Barriers facing e-service adopting and implementation at local environment level in Nigeria

Overview

• The research examines the barriers to adopting and implementing E-Government services at the local government level in developing countries, using Nigeria as a case study.
• It employs an interpretive research paradigm and uses action research methods, including interviews, surveys, focus groups, and document analysis.
• The study is grounded in the diffusion of innovation (DOI) theory and the theory of change.

Plain English Explanation

This research looks at the challenges faced by local governments in developing countries when trying to provide online or digital government services to citizens. It uses Nigeria as an example to understand these issues. The researchers used a variety of methods, including interviews, surveys, and studying government documents, to gather information. They drew on two main theories - the diffusion of innovation theory and the theory of change - to guide their investigation.

The diffusion of innovation theory explains how new technologies and ideas spread through a population, while the theory of change looks at the process of organizational transformation. By combining these frameworks, the researchers aimed to better understand the barriers to successfully implementing digital government services at the local level in developing economies, which often have unstable and fragile economic conditions.

Technical Explanation

The researchers adopted an interpretive paradigm and used an action research methodology for this study. This involved conducting a large field study in Nigeria, which included interviews with government officials, an online survey, online focus groups, and an analysis of government documents and e-service initiatives.

The researchers also carried out a structured literature review, sifting through 3,245 papers to identify the key theoretical frameworks relevant to the study. The main theories used were the diffusion of innovation (DOI) theory and the theory of change.

Critical Analysis

The research acknowledges the lack of existing studies on e-government services at the local government level, particularly in developing countries. This is an important gap to address, as local governments play a crucial role in service delivery and citizen engagement.

The use of a mixed methods approach, combining qualitative and quantitative data, helps to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the barriers to e-service adoption. However, the large scale of the field study in Nigeria may have made it challenging to conduct an in-depth analysis of the contextual factors influencing e-government implementation.

Additionally, the reliance on the diffusion of innovation and theory of change frameworks, while relevant, may have limited the study's ability to uncover unexpected or novel barriers that are specific to the local government context in developing countries. Further research could explore alternative theoretical lenses to broaden the understanding of this complex issue.

Conclusion

This research offers valuable insights into the challenges faced by local governments in developing countries when trying to implement successful e-government services. By using Nigeria as a case study and drawing on established theories, the researchers have identified a range of barriers that need to be addressed, such as limited technological infrastructure, financial constraints, and organizational resistance to change.

These findings have important implications for policymakers and practitioners working to [improve the usability and digitalization of government services in developing countries. Addressing the unique challenges at the local level will be crucial for ensuring that the benefits of e-government are accessible to all citizens, regardless of their geographic location or socioeconomic status.