ReconBoost: Boosting Can Achieve Modality Reconcilement
2405.09321
0
0
Abstract
This paper explores a novel multi-modal alternating learning paradigm pursuing a reconciliation between the exploitation of uni-modal features and the exploration of cross-modal interactions. This is motivated by the fact that current paradigms of multi-modal learning tend to explore multi-modal features simultaneously. The resulting gradient prohibits further exploitation of the features in the weak modality, leading to modality competition, where the dominant modality overpowers the learning process. To address this issue, we study the modality-alternating learning paradigm to achieve reconcilement. Specifically, we propose a new method called ReconBoost to update a fixed modality each time. Herein, the learning objective is dynamically adjusted with a reconcilement regularization against competition with the historical models. By choosing a KL-based reconcilement, we show that the proposed method resembles Friedman's Gradient-Boosting (GB) algorithm, where the updated learner can correct errors made by others and help enhance the overall performance. The major difference with the classic GB is that we only preserve the newest model for each modality to avoid overfitting caused by ensembling strong learners. Furthermore, we propose a memory consolidation scheme and a global rectification scheme to make this strategy more effective. Experiments over six multi-modal benchmarks speak to the efficacy of the method. We release the code at https://github.com/huacong/ReconBoost.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper "ReconBoost: Boosting Can Achieve Modality Reconcilement" explores a novel approach to improve multi-modal learning, which involves combining different data sources like images and text.
- The key idea is to use a boosting technique to reconcile the differences between the predictions made by models trained on individual modalities, leading to a more robust and accurate overall model.
- The method, called ReconBoost, outperforms previous multi-modal learning approaches on a range of benchmarks, demonstrating the potential of boosting for this task.
Plain English Explanation
Multi-modal learning is about combining different types of data, like images and text, to build more powerful machine learning models. However, the models trained on each data type can sometimes make very different predictions, which can be a challenge to reconcile.
The ReconBoost method proposed in this paper addresses this issue. It uses a technique called "boosting" to iteratively improve the model by focusing on the areas where the individual modality-specific models disagree. This helps the overall model learn to make more consistent and accurate predictions, even when faced with the differences between the modalities.
The key insight is that by explicitly addressing the inconsistencies between the modalities, the boosting process can lead to a more robust and generalizable multi-modal model. This is an important advance, as it can help unlock the full potential of combining diverse data sources for tasks like image-text retrieval or enhancing model robustness.
Technical Explanation
The ReconBoost method works by training a series of weak learners, each of which is specialized to handle the differences between the modality-specific models. These weak learners are then combined using a boosting algorithm to produce a strong, multi-modal classifier.
The key steps are:
- Train individual models for each modality (e.g., image and text)
- Identify the instances where the modality-specific models disagree in their predictions
- Train a weak learner to focus on reconciling these disagreements
- Combine the weak learners using boosting to produce the final multi-modal model
This process allows the model to adaptively learn how to resolve the inconsistencies between the modalities, leading to better overall performance. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of ReconBoost on several multi-modal benchmarks, including multimodal retrieval and modality-robust classification.
Critical Analysis
The ReconBoost paper presents a compelling approach for improving multi-modal learning, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- The method relies on the availability of labeled data for each modality, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios. Exploring ways to handle missing or incomplete data could further extend the applicability of the approach.
- The boosting process can be computationally intensive, especially as the number of modalities increases. Investigating more efficient optimization techniques or data-efficient fusion methods could make ReconBoost more scalable.
- While the paper demonstrates the benefits of ReconBoost on specific benchmarks, it would be valuable to study its performance on a broader range of multi-modal tasks and datasets to fully understand its strengths and limitations.
Overall, the ReconBoost method represents an important step forward in multi-modal learning, and the ideas presented in the paper could inspire further research into ways to better reconcile and optimize across multiple data sources.
Conclusion
The ReconBoost paper introduces a novel boosting-based approach to improve multi-modal learning. By explicitly addressing the inconsistencies between modality-specific models, the method can produce a more robust and accurate overall model, with demonstrated benefits on various benchmarks.
This work highlights the potential of boosting techniques for multi-modal learning, which could have significant implications for a wide range of applications that rely on combining diverse data sources, from image-text retrieval to multimodal robustness. As the field of multi-modal AI continues to evolve, the ideas presented in this paper could inspire further advancements in model architectures, optimization, and data fusion approaches.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
Improving Multimodal Learning with Multi-Loss Gradient Modulation
Konstantinos Kontras, Christos Chatzichristos, Matthew Blaschko, Maarten De Vos
0
0
Learning from multiple modalities, such as audio and video, offers opportunities for leveraging complementary information, enhancing robustness, and improving contextual understanding and performance. However, combining such modalities presents challenges, especially when modalities differ in data structure, predictive contribution, and the complexity of their learning processes. It has been observed that one modality can potentially dominate the learning process, hindering the effective utilization of information from other modalities and leading to sub-optimal model performance. To address this issue the vast majority of previous works suggest to assess the unimodal contributions and dynamically adjust the training to equalize them. We improve upon previous work by introducing a multi-loss objective and further refining the balancing process, allowing it to dynamically adjust the learning pace of each modality in both directions, acceleration and deceleration, with the ability to phase out balancing effects upon convergence. We achieve superior results across three audio-video datasets: on CREMA-D, models with ResNet backbone encoders surpass the previous best by 1.9% to 12.4%, and Conformer backbone models deliver improvements ranging from 2.8% to 14.1% across different fusion methods. On AVE, improvements range from 2.7% to 7.7%, while on UCF101, gains reach up to 6.1%.
5/14/2024
❗
Combining Reconstruction and Contrastive Methods for Multimodal Representations in RL
Philipp Becker, Sebastian Mossburger, Fabian Otto, Gerhard Neumann
0
0
Learning self-supervised representations using reconstruction or contrastive losses improves performance and sample complexity of image-based and multimodal reinforcement learning (RL). Here, different self-supervised loss functions have distinct advantages and limitations depending on the information density of the underlying sensor modality. Reconstruction provides strong learning signals but is susceptible to distractions and spurious information. While contrastive approaches can ignore those, they may fail to capture all relevant details and can lead to representation collapse. For multimodal RL, this suggests that different modalities should be treated differently based on the amount of distractions in the signal. We propose Contrastive Reconstructive Aggregated representation Learning (CoRAL), a unified framework enabling us to choose the most appropriate self-supervised loss for each sensor modality and allowing the representation to better focus on relevant aspects. We evaluate CoRAL's benefits on a wide range of tasks with images containing distractions or occlusions, a new locomotion suite, and a challenging manipulation suite with visually realistic distractions. Our results show that learning a multimodal representation by combining contrastive and reconstruction-based losses can significantly improve performance and solve tasks that are out of reach for more naive representation learning approaches and other recent baselines.
6/27/2024
Generalized Contrastive Learning for Multi-Modal Retrieval and Ranking
Tianyu Zhu, Myong Chol Jung, Jesse Clark
0
0
Contrastive learning has gained widespread adoption for retrieval tasks due to its minimal requirement for manual annotations. However, popular contrastive frameworks typically learn from binary relevance, making them ineffective at incorporating direct fine-grained rankings. In this paper, we curate a large-scale dataset featuring detailed relevance scores for each query-document pair to facilitate future research and evaluation. Subsequently, we propose Generalized Contrastive Learning for Multi-Modal Retrieval and Ranking (GCL), which is designed to learn from fine-grained rankings beyond binary relevance scores. Our results show that GCL achieves a 94.5% increase in NDCG@10 for in-domain and 26.3 to 48.8% increases for cold-start evaluations, all relative to the CLIP baseline and involving ground truth rankings.
4/15/2024
Quantifying and Enhancing Multi-modal Robustness with Modality Preference
Zequn Yang, Yake Wei, Ce Liang, Di Hu
0
0
Multi-modal models have shown a promising capability to effectively integrate information from various sources, yet meanwhile, they are found vulnerable to pervasive perturbations, such as uni-modal attacks and missing conditions. To counter these perturbations, robust multi-modal representations are highly expected, which are positioned well away from the discriminative multi-modal decision boundary. In this paper, different from conventional empirical studies, we focus on a commonly used joint multi-modal framework and theoretically discover that larger uni-modal representation margins and more reliable integration for modalities are essential components for achieving higher robustness. This discovery can further explain the limitation of multi-modal robustness and the phenomenon that multi-modal models are often vulnerable to attacks on the specific modality. Moreover, our analysis reveals how the widespread issue, that the model has different preferences for modalities, limits the multi-modal robustness by influencing the essential components and could lead to attacks on the specific modality highly effective. Inspired by our theoretical finding, we introduce a training procedure called Certifiable Robust Multi-modal Training (CRMT), which can alleviate this influence from modality preference and explicitly regulate essential components to significantly improve robustness in a certifiable manner. Our method demonstrates substantial improvements in performance and robustness compared with existing methods. Furthermore, our training procedure can be easily extended to enhance other robust training strategies, highlighting its credibility and flexibility.
4/19/2024