recognize real-world quality issues, even with a limited amount of labeled clinical data. However, it's important to note that the simulated artefacts may not fully capture the complexity and variability of quality problems encountered in practice.
Additionally, while the researchers demonstrated the model's performance on a large dataset of clinical MRI scans, the study was limited to a single institution. Further validation on more diverse patient populations and imaging protocols would be necessary to assess the generalizability of the approach. There may also be challenges in deploying such an AI system in clinical settings, such as ensuring robust performance and integrating it seamlessly into existing workflows.
Overall, this research represents an important step towards automated quality control for medical imaging, which could have significant impacts on clinical decision-making and patient outcomes. However, continued development and rigorous testing will be necessary to realize the full potential of this technology.
Conclusion
In this study, the researchers presented a novel transfer learning approach for automated quality assessment of brain T1-weighted MRI scans in clinical data warehouses. By leveraging simulated MRI artefacts to pre-train a deep learning model, they were able to achieve improved performance in detecting and classifying quality issues compared to traditional methods.
The proposed system has the potential to streamline MRI quality control workflows, ensure the reliability of diagnostic imaging data, and ultimately enhance clinical decision-making and patient care. As the use of AI in medical imaging continues to grow, this work represents an important contribution to the field of automated quality assessment for medical imaging.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Automated MRI Quality Assessment of Brain T1-weighted MRI in Clinical Data Warehouses: A Transfer Learning Approach Relying on Artefact Simulation
Sophie Loizillon (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), Simona Bottani (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), St'ephane Mabille (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), Yannick Jacob (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), Aur'elien Maire (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), Sebastian Stroer (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), Didier Dormont (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), Olivier Colliot (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group), Ninon Burgos (for The Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, APPRIMAGE Study Group)
The emergence of clinical data warehouses (CDWs), which contain the medical data of millions of patients, has paved the way for vast data sharing for research. The quality of MRIs gathered in CDWs differs greatly from what is observed in research settings and reflects a certain clinical reality. Consequently, a significant proportion of these images turns out to be unusable due to their poor quality. Given the massive volume of MRIs contained in CDWs, the manual rating of image quality is impossible. Thus, it is necessary to develop an automated solution capable of effectively identifying corrupted images in CDWs. This study presents an innovative transfer learning method for automated quality control of 3D gradient echo T1-weighted brain MRIs within a CDW, leveraging artefact simulation. We first intentionally corrupt images from research datasets by inducing poorer contrast, adding noise and introducing motion artefacts. Subsequently, three artefact-specific models are pre-trained using these corrupted images to detect distinct types of artefacts. Finally, the models are generalised to routine clinical data through a transfer learning technique, utilising 3660 manually annotated images. The overall image quality is inferred from the results of the three models, each designed to detect a specific type of artefact. Our method was validated on an independent test set of 385 3D gradient echo T1-weighted MRIs. Our proposed approach achieved excellent results for the detection of bad quality MRIs, with a balanced accuracy of over 87%, surpassing our previous approach by 3.5 percent points. Additionally, we achieved a satisfactory balanced accuracy of 79% for the detection of moderate quality MRIs, outperforming our previous performance by 5 percent points. Our framework provides a valuable tool for exploiting the potential of MRIs in CDWs.
Read more6/19/2024
0
Non-Reference Quality Assessment for Medical Imaging: Application to Synthetic Brain MRIs
Karl Van Eeden Risager, Torkan Gholamalizadeh, Mostafa Mehdipour Ghazi
Generating high-quality synthetic data is crucial for addressing challenges in medical imaging, such as domain adaptation, data scarcity, and privacy concerns. Existing image quality metrics often rely on reference images, are tailored for group comparisons, or are intended for 2D natural images, limiting their efficacy in complex domains like medical imaging. This study introduces a novel deep learning-based non-reference approach to assess brain MRI quality by training a 3D ResNet. The network is designed to estimate quality across six distinct artifacts commonly encountered in MRI scans. Additionally, a diffusion model is trained on diverse datasets to generate synthetic 3D images of high fidelity. The approach leverages several datasets for training and comprehensive quality assessment, benchmarking against state-of-the-art metrics for real and synthetic images. Results demonstrate superior performance in accurately estimating distortions and reflecting image quality from multiple perspectives. Notably, the method operates without reference images, indicating its applicability for evaluating deep generative models. Besides, the quality scores in the [0, 1] range provide an intuitive assessment of image quality across heterogeneous datasets. Evaluation of generated images offers detailed insights into specific artifacts, guiding strategies for improving generative models to produce high-quality synthetic images. This study presents the first comprehensive method for assessing the quality of real and synthetic 3D medical images in MRI contexts without reliance on reference images.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Rethinking Medical Anomaly Detection in Brain MRI: An Image Quality Assessment Perspective
Zixuan Pan, Jun Xia, Zheyu Yan, Guoyue Xu, Yawen Wu, Zhenge Jia, Jianxu Chen, Yiyu Shi
Reconstruction-based methods, particularly those leveraging autoencoders, have been widely adopted to perform anomaly detection in brain MRI. While most existing works try to improve detection accuracy by proposing new model structures or algorithms, we tackle the problem through image quality assessment, an underexplored perspective in the field. We propose a fusion quality loss function that combines Structural Similarity Index Measure loss with l1 loss, offering a more comprehensive evaluation of reconstruction quality. Additionally, we introduce a data pre-processing strategy that enhances the average intensity ratio (AIR) between normal and abnormal regions, further improving the distinction of anomalies. By fusing the aforementioned two methods, we devise the image quality assessment (IQA) approach. The proposed IQA approach achieves significant improvements (>10%) in terms of Dice coefficient (DICE) and Area Under the Precision-Recall Curve (AUPRC) on the BraTS21 (T2, FLAIR) and MSULB datasets when compared with state-of-the-art methods. These results highlight the importance of invoking the comprehensive image quality assessment in medical anomaly detection and provide a new perspective for future research in this field.
Read more8/16/2024
🤷
0
Statistical Distance-Guided Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Automated Multi-Class Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance Image Quality Assessment
Shahabedin Nabavi, Kian Anvari Hamedani, Mohsen Ebrahimi Moghaddam, Ahmad Ali Abin, Alejandro F. Frangi
This study proposes an attention-based statistical distance-guided unsupervised domain adaptation model for multi-class cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) image quality assessment. The proposed model consists of a feature extractor, a label predictor and a statistical distance estimator. An annotated dataset as the source set and an unlabeled dataset as the target set with different statistical distributions are considered inputs. The statistical distance estimator approximates the Wasserstein distance between the extracted feature vectors from the source and target data in a mini-batch. The label predictor predicts data labels of source data and uses a combinational loss function for training, which includes cross entropy and centre loss functions plus the estimated value of the distance estimator. Four datasets, including imaging and k-space data, were used to evaluate the proposed model in identifying four common CMR imaging artefacts: respiratory and cardiac motions, Gibbs ringing and Aliasing. The results of the extensive experiments showed that the proposed model, both in image and k-space analysis, has an acceptable performance in covering the domain shift between the source and target sets. The model explainability evaluations and the ablation studies confirmed the proper functioning and effectiveness of all the model's modules. The proposed model outperformed the previous studies regarding performance and the number of examined artefacts. The proposed model can be used for CMR post-imaging quality control or in large-scale cohort studies for image and k-space quality assessment due to the appropriate performance in domain shift coverage without a tedious data-labelling process.
Read more9/4/2024