Cleaning Robots in Public Spaces: A Survey and Proposal for Benchmarking Based on Stakeholders Interviews

Overview

• This paper presents a survey and proposal for benchmarking cleaning robots in public spaces based on interviews with stakeholders.
• The authors conducted interviews with experts in the field to understand the current state of cleaning robots, their challenges, and the needs of different stakeholders.
• The paper proposes a framework for benchmarking cleaning robots in public spaces, taking into account the diverse requirements and perspectives of various stakeholders.

Plain English Explanation

The paper explores the use of cleaning robots in public spaces, such as office buildings, hospitals, and shopping malls. The researchers conducted interviews with experts, including robot manufacturers, cleaning service providers, and facility managers, to get a better understanding of the current state of this technology and the challenges it faces.

Based on these interviews, the researchers propose a framework for benchmarking cleaning robots in public spaces. Benchmarking is the process of evaluating the performance of a product or service against a set of standards or criteria. In this case, the researchers want to develop a way to assess how well cleaning robots perform in real-world public settings, taking into account the needs and concerns of different stakeholders.

The goal of this framework is to help guide the development and deployment of cleaning robots in a way that addresses the diverse requirements of the people and organizations involved, such as building owners, cleaning staff, and the general public. By understanding the different perspectives and priorities of these stakeholders, the researchers hope to create a more comprehensive and effective system for evaluating the performance of cleaning robots in public spaces.

Technical Explanation

The paper starts by reviewing the related research on cleaning robots and the challenges they face in public environments. The authors then describe their methodology for conducting interviews with various stakeholders, including robot manufacturers, cleaning service providers, facility managers, and cleaning staff.

Through these interviews, the researchers identified key requirements and challenges for cleaning robots in public spaces, such as navigation in crowded environments, interaction with building occupants, safety and security concerns, and integration with existing cleaning workflows. The paper presents a detailed analysis of the insights gathered from the stakeholder interviews.

Based on these findings, the authors propose a framework for benchmarking cleaning robots in public spaces. This framework includes a set of performance metrics and test scenarios that can be used to evaluate the robots' capabilities in areas like navigation, object manipulation, and interaction with people. The researchers also discuss the need for standardized data collection and reporting to facilitate the comparison of different cleaning robot systems.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a valuable contribution to the field of cleaning robotics by taking a comprehensive, stakeholder-centric approach to understanding the requirements and challenges in public spaces. The interviews with diverse stakeholders help to reveal the complex and often conflicting needs that must be addressed when deploying cleaning robots in these environments.

One potential limitation of the study is the relatively small sample size of the interviews, which may not fully capture the breadth of perspectives and experiences across different types of public spaces and organizations. Additionally, the paper does not delve into potential privacy concerns that could arise from the use of cleaning robots in public areas, which could be an important consideration for future research.

Overall, the proposed benchmarking framework seems promising, but its effectiveness would need to be validated through real-world deployments and testing. The authors acknowledge the need for further research and collaboration with industry partners to refine and implement this approach.

Conclusion

This paper presents a comprehensive survey and proposal for benchmarking cleaning robots in public spaces, based on in-depth interviews with various stakeholders. The researchers have identified key requirements and challenges facing this technology, and have proposed a framework to guide the development and evaluation of cleaning robots in a way that addresses the diverse needs of building owners, cleaning staff, and the public.

While there are some limitations to the study, the authors have laid the groundwork for a more systematic and inclusive approach to deploying cleaning robots in real-world public environments. This research has the potential to inform the design, testing, and deployment of more effective and user-friendly cleaning robots that can enhance the cleanliness and safety of public spaces.