Conceptual Learning via Embedding Approximations for Reinforcing Interpretability and Transparency
2406.08840
0
0
Abstract
Concept bottleneck models (CBMs) have emerged as critical tools in domains where interpretability is paramount. These models rely on predefined textual descriptions, referred to as concepts, to inform their decision-making process and offer more accurate reasoning. As a result, the selection of concepts used in the model is of utmost significance. This study proposes underline{textbf{C}}onceptual underline{textbf{L}}earning via underline{textbf{E}}mbedding underline{textbf{A}}pproximations for underline{textbf{R}}einforcing Interpretability and Transparency, abbreviated as CLEAR, a framework for constructing a CBM for image classification. Using score matching and Langevin sampling, we approximate the embedding of concepts within the latent space of a vision-language model (VLM) by learning the scores associated with the joint distribution of images and concepts. A concept selection process is then employed to optimize the similarity between the learned embeddings and the predefined ones. The derived bottleneck offers insights into the CBM's decision-making process, enabling more comprehensive interpretations. Our approach was evaluated through extensive experiments and achieved state-of-the-art performance on various benchmarks. The code for our experiments is available at https://github.com/clearProject/CLEAR/tree/main
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new approach for conceptual learning in machine learning models to improve interpretability and transparency.
- The method uses embedding approximations to learn representations that better align with human-understandable concepts.
- This aims to make the inner workings of the models more interpretable and transparent to users.
Plain English Explanation
The research explores ways to make machine learning models more interpretable and transparent. Often, these models are complex "black boxes" that are difficult for humans to understand. The authors propose a new technique that tries to align the model's internal representations with human-understandable concepts.
The core idea is to use "embedding approximations" - ways of representing information that are easier for people to grasp. For example, rather than just having abstract numerical representations, the model might learn concepts like "dog", "red", or "happy". This makes it clearer how the model is reasoning and arriving at its outputs.
By reinforcing this conceptual learning, the goal is to make the model's decision-making process more transparent. Users can better understand why the model is making certain predictions or recommendations. This improved interpretability could be valuable in high-stakes applications like healthcare or finance, where model decisions need to be explainable.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new approach for "conceptual learning" in machine learning models. The key idea is to use embedding approximations to learn representations that better align with human-understandable concepts, rather than just abstract numerical representations.
The authors propose a model architecture that incorporates a "concept bottleneck" - a layer that forces the model to learn and reason in terms of these higher-level concepts. This is achieved through a combination of techniques:
- Improving Concept Alignment in Vision-Language Models: Aligning the model's internal representations with human-annotated concepts.
- Editable Concept Bottleneck Models: Allowing users to directly edit and manipulate the concept representations.
- Incremental Residual Concept Bottleneck Models: Incrementally building up the concept representations over time.
- Sparse Concept Bottleneck Models with Gumbel Tricks & Contrastive Learning: Encouraging sparse and disentangled concept representations.
- Improving Intervention Efficacy via Concept Realignment: Realigning the concept representations to improve the model's performance on certain tasks.
Through a series of experiments, the authors demonstrate that this conceptual learning approach can improve the interpretability and transparency of the models, while maintaining strong performance on various tasks.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for enhancing the interpretability and transparency of machine learning models. By aligning the internal representations with human-understandable concepts, the authors aim to make the models' decision-making processes more explainable.
One potential limitation is the reliance on pre-defined concept annotations. While this allows for direct supervision of the conceptual learning, it may be challenging to scale to a wide range of domains and applications. An interesting avenue for future research could be exploring unsupervised or semi-supervised methods for discovering relevant concepts.
Additionally, the authors acknowledge that the concept bottleneck architecture may come at the cost of some performance on the primary task. Further research is needed to understand the optimal balance between interpretability and task performance, and how to best optimize the tradeoffs.
Overall, the techniques proposed in this paper represent an important step towards more transparent and explainable machine learning systems. As these models become increasingly deployed in high-stakes applications, such advancements in interpretability will be crucial for building trust and ensuring responsible use of the technology.
Conclusion
The paper presents a novel approach for conceptual learning in machine learning models, with the goal of enhancing their interpretability and transparency. By aligning the internal representations with human-understandable concepts, the authors aim to make the models' decision-making processes more accessible and explainable to users.
Through a series of technical innovations, such as the concept bottleneck architecture and various concept learning techniques, the researchers demonstrate promising results in improving the interpretability of the models while maintaining strong performance on various tasks.
This work represents an important step towards more transparent and accountable machine learning systems, which will be crucial as these models are increasingly deployed in high-impact domains. Further research is needed to address the potential limitations and optimize the tradeoffs between interpretability and task performance, but the conceptual learning approach outlined in this paper holds significant promise for the future of artificial intelligence.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Improving Concept Alignment in Vision-Language Concept Bottleneck Models
Nithish Muthuchamy Selvaraj, Xiaobao Guo, Bingquan Shen, Adams Wai-Kin Kong, Alex Kot
0
0
Concept Bottleneck Models (CBM) map the input image to a high-level human-understandable concept space and then make class predictions based on these concepts. Recent approaches automate the construction of CBM by prompting Large Language Models (LLM) to generate text concepts and then use Vision Language Models (VLM) to obtain concept scores to train a CBM. However, it is desired to build CBMs with concepts defined by human experts instead of LLM generated concepts to make them more trustworthy. In this work, we take a closer inspection on the faithfulness of VLM concept scores for such expert-defined concepts in domains like fine-grain bird species classification and animal classification. Our investigations reveal that frozen VLMs, like CLIP, struggle to correctly associate a concept to the corresponding visual input despite achieving a high classification performance. To address this, we propose a novel Contrastive Semi-Supervised (CSS) learning method which uses a few labeled concept examples to improve concept alignment (activate truthful visual concepts) in CLIP model. Extensive experiments on three benchmark datasets show that our approach substantially increases the concept accuracy and classification accuracy, yet requires only a fraction of the human-annotated concept labels. To further improve the classification performance, we also introduce a new class-level intervention procedure for fine-grain classification problems that identifies the confounding classes and intervenes their concept space to reduce errors.
5/6/2024
🌿
Coarse-to-Fine Concept Bottleneck Models
Konstantinos P. Panousis, Dino Ienco, Diego Marcos
0
0
Deep learning algorithms have recently gained significant attention due to their impressive performance. However, their high complexity and un-interpretable mode of operation hinders their confident deployment in real-world safety-critical tasks. This work targets ante hoc interpretability, and specifically Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs). Our goal is to design a framework that admits a highly interpretable decision making process with respect to human understandable concepts, on two levels of granularity. To this end, we propose a novel two-level concept discovery formulation leveraging: (i) recent advances in vision-language models, and (ii) an innovative formulation for coarse-to-fine concept selection via data-driven and sparsity-inducing Bayesian arguments. Within this framework, concept information does not solely rely on the similarity between the whole image and general unstructured concepts; instead, we introduce the notion of concept hierarchy to uncover and exploit more granular concept information residing in patch-specific regions of the image scene. As we experimentally show, the proposed construction not only outperforms recent CBM approaches, but also yields a principled framework towards interpetability.
6/28/2024
Editable Concept Bottleneck Models
Lijie Hu, Chenyang Ren, Zhengyu Hu, Cheng-Long Wang, Di Wang
0
0
Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs) have garnered much attention for their ability to elucidate the prediction process through a human-understandable concept layer. However, most previous studies focused on cases where the data, including concepts, are clean. In many scenarios, we always need to remove/insert some training data or new concepts from trained CBMs due to different reasons, such as privacy concerns, data mislabelling, spurious concepts, and concept annotation errors. Thus, the challenge of deriving efficient editable CBMs without retraining from scratch persists, particularly in large-scale applications. To address these challenges, we propose Editable Concept Bottleneck Models (ECBMs). Specifically, ECBMs support three different levels of data removal: concept-label-level, concept-level, and data-level. ECBMs enjoy mathematically rigorous closed-form approximations derived from influence functions that obviate the need for re-training. Experimental results demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of our ECBMs, affirming their adaptability within the realm of CBMs.
5/27/2024
Evidential Concept Embedding Models: Towards Reliable Concept Explanations for Skin Disease Diagnosis
Yibo Gao, Zheyao Gao, Xin Gao, Yuanye Liu, Bomin Wang, Xiahai Zhuang
0
0
Due to the high stakes in medical decision-making, there is a compelling demand for interpretable deep learning methods in medical image analysis. Concept Bottleneck Models (CBM) have emerged as an active interpretable framework incorporating human-interpretable concepts into decision-making. However, their concept predictions may lack reliability when applied to clinical diagnosis, impeding concept explanations' quality. To address this, we propose an evidential Concept Embedding Model (evi-CEM), which employs evidential learning to model the concept uncertainty. Additionally, we offer to leverage the concept uncertainty to rectify concept misalignments that arise when training CBMs using vision-language models without complete concept supervision. With the proposed methods, we can enhance concept explanations' reliability for both supervised and label-efficient settings. Furthermore, we introduce concept uncertainty for effective test-time intervention. Our evaluation demonstrates that evi-CEM achieves superior performance in terms of concept prediction, and the proposed concept rectification effectively mitigates concept misalignments for label-efficient training. Our code is available at https://github.com/obiyoag/evi-CEM.
6/28/2024