Combining Reconstruction and Contrastive Methods for Multimodal Representations in RL
2302.05342
0
0
❗
Abstract
Learning self-supervised representations using reconstruction or contrastive losses improves performance and sample complexity of image-based and multimodal reinforcement learning (RL). Here, different self-supervised loss functions have distinct advantages and limitations depending on the information density of the underlying sensor modality. Reconstruction provides strong learning signals but is susceptible to distractions and spurious information. While contrastive approaches can ignore those, they may fail to capture all relevant details and can lead to representation collapse. For multimodal RL, this suggests that different modalities should be treated differently based on the amount of distractions in the signal. We propose Contrastive Reconstructive Aggregated representation Learning (CoRAL), a unified framework enabling us to choose the most appropriate self-supervised loss for each sensor modality and allowing the representation to better focus on relevant aspects. We evaluate CoRAL's benefits on a wide range of tasks with images containing distractions or occlusions, a new locomotion suite, and a challenging manipulation suite with visually realistic distractions. Our results show that learning a multimodal representation by combining contrastive and reconstruction-based losses can significantly improve performance and solve tasks that are out of reach for more naive representation learning approaches and other recent baselines.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of self-supervised representation learning to improve the performance and sample efficiency of image-based and multimodal reinforcement learning (RL).
- It compares the advantages and limitations of reconstruction-based and contrastive-based self-supervised learning approaches for different sensor modalities.
- The authors propose a framework called Contrastive Reconstructive Aggregated representation Learning (CoRAL) that combines these two approaches to leverage the strengths of each.
- CoRAL is evaluated on a range of tasks with image-based distractions, a new locomotion suite, and a challenging manipulation suite with visual distractions.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers investigate how to train AI systems to learn useful representations of their environment through self-supervised learning. This means the AI can learn meaningful features of the world around it without the need for labeled training data.
The researchers compare two main approaches to self-supervised learning: reconstruction and contrastive learning. Reconstruction-based methods try to recreate the original input, which provides strong learning signals but can be distracted by irrelevant details. Contrastive learning, on the other hand, tries to distinguish between related and unrelated inputs, which can ignore distractions but may miss important details.
The key insight is that different sensor modalities (e.g., vision, touch) have different levels of information density and distractions. So the researchers propose a framework called CoRAL that allows the AI to choose the most appropriate self-supervised loss function for each modality. This helps the AI focus on the relevant aspects of its environment and learn more efficiently.
The researchers test CoRAL on a variety of challenging tasks, including navigating environments with visual clutter, controlling a robot to walk and manipulate objects in the presence of distractions. The results show that CoRAL significantly outperforms other representation learning approaches, enabling the AI to solve tasks that were previously out of reach.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates how different self-supervised learning approaches, such as reconstruction-based and contrastive losses, can be leveraged to improve the performance and sample efficiency of image-based and multimodal reinforcement learning (RL).
The key observation is that reconstruction-based losses provide strong learning signals but can be distracted by spurious information, while contrastive losses can ignore distractions but may fail to capture all relevant details. This suggests that different sensor modalities, which have varying levels of information density and distractions, should be treated differently.
To address this, the authors propose CoRAL, a unified framework that allows the most appropriate self-supervised loss function to be chosen for each modality. This enables the representation to better focus on the relevant aspects of the environment.
The researchers evaluate CoRAL on a wide range of tasks, including environments with image-based distractions or occlusions, a new locomotion suite, and a challenging manipulation suite with visually realistic distractions. The results show that learning a multimodal representation by combining contrastive and reconstruction-based losses can significantly improve performance and solve tasks that are out of reach for more naive representation learning approaches and other recent baselines, such as semi-supervised and multi-loss gradient modulation techniques.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough investigation into the use of self-supervised representation learning to improve the performance of multimodal RL. The authors acknowledge the limitations of both reconstruction-based and contrastive-based approaches, and their proposed CoRAL framework is a thoughtful attempt to combine the strengths of these two methods.
One potential area for further research could be exploring how the choice of self-supervised loss function for each modality is determined within the CoRAL framework. The paper does not provide details on the criteria or heuristics used to make this decision, which could be an interesting avenue to investigate.
Additionally, while the authors demonstrate the benefits of CoRAL on a range of tasks, it would be valuable to understand how the approach scales to more complex and realistic environments. The manipulation suite used in the experiments, while visually challenging, may not fully capture the nuances and uncertainties of real-world manipulation tasks.
Overall, the paper makes a compelling case for the importance of modality-specific self-supervised representation learning in the context of multimodal RL. The CoRAL framework represents a promising step forward in this direction, and the results suggest it could have a significant impact on the field.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel framework called CoRAL that leverages both reconstruction-based and contrastive-based self-supervised learning approaches to improve the performance and sample efficiency of image-based and multimodal reinforcement learning. By allowing the most appropriate self-supervised loss function to be chosen for each sensor modality, CoRAL helps the AI system focus on the relevant aspects of its environment and learn more effectively.
The researchers demonstrate the benefits of CoRAL on a range of challenging tasks, including navigation in visually cluttered environments, locomotion, and object manipulation with realistic distractions. The results show that this modality-specific approach to self-supervised representation learning can significantly outperform other state-of-the-art techniques, solving tasks that were previously out of reach.
This work highlights the importance of understanding the unique properties of different sensory inputs and tailoring the learning approach accordingly. As AI systems continue to become more sophisticated and interact with increasingly complex environments, techniques like CoRAL will be crucial for enabling them to learn efficient and robust representations of the world around them.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
M2CURL: Sample-Efficient Multimodal Reinforcement Learning via Self-Supervised Representation Learning for Robotic Manipulation
Fotios Lygerakis, Vedant Dave, Elmar Rueckert
0
0
One of the most critical aspects of multimodal Reinforcement Learning (RL) is the effective integration of different observation modalities. Having robust and accurate representations derived from these modalities is key to enhancing the robustness and sample efficiency of RL algorithms. However, learning representations in RL settings for visuotactile data poses significant challenges, particularly due to the high dimensionality of the data and the complexity involved in correlating visual and tactile inputs with the dynamic environment and task objectives. To address these challenges, we propose Multimodal Contrastive Unsupervised Reinforcement Learning (M2CURL). Our approach employs a novel multimodal self-supervised learning technique that learns efficient representations and contributes to faster convergence of RL algorithms. Our method is agnostic to the RL algorithm, thus enabling its integration with any available RL algorithm. We evaluate M2CURL on the Tactile Gym 2 simulator and we show that it significantly enhances the learning efficiency in different manipulation tasks. This is evidenced by faster convergence rates and higher cumulative rewards per episode, compared to standard RL algorithms without our representation learning approach.
6/21/2024
ReconBoost: Boosting Can Achieve Modality Reconcilement
Cong Hua, Qianqian Xu, Shilong Bao, Zhiyong Yang, Qingming Huang
0
0
This paper explores a novel multi-modal alternating learning paradigm pursuing a reconciliation between the exploitation of uni-modal features and the exploration of cross-modal interactions. This is motivated by the fact that current paradigms of multi-modal learning tend to explore multi-modal features simultaneously. The resulting gradient prohibits further exploitation of the features in the weak modality, leading to modality competition, where the dominant modality overpowers the learning process. To address this issue, we study the modality-alternating learning paradigm to achieve reconcilement. Specifically, we propose a new method called ReconBoost to update a fixed modality each time. Herein, the learning objective is dynamically adjusted with a reconcilement regularization against competition with the historical models. By choosing a KL-based reconcilement, we show that the proposed method resembles Friedman's Gradient-Boosting (GB) algorithm, where the updated learner can correct errors made by others and help enhance the overall performance. The major difference with the classic GB is that we only preserve the newest model for each modality to avoid overfitting caused by ensembling strong learners. Furthermore, we propose a memory consolidation scheme and a global rectification scheme to make this strategy more effective. Experiments over six multi-modal benchmarks speak to the efficacy of the method. We release the code at https://github.com/huacong/ReconBoost.
5/16/2024
Semi-supervised Multimodal Representation Learning through a Global Workspace
Benjamin Devillers, L'eopold Mayti'e, Rufin VanRullen
0
0
Recent deep learning models can efficiently combine inputs from different modalities (e.g., images and text) and learn to align their latent representations, or to translate signals from one domain to another (as in image captioning, or text-to-image generation). However, current approaches mainly rely on brute-force supervised training over large multimodal datasets. In contrast, humans (and other animals) can learn useful multimodal representations from only sparse experience with matched cross-modal data. Here we evaluate the capabilities of a neural network architecture inspired by the cognitive notion of a Global Workspace: a shared representation for two (or more) input modalities. Each modality is processed by a specialized system (pretrained on unimodal data, and subsequently frozen). The corresponding latent representations are then encoded to and decoded from a single shared workspace. Importantly, this architecture is amenable to self-supervised training via cycle-consistency: encoding-decoding sequences should approximate the identity function. For various pairings of vision-language modalities and across two datasets of varying complexity, we show that such an architecture can be trained to align and translate between two modalities with very little need for matched data (from 4 to 7 times less than a fully supervised approach). The global workspace representation can be used advantageously for downstream classification tasks and for robust transfer learning. Ablation studies reveal that both the shared workspace and the self-supervised cycle-consistency training are critical to the system's performance.
5/28/2024
🏅
Contrastive UCB: Provably Efficient Contrastive Self-Supervised Learning in Online Reinforcement Learning
Shuang Qiu, Lingxiao Wang, Chenjia Bai, Zhuoran Yang, Zhaoran Wang
0
0
In view of its power in extracting feature representation, contrastive self-supervised learning has been successfully integrated into the practice of (deep) reinforcement learning (RL), leading to efficient policy learning in various applications. Despite its tremendous empirical successes, the understanding of contrastive learning for RL remains elusive. To narrow such a gap, we study how RL can be empowered by contrastive learning in a class of Markov decision processes (MDPs) and Markov games (MGs) with low-rank transitions. For both models, we propose to extract the correct feature representations of the low-rank model by minimizing a contrastive loss. Moreover, under the online setting, we propose novel upper confidence bound (UCB)-type algorithms that incorporate such a contrastive loss with online RL algorithms for MDPs or MGs. We further theoretically prove that our algorithm recovers the true representations and simultaneously achieves sample efficiency in learning the optimal policy and Nash equilibrium in MDPs and MGs. We also provide empirical studies to demonstrate the efficacy of the UCB-based contrastive learning method for RL. To the best of our knowledge, we provide the first provably efficient online RL algorithm that incorporates contrastive learning for representation learning. Our codes are available at https://github.com/Baichenjia/Contrastive-UCB.
4/16/2024