Field Notes on Deploying Research Robots in Public Spaces

Overview

• Researchers deployed two trash barrel service robots in public spaces in Manhattan and Brooklyn to study human-robot interactions in urban settings.
• This study aims to share insights and lessons learned to benefit researchers and practitioners working on deploying robots in public spaces.
• The researchers call for the HRI community to contribute their own lessons learned to a GitHub repository to encourage more in-the-wild research of robots in public spaces.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers wanted to better understand how people interact with robots in real-world public settings, rather than just in controlled lab environments. To do this, they deployed two robot "trash barrel" systems in public plazas in Manhattan and Brooklyn over the course of 2022 and 2023.

These robots were designed to interact with and assist people in public spaces, like collecting trash. By observing how people reacted to and engaged with the robots in these public settings, the researchers hoped to gain valuable insights that would help guide future development of robots for use in shared public spaces.

The researchers acknowledge that there have been relatively few long-term studies of human-robot interaction in actual public environments. So, by sharing the lessons they learned through this work, they aim to provide a helpful resource for other researchers and practitioners who want to deploy robots in the real world, beyond the lab. They also encourage the broader robotics community to contribute their own experiences and learnings to a shared repository, to further advance this area of research.

Technical Explanation

The researchers deployed two "wizard-of-oz" protocol service robots in public plazas in downtown Manhattan and Brooklyn over the summers of 2022 and 2023. This "wizard-of-oz" approach involves a human operator controlling the robot remotely, rather than the robot operating autonomously. The researchers spent a collective 20 hours observing how people interacted with these robots in these shared public spaces.

This study aimed to address the relative lack of long-term human-robot interaction research conducted in real-world public environments, as opposed to controlled lab settings. By sharing the insights and lessons they learned from this field deployment, the researchers hope to provide guidance and encourage more in-the-wild research of robots in public spaces.

The researchers highlight that deploying robots in public spaces presents unique challenges compared to lab-based robotics research. Issues around safety, legibility, and proactive planning must be carefully considered when bringing robots into shared public environments. The researchers also note the importance of co-designing accessible public robots that can effectively serve diverse user needs.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that their study is limited by the relatively short duration of the deployments (20 hours total) and the use of a "wizard-of-oz" control scheme rather than fully autonomous operation. These factors may have influenced the nature of the human-robot interactions observed.

Additionally, the study was conducted in urban public plazas in Manhattan and Brooklyn, which may not be representative of all potential public spaces where robots could be deployed, such as construction sites or other specialized environments.

Further research would be needed to validate the generalizability of the insights and lessons learned from this specific deployment scenario. Nonetheless, the researchers' call for the broader HRI community to share their own field experiences is a valuable contribution that can help advance the state of research on real-world human-robot interaction.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates the importance of conducting human-robot interaction research in actual public settings, rather than just in controlled lab environments. By deploying service robots in urban public spaces, the researchers were able to gain important insights into the practical challenges and considerations involved in bringing robots into shared human environments.

While the study has some limitations, the researchers' willingness to share their lessons learned is a significant contribution to the field. By encouraging the broader HRI community to contribute their own experiences, the researchers aim to build a valuable resource to guide future efforts in deploying robots in the real world, beyond the confines of the laboratory.