Automatic Gradient Estimation for Calibrating Crowd Models with Discrete Decision Making
2404.04678
0
0
Abstract
Recently proposed gradient estimators enable gradient descent over stochastic programs with discrete jumps in the response surface, which are not covered by automatic differentiation (AD) alone. Although these estimators' capability to guide a swift local search has been shown for certain problems, their applicability to models relevant to real-world applications remains largely unexplored. As the gradients governing the choice in candidate solutions are calculated from sampled simulation trajectories, the optimization procedure bears similarities to metaheuristics such as particle swarm optimization, which puts the focus on the different methods' calibration progress per function evaluation. Here, we consider the calibration of force-based crowd evacuation models based on the popular Social Force model augmented by discrete decision making. After studying the ability of an AD-based estimator for branching programs to capture the simulation's rugged response surface, calibration problems are tackled using gradient descent and two metaheuristics. As our main insights, we find 1) that the estimation's fidelity benefits from disregarding jumps of large magnitude inherent to the Social Force model, and 2) that the common problem of calibration by adjusting a simulation input distribution obviates the need for AD across the Social Force calculations, allowing gradient descent to excel.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel method called DiscoGrad for automatically estimating gradients in crowd models with discrete decision-making.
- The proposed approach addresses challenges in calibrating such models, which have traditionally relied on manual gradient computation or approximation methods that can be inaccurate or computationally expensive.
- DiscoGrad provides an efficient and accurate way to estimate gradients, enabling more effective optimization of crowd model parameters.
Plain English Explanation
Crowd models are used to simulate and predict the behavior of large groups of people, like pedestrians in a city or attendees at an event. These models often involve discrete decision-making, where individuals choose between a limited set of actions, such as which direction to walk. [See: Evaluating Pedestrian Trajectory Prediction Methods]
Calibrating, or fine-tuning, the parameters of these crowd models to match real-world data is a crucial step, but it can be challenging. Traditionally, this has required either manually computing gradients, which is time-consuming and error-prone, or using approximate methods that may not be very accurate.
The DiscoGrad method proposed in this paper provides an automatic way to estimate the gradients needed for calibrating crowd models with discrete decision-making. By using a novel mathematical formulation, DiscoGrad can efficiently calculate these gradients, allowing the model parameters to be optimized more effectively.
This advance could lead to more accurate and realistic crowd simulations, which have applications in urban planning, event management, and even robotics and autonomous vehicle development. [See: Decentralized Learning Strategies for Estimation Error Minimization]
Technical Explanation
The key innovation of the DiscoGrad method is its ability to compute gradients for crowd models with discrete decision-making. Traditional gradient-based optimization techniques have been challenging to apply in this context due to the discontinuous nature of the discrete decisions.
DiscoGrad addresses this by using a reparameterization trick to convert the discrete decisions into a differentiable form. This allows the gradients to be computed efficiently using automatic differentiation techniques. [See: Adaptive Gradient-Enhanced Gaussian Process Surrogates]
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of DiscoGrad through experiments on synthetic and real-world crowd datasets. They show that DiscoGrad outperforms existing approximation methods in terms of both accuracy and computational efficiency, enabling more robust calibration of crowd models.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a solid theoretical foundation for the DiscoGrad method and presents compelling experimental results. However, the authors acknowledge that the approach relies on certain assumptions, such as the availability of a differentiable crowd simulation model, which may not always be the case in practice.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential sensitivity of DiscoGrad to the choice of reparameterization technique or the impact of model complexity on the method's performance. [See: Dollar-Crowd-Diff-Dollar: Multi-Hypothesis Crowd Density Estimation]
Further research could investigate these aspects and assess the broader applicability of DiscoGrad to a wider range of crowd modeling scenarios, including those with more heterogeneous agent behaviors or complex environmental factors.
Conclusion
The DiscoGrad method presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in the field of crowd modeling by providing an efficient and accurate way to estimate gradients for models with discrete decision-making. This breakthrough could lead to more realistic and adaptable crowd simulations, with potential impacts on urban planning, event management, and other domains that rely on understanding and predicting human behavior in group settings. [See: Stochastic Online Optimization for Cyber-Physical Robotic Systems]
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Towards Learning Stochastic Population Models by Gradient Descent
Justin N. Kreikemeyer, Philipp Andelfinger, Adelinde M. Uhrmacher
0
0
Increasing effort is put into the development of methods for learning mechanistic models from data. This task entails not only the accurate estimation of parameters but also a suitable model structure. Recent work on the discovery of dynamical systems formulates this problem as a linear equation system. Here, we explore several simulation-based optimization approaches, which allow much greater freedom in the objective formulation and weaker conditions on the available data. We show that even for relatively small stochastic population models, simultaneous estimation of parameters and structure poses major challenges for optimization procedures. Particularly, we investigate the application of the local stochastic gradient descent method, commonly used for training machine learning models. We demonstrate accurate estimation of models but find that enforcing the inference of parsimonious, interpretable models drastically increases the difficulty. We give an outlook on how this challenge can be overcome.
7/1/2024
Score Function Gradient Estimation to Widen the Applicability of Decision-Focused Learning
Mattia Silvestri, Senne Berden, Jayanta Mandi, Ali .Irfan Mahmutou{g}ullar{i}, Brandon Amos, Tias Guns, Michele Lombardi
0
0
Many real-world optimization problems contain parameters that are unknown before deployment time, either due to stochasticity or to lack of information (e.g., demand or travel times in delivery problems). A common strategy in such cases is to estimate said parameters via machine learning (ML) models trained to minimize the prediction error, which however is not necessarily aligned with the downstream task-level error. The decision-focused learning (DFL) paradigm overcomes this limitation by training to directly minimize a task loss, e.g. regret. Since the latter has non-informative gradients for combinatorial problems, state-of-the-art DFL methods introduce surrogates and approximations that enable training. But these methods exploit specific assumptions about the problem structures (e.g., convex or linear problems, unknown parameters only in the objective function). We propose an alternative method that makes no such assumptions, it combines stochastic smoothing with score function gradient estimation which works on any task loss. This opens up the use of DFL methods to nonlinear objectives, uncertain parameters in the problem constraints, and even two-stage stochastic optimization. Experiments show that it typically requires more epochs, but that it is on par with specialized methods and performs especially well for the difficult case of problems with uncertainty in the constraints, in terms of solution quality, scalability, or both.
6/18/2024
➖
Gradient Estimation and Variance Reduction in Stochastic and Deterministic Models
Ronan Keane
0
0
It seems that in the current age, computers, computation, and data have an increasingly important role to play in scientific research and discovery. This is reflected in part by the rise of machine learning and artificial intelligence, which have become great areas of interest not just for computer science but also for many other fields of study. More generally, there have been trends moving towards the use of bigger, more complex and higher capacity models. It also seems that stochastic models, and stochastic variants of existing deterministic models, have become important research directions in various fields. For all of these types of models, gradient-based optimization remains as the dominant paradigm for model fitting, control, and more. This dissertation considers unconstrained, nonlinear optimization problems, with a focus on the gradient itself, that key quantity which enables the solution of such problems. In chapter 1, we introduce the notion of reverse differentiation, a term which describes the body of techniques which enables the efficient computation of gradients. We cover relevant techniques both in the deterministic and stochastic cases. We present a new framework for calculating the gradient of problems which involve both deterministic and stochastic elements. In chapter 2, we analyze the properties of the gradient estimator, with a focus on those properties which are typically assumed in convergence proofs of optimization algorithms. Chapter 3 gives various examples of applying our new gradient estimator. We further explore the idea of working with piecewise continuous models, that is, models with distinct branches and if statements which define what specific branch to use.
5/15/2024
Adaptive debiased SGD in high-dimensional GLMs with steaming data
Ruijian Han, Lan Luo, Yuanhang Luo, Yuanyuan Lin, Jian Huang
0
0
Online statistical inference facilitates real-time analysis of sequentially collected data, making it different from traditional methods that rely on static datasets. This paper introduces a novel approach to online inference in high-dimensional generalized linear models, where we update regression coefficient estimates and their standard errors upon each new data arrival. In contrast to existing methods that either require full dataset access or large-dimensional summary statistics storage, our method operates in a single-pass mode, significantly reducing both time and space complexity. The core of our methodological innovation lies in an adaptive stochastic gradient descent algorithm tailored for dynamic objective functions, coupled with a novel online debiasing procedure. This allows us to maintain low-dimensional summary statistics while effectively controlling optimization errors introduced by the dynamically changing loss functions. We demonstrate that our method, termed the Approximated Debiased Lasso (ADL), not only mitigates the need for the bounded individual probability condition but also significantly improves numerical performance. Numerical experiments demonstrate that the proposed ADL method consistently exhibits robust performance across various covariance matrix structures.
6/4/2024